Will you tell the truth? Or will someone tell it for you? The answer can make all the difference in the world.

"As Above, So Below" is the ninth episode of Volume 7 and the eighty-eighth episode of RWBY. It premiered for Rooster Teeth FIRST members on January 4th, 2020 and was made public on the Rooster Teeth site on January 11th, 2020.


In Mantle, with the heat disabled, Pietro Polendina opens his shop as a shelter.

At Schnee Manor, Sleet and Camilla call James Ironwood out for his broad use of the power of his two Council seats. A Faunus waiter whispers in Jacques Schnee's ear that something is happening with his authorization, which shocks him; when the others at the table ask what was said, he deflects, concurring with Sleet and Camilla. Robyn Hill asks what Ironwood is hiding and asks him to submit to her Semblance, only to be interrupted by Weiss Schnee, who shows those assembled footage from Willow Schnee's cameras of Jacques meeting with Arthur Watts, in which Jacques gives Watts his credentials in exchange for manipulating the election. Jacques tries to run, but his exit is blocked by Weiss' Arma Gigas, and Weiss places him under arrest.

The people of Mantle riot, stealing Dust crystals for a bonfire. As those assembled in Schnee Manor enumerate Jacques' crimes, including the murders at Robyn's rally, they receive messages informing them of the crisis in Mantle. Jacques' response makes clear he was already aware, and Winter Schnee demands he restore the heat, to which he responds that he has been locked out of the system. As Ironwood tries to track and contain Watts, noting that Amity remains safe, Robyn interrupts to again ask what Ironwood is hiding, this time openly referring to Amity Communications Tower.

In Mantle, the riots attract Grimm. Clover Ebi and Oscar Pine interrupt Robyn's questioning of Ironwood to request ground support; Robyn insists they evacuate Mantle instead, but Ironwood objects this would leave Atlas vulnerable. Oscar reminds Ironwood of having asked his advice, and pushes him to tell the truth; Ironwood agrees to brief Robyn, Sleet, and Camilla. Oscar and Ruby Rose decide to tell Ironwood about Jinn's revelation. As Camilla and Sleet discuss Ironwood's claims, with Robyn thinking silently, Oscar tells Ironwood the truth in private. Ironwood, stunned, opts to focus on the present danger to Mantle. Oscar compliments him on living up to the ideals behind Atlas' raising, to which Ironwood responds he sounds as though he'd been there.

Ruby's Group (bar Oscar) and the Ace Operatives deploy to Mantle in an airship that a Teryx destroys, forcing all to eject. As Jacques is taken into custody, Neopolitan, disguised as a waitress, skips off to a suite shared with Cinder Fall.


Snow continues to fall from the night sky over Mantle, collecting on roads, sidewalks and rooftops. Pietro Polendina and Maria Calavera stand outside Pietro's clinic with the door open, allowing civilians to take shelter inside.

Woman: What's going on? Is the heat off in Atlas too?

Man: They wouldn't just turn the heat off…

Pietro and Maria look at each other.

Man: ...Would they?

Maria and Pietro look up at the City of Atlas, the underside of which is still lit up cyan and purple.

Inside the dining room of the Schnee Manor, the Atlas councilmen continue to talk to James Ironwood.

Camilla: General, since the day you were appointed Headmaster, there have been Atlesians who are skeptical of one man holding two Council seats.

Ironwood: Yes, which is exactly why we have checks and balances.

Sleet: We're supposed to, but lately you've been running roughshod all over them, making unilateral decisions without us.

Ironwood: Councilman, I never intended--

Sleet: What people intend and what they do aren't always the same, General.

A butler walks into the room, stops at Jacques Schnee's side, and whispers to him.

Jacques: Hm? (hushed) What? For how long?

The butler whispers again. Jacques' eyes widen.

Jacques: (hushed) My authorization? Check it again!

The butler hurries out of the room, and Councilman Sleet looks at Jacques.

Sleet: Councilman Schnee?

Jacques tenses. As he speaks, he adjusts his tie and gestures awkwardly.

Jacques: Um... (clears throat) Yes, I, uh… agree with everything, everything that was, uh, just said. No, uh, no further questions.

He quiets down, collecting himself, and Sleet, Camilla and Robyn Hill stare at him for a moment.

Robyn: (turning to Ironwood) I'm not quite done yet. You're afraid of something, General. Aren't you?

Ironwood: I think that's pretty obvious, Miss Hill. I'm trying to prevent Atlas from becoming another Beacon, another Haven.

While Robyn speaks, Jacques does not appear to be paying close attention. Instead, he clasps his hands in front of his face, then puts his left hand to his face.

Robyn: Yet, you don't trust your own Council to help you? Operating in secret? These are the actions of somebody who's hiding something.

Ironwood: I'm not hiding anything.

Robyn: Let's put it to the test then.

Robyn stands up, and Jacques lowers his hand from his face and watches as she approaches Ironwood.

Robyn: You're all aware of my Semblance. Let's settle it here and now, General Ironwood.

She stands next to Ironwood and holds her hand out to him. He looks at her hand, then at the councilmen.

Robyn: Here and now.

He looks at her hand again, but before he can do anything, the double doors on the other end of the room noisily swing open.

Weiss: Wait!

Everyone looks toward the door, and Robyn gains a slightly annoyed expression. Weiss is standing in the doorway, holding the doors open.

Weiss: You've got the wrong man on trial.

She walks into the room and stops next to Jacques.

Weiss: I know who's been framing Ironwood, who rigged the election. And my father does, too. He's been working with him.

Jacques looks nervous, and Weiss sets the Scroll that Willow Schnee gave her on the table and taps the screen, causing it to project a hologram screen into the air. The screen depicts a paused video of Jacques and Arthur Watts in Jacques' office.

Camilla: Is that... Arthur Watts?

Sleet stands up.

Sleet: That's impossible! Dr. Watts died in the Paladin Incident years ago.

Jacques: Wha-- W-w-what is this?

Ironwood stands up.

Ironwood: Play it.

Weiss taps the play button on the Scroll, and the floating screen begins playing the video. As it plays, Jacques becomes more and more nervous, fidgeting with his hands and then his mustache, sweat quickly appearing on his brow.

Jacques: (in the video) That bastard is costing me more money every day with this embargo. I'd lay off every employee in Mantle if I wasn't trying to get their damn votes for this Council seat!

Watts: What if I said you could have your cake and eat it, too?

Jacques: (in the video) What did you have in mind?

Watts: James Ironwood never recognized my genius. After everything I gave him, he still disgraced me. I simply wish to return the favor.

Sleet watches the video in stunned silence and sits back down. Ironwood begins walking across the room toward Jacques.

Jacques: (in the video) What's in it for me?

Watts: A seat on the council. All I need is your login credentials for the Atlas network.

Winter Schnee narrows her eyes and subtly shakes her head disapprovingly.

Watts: You promise to make Ironwood's life a waking nightmare, and I will guarantee you victory at the polls by giving the voters down in Mantle a little… "digital push", if you will.

Robyn watches with widened eyes, then grips a nearby chair and narrows her eyes angrily.

Jacques: (in the video) I always knew you were a good scientist, Arthur... but I never knew you were such a good salesman.

Ironwood comes to a stop near Weiss.

Ironwood: Enough.

In the video, Jacques cackles, and Weiss taps the Scroll's screen, pausing the video and making the floating screen disappear.

Jacques: (stammering) That, that is-- I--

Jacques quickly stands and moves next to his chair, putting his hands up.

Jacques: (stammering) I can explain that. (clears throat) That… isn't real.

Sleet: (angrily) Jacques, take your seat.

There is a brief pause before Jacques frantically runs for the double doors behind him. He swings the doors open, only to stumble backward at the sight of an Arma Gigas summon. He sputters a little, then turns and looks at Weiss.

Jacques: Weiss

Weiss: Jacques Schnee, you're under arrest.

Weiss withdraws her Scroll and displays her Huntress license to him with a very serious expression. A few moments pass, and she looks over her shoulder at Ironwood.

Weiss: Can I do that?

In Mantle, people have begun shouting, and someone in the crowd screams "I hate you!" Paying no mind to the commotion, Watts catches a snowflake in his palm and then crushes it.

Someone breaks glass nearby, and he turns to look. A man has shattered the front window of a shop called Dust in the Wind. On the other side of the window is a display of very large Dust crystals and a pair of small signs. The sign on the left, sitting above a tray of purple Dust crystals, says "Sale on Gravity Dust". The sign on the right says "Premium Dust XL". The man grabs two Fire Dust crystals.

The citizens have started a bonfire in the street and are throwing wooden furniture into the fire. The man who looted the Dust shop runs over with his Dust crystals.

Woman: Atlas killed the heat on purpose!

Man: They'll do anything to control us.

Drinking Buddy and Drunk Mann stand back and watch their fellow citizens, and the looter tosses one of the crystals into the fire. There is a small sound as the crystal enters the flames, and the fire briefly bursts outward, growing taller and brighter.

A pair of Atlas soldiers watch from down the road, and one of them activates her communicator.

Soldier: The situation here is getting out of control. Please advise.

Further down that same road, Watts stands around the corner of a building, peeking out at the Atlas soldiers. Behind him, Tyrian Callows drops down from somewhere above and chuckles.

In the Schnee Manor dining room, Jacques is sitting in a chair on the side of the room, with Winter, Ironwood, the councilmen, Robyn and Clover Ebi standing around him. Team RWBY and Penny Polendina are standing together at the end of the room. Clover receives contact on his communicator and puts his fingers to it, listening.

Ironwood: I knew you'd stoop low to get what you wanted, Jacques. But this?

Clover glances at Ironwood and then walks out of the room, continuing to listen to his communicator.

Jacques: This is all a great leap, James.

Ironwood: No, it's quite simple really -- now that I know Arthur Watts is alive. Working with a madman like Tyrian Callows, it would be easy for someone like him to coordinate an unthinkably heinous act like the one in that warehouse. Watts designed Mantle's entire security network. He used that access to hack the surveillance system and frame someone else for the job.

Everyone but Jacques looks at Penny, who looks away sadly. Ruby places her hand on Penny's shoulder. Ironwood looks at Jacques again.

Ironwood: All while stealing an election.

Ironwood moves closer to Jacques, who becomes nervous.

Ironwood: And once you became a Councilman, your newly granted clearance gave him a (slamming his hands onto the chair's arms) backdoor into Atlas' secure network. But you probably hadn't even considered that, had you?

Robyn: The people that died that night, their blood is on your hands.

Sleet: Jacques Schnee must be tried, not only for treason, but as an accesory to murder.

Jacques: These are outrageous accusations! I only intended to win the election. I had nothing to do--

Robyn: Only?!

Enraged, Robyn grabs the nearest chair and slams it into the wall. Penny puts her hand to her lips, and Jacques, Ironwood, Winter and the councilmen look at Robyn. Ironwood straightens up.

Camilla: What else will he be able to do with the access Jacques' given him?

Ironwood: With enough time… whatever he wants.

Jacques, Camilla, Sleet and Ironwood's Scrolls all buzz and ping, with Jacques' Scroll lighting up the pocket of his coat. The sudden noise and sensation causes Jacques to jump in fright. Ironwood, Camilla and Sleet withdraw their Scrolls. Camilla deploys her Scroll's screen, which displays an emergency alert, and Sleet answers a call on his.

Sleet: Wait… wait, what? What do you mean the heat has gone off?

Weiss gasps and puts her hand to her lips. Blake Belladonna looks worried, and Yang Xiao Long looks somewhat angry.

Jacques: You have to believe me, I-I-I didn't know he was planning this.

Winter slams her hands down on the arm of Jacques' chair, and he flinches away from her.

Winter: You are going to shut your mouth and get the heating grid up and running again.

Jacques: I… I've been informed that we can't get into the system. It's… it's been blocked off.

Ironwood has been staring at the alert on his Scroll's screen, which says "! Emergency Alert !" and "Atlas Council Security Notification". He lowers his Scroll and turns away, while Robyn walks over to a window and places her hand on it, looking outside.

Sleet: Without heat down there... people are going to die.

Penny and Ruby look at each other worriedly. Ironwood has his hand to his jaw, covering his lips. Ruby walks over to him.

Ruby: General Ironwood? How bad is it?

Ironwood types something into his Scroll and then scrolls through things, one being a screen that displays a shape similar to the Amity Communications Tower.

Ironwood: He's using Jacques' credentials. We can follow that activity on the network. If he's found his way into the Amity system…

Robyn turns her head and looks at Ironwood.

Ironwood: No, the secret is safe. For now. But if he learns about Amity, she learns about Amity.

While he speaks, Ironwood walks past Ruby and Robyn, both of whom watch him.

Weiss: Can you block his access?

He walks past Weiss, Blake and Yang, swiping through pages that keep bringing up an "Access Denied" alert.

Ironwood: It's too late. He's already starting to lock us out.

Blake: Can we trace him somehow? Find out where he's hiding?

Ironwood: He's going to be mobile. We need his access point. We need to get him out in the open.

Robyn: Okay, so let me get this straight.

Ironwood stops, and he, Blake, Yang, Weiss and Penny look at Robyn. She holds up her hand and then does a finger gun gesture as she speaks.

Robyn: Yep, still here everyone.

Robyn resumes a serious expression and walks toward Ironwood.

Robyn: How do a disgraced scientist and disappeared serial killer find each other, General? Why would they target you? And why are you working so hard to hide the Amity Communications Tower from them?

Ironwood: (surprised) You know?

In Mantle, an even larger crowd has begun to gather around the bonfire, with more people running toward it. Pietro and Maria exit the clinic and watch worriedly.

AK-200: Citizens, please disperse. For your own safety, please disperse.

Five Atlesian Knight-200s approach some of the civilians and then stand still.

AK-200: For your own safety, please--

A pair of civilians wielding metal pipes suddenly attack the front to AK-200s and begin beating the fallen robots with the pipes. Nearby, Pietro watches, horrified. The Grimm sirens begin going off, and the street lamps turn red. A large herd of Megoliaths are charging toward a break in Mantle's wall. A group of Mantas fly toward the herd.

Pilot: Atlas, Manta Team Delta -- beginning first run.

One of the Mantas fires a barrage of missiles at the Megoliaths, but the Grimm appear to be unaffected. The Mantas continue firing missiles at the Megoliaths, while a small group of Sabyrs run ahead and attack the AK-200s guarding the hole in the wall, quickly knocking the robots down. A pair of Atlas soldiers are stationed atop the wall, firing at Grimm that approach it, and they watch the Sabyrs run through the streets. The soldiers hear a screeching noise, look back, and then duck down and cover their heads as a Teryx flies overhead.

Robyn stands face to face with Ironwood.

Robyn: I used to think you were hiding something to protect yourself. But I can tell there's something much bigger going on here. Now I think it's to protect something else. Us… Atlas, maybe even all of Remnant. And you're afraid of what might happen if you tell the truth.

Ironwood frowns. The double doors on the other end of the room swing open, with Clover and Oscar Pine on the other side.

Clover: General, the Grimm are all over Mantle.

Clover and Oscar hurry across the room to stand near Ironwood.

Clover: The air fleet's doing everything they can, but they can't easily target Grimm in the city without risking casualties.

Ironwood: This... this is what I was afraid would happen.

Ironwood puts his hand to his jaw and walks away.

Clover: Sir, we need ground support now.

Robyn: What we need is to start evacuating Mantle. If it's completely overrun, it's not going to be safe anywhere. Use the fleet to get--

Ironwood: If I move the fleet, then Atlas is vulnerable. I… I tried to keep the kingdom safe. And now we're losing everything.

Ironwood places his right hand on the wall and leans on that arm, covering his face with his left hand. Oscar approaches him, resting his hand on the Relic of Knowledge.

Oscar: General? Earlier, you asked for my advice.

Ironwood: I wanted Ozpin's advice.

Oscar: And his advice probably would've been to keep your secrets. When we first got here, you already knew that wasn't the right course. You had a new plan.

Ironwood: It's time to give up on that plan.

Ironwood straightens up, lowering his hand from his face.

Ironwood: It's all falling apart.

Oscar: The panic you were worried about? It's already happening. The secrets you're keeping? They're about to be in the open anyway. It's time.

Ironwood turns and looks at Oscar.

Oscar: Tell the truth.

Ruby: You're not alone.

Ironwood looks over to see that Ruby has approached him with an encouraging smile.

Ruby: We can do this together.

Ironwood nods and smiles.

Ironwood: Thank you. Oscar, I think it's time you get back to the Academy.

Oscar: I think you're right.

Oscar rests his hand on the Relic again. While Ironwood speaks, Winter brings out her Scroll and starts using it, heading over to him.

Ironwood: Miss Hill, Councilman Sleet, Councilwoman Camilla, there are some things you need to know about. Let's figure out how we can help Mantle… together.

Winter holds up her Scroll, with "Transport Authorized" displayed at the top of the screen.

Winter: I've called a transport.

Yang: What about Watts and Tyrian?

Ironwood: You leave them to me. Right now, you're needed down below.

Ruby steps toward the others and poses with her hands on her hips, while Winter watches, smiling.

Ruby: Alright everybody, it's time to do our jobs. All of us.

Weiss, Blake and Yang look at Penny, who smiles.

Clover: What she said. Let's make it happen, Huntsmen.

Clover heads out of the room with Team RWBY, Penny, Oscar and Winter following him. In the hallway, the group passes by the dark-haired waitress who had been serving the council earlier that night. As she watches them go, she narrows her dark green eyes and smirks.

The last remaining party guests run out the manor's front door, which Marrow Amin is holding open. Jaune Arc, Nora Valkyrie and Lie Ren head outside, as well. In the foyer, Ruby runs to catch up with Oscar.

Ruby: Oscar?

Oscar turns to face Ruby, who nearly bumps into him.

Ruby and Oscar: I--

The two awkwardly interrupt and speak over each other.

Ruby: Oh. (awkward laugh)

Oscar: Oh, you first.

Ruby: Sorry. I didn't meant to interrupt--

Oscar: You didn't, actually.

Ruby: Um... I just wanted to say uh--

Oscar: I had thought that maybe--

Both: We should tell Ironwood.

The two laugh awkwardly while Ruby's teammates run past.

Ruby: Well, uh… (awkward laugh) I guess we're on the same page, huh?

Oscar: Guess so. He's finally choosing the truth over fear. We should do the same.

Ruby: I'll tell him. I'm the one who chose to keep it from him in the first place.

Marrow: Ruby! Transport's leaving.

Marrow points out the door with his thumb, and Ruby waves her hands to him.

Oscar: I think you're needed elsewhere.

Oscar starts heading to the dining room.

Ruby: You're sure?

Oscar: Yeah, I've got it.

He gives her a thumbs up and continues on his way, and she heads to the front door. They both stop and turn to each other, once again accidentally speaking over each other.

Ruby: Good luck in there.

Oscar: Good luck down there.

They laugh awkwardly, and Ruby does a finger gun gesture at him with both hands before running out the door.

Marrow: Ugh, kids.

Marrow walks out the door.

Team RWBY, Team JNPR, Qrow Branwen and the Ace Operatives fly toward Mantle aboard a Manta that is being piloted by Harriet Bree. Clover looks out the windshield, then turns around to address everyone sitting in the passenger area in the back.

Clover: Alright, everyone. I need to stress to our new Huntsmen and Huntresses, we are prioritizing citizen safety over killing Grimm. Got it?

Teams RWBY and JNPR nod their heads in acknowledgement. Nora looks at Ren, who has his head turned away and his eyes closed. She sets her hand on top of his and grips it, and he curls his fingers to grip her fingertips. They look at each other and then look down. Yang watches them. Blake looks at Yang, who looks back at her, then turns her eyes away and smiles.

High in the air, a Teryx trails the Manta, uttering a small screech.

Sleet, Camilla and Robyn stand out in the hallway in the Schnee Manor.

Sleet: She can control Grimm?

Camilla: Ironwood wouldn't lie about something like this.

Sleet: Do you really think he can stop her?

Robyn looks at the door.

Inside the dining room, Ironwood is sitting at the table with a stunned expression. Oscar is sitting to his right.

Ironwood: She… can't be killed. Jinn told you this?

Oscar: She showed us when we asked what Oz was hiding.

Ironwood: (distraught) Why? Why would Oz keep this from us? From the people who trusted him?

Oscar: He was worried you would lose hope.

Ironwood turns away a little, resting his hand over his mouth.

Oscar: We're sorry we kept it from you, too. We didn't know who to trust. I figured you should know before you make any… sacrifices.

They sit in silence for a couple of seconds.

Oscar: Sir? What are you gonna do?

Ironwood lowers his hand from his face, uncertain at first.

Ironwood: I… (collects himself) All we can do for the moment is what we can to save Mantle. That's what's in front of us.

Oscar: (smiling) He'd be proud of you. You're bringing the hope that Atlas was meant to inspire. A city in the sky is held to a higher standard.

Ironwood: You say that... like you were ther--

Ironwood's Scroll, which is sitting on the table, beeps. He taps the screen.

Ironwood: Our transports are here. We should move.

Oscar nods, stands up and heads for the door. As soon as his back is turned to Ironwood, his smile turns into a frown.

Ironwood: Oscar.

Ironwood pushes his chair away from the table and turns it sideways so he can look at Oscar.

Ironwood: No more surprises, all right? I'm not sure I could take it.

Oscar, having turned to face Ironwood, smiles a little.

Oscar: You and me both.

In the skies above Mantle, a Teryx lands on the front end of the Ace-Ops' Manta and looks through the windshield. It roars and spreads its wings. Marrow looks into the back of the ship.

Marrow: Hang on!

Jaune, Nora, Ren, Blake and Yang have buckled their seatbelts. Jaune is leaning on his sword with his eyes closed in concentration. Elm Ederne holds onto Qrow and Clover, activating her Semblance to keep her footing. Weiss creates black-and-purple glyphs under herself, Ruby and Vine Zeki to keep the three of them steady.

Harriet begins making the Manta perform maneuvers, leaning and spinning in an attempt to knock the Teryx off. Inside, Jaune holds back vomit, and Ren looks at Nora, holding onto her right arm.

The Teryx lets go with its hind legs and swings itself to stand on top of the Manta. It then makes its way down the right side of the ship and swings its right hand at the ship. Blake and Yang hear a noise and lean away from each other, just in time to avoid the Teryx's claws as they slash straight through the wall. Yang yelps, looking terrified.

Harriet: I can't shake it!

Another Teryx swoops down, slams its hind claws through the ship's right wing, and flies away, causing an explosion in the ship's wing. Debris flies off the damaged wing, which begins flaming and smoking, and the ship becomes unsteady.

Marrow: I don't think we're staying airborne.

Qrow: It's time to go.

Clover: You have your team assignments.

Clover heads over to the ship door, flicking his clover medal with his thumb.

Clover: Let's go.

He hits the airship's door, making it slide open. On the other side of the door is the Teryx's head, and it screeches at Clover, who confidently stands with his back to it and a smirk on his face. Half of the damaged ship wing snaps off and slams into the Teryx, knocking it off the ship. Jaune, Ren, Weiss and Nora jump out of the ship one by one.

Elm: Harriet, don't stay too long.

Harriet: (sarcastic) Yeah, thanks for the tip.

Marrow, Yang and Blake jump out of the ship. Elm and Clover clasp hands with each other, and then Elm jumps up, grabs onto the ship, and swings herself out. Glass from the front of the ship shatters and flies backward toward Clover, who shields his face with his arms. Harriet is standing on the pilot seat with her weapon deployed, having shattered the windshield. She looks back at Ruby and smirks.

Harriet: Try to keep up, kid.

Ruby laughs and grins excitedly. Harriet uses her Semblance to jump out the broken windshield, run along the top of the ship and jump off the tail, while Ruby follows her, flying through the air with her own Semblance.

The ship begins descending toward Mantle, and Qrow opens the other door. Clover salutes him and falls backward from the ship.

Qrow: (scoffs, smiling) Show off.

Qrow leaps from the ship and does a flip before letting himself freefall.

In the foyer of the Schnee Manor, Whitley Schnee is sitting at the bottom of the main staircase, staring sadly out the open front door.

Jacques: How dare you! This is highly unnecessary.

Atlas soldiers are escorting Jacques to a prison transport airship, while another soldier speaks with Willow.

Jacques: I will not stand for this. Don't touch me like that.

Willow turns and looks at Whitley, who gets up and runs up the stairs. Willow turns back around, looking down sadly. The soldiers continue escorting Jacques, whose wrists are bound in front of him by a bolas.

Jacques: I'll be reporting this rough treatment.

The soldiers push him inside, and one of them slams the door shut.

Jacques: What is your name and badge number?!

While this happens, the dark-haired waitress exits the Schnee Manor, and as the ship flies away, she begins cheerfully skipping with her hands behind her back.

In a hallway somewhere, the dark-haired waitress enters the passcode 1210 next to a door. The number pad beeps in confirmation, and the door slides open. She glances down the hall both ways and then enters, walking over to a glass wall with a view of the City of Atlas, where she stands with her hand on her hip. She hears a voice behind her, and a light turns on.

Cinder: Huh. You're back early.

Cinder is leaning against a wall. The waitress rolls her eyes, then turns to face Cinder, who takes a few steps forward.

Cinder: Tell me you found what we've been looking for.

The waitress strikes a sassy pose, bringing her index finger to her cheek in a feigned thinking gesture. As she does so, pink energy resembling clusters of glass shards moves up her body, dispelling the illusion and revealing her to be Neopolitan. Neo flicks Roman Torchwick's hat atop her head and smirks at Cinder.


Minor Characters


  • The episode title refers to a phrase which means "to explain why and how the world works."
  • Jaune almost vomiting on the airship is a callback to his debut in "Ruby Rose".
  • The crew wanted to showcase that Ironwood was starting to have doubts, which would later be fully shown in Gravity.[1]
  • The AK-200s that the Grimm were able to overwhelm in only a few seconds were meant to represent that Atlas wouldn't provide them with much defense against Grimm because they don't care enough.[2]
  • The Teryx's first appearance is a callback to Jurassic Park.[3]
  • It was difficult to keep shots in the dining room interesting.[4]
  • Every storyline was coming together in this episode, and it's tricky to make a setup episode like this not seem like filler.[5]
  • Throughout volume 7, they made sure to have an orange glow represent the heating in Mantle since the writers knew it would be turned off in Cordially Invited.[6]
  • Ruby and Oscar's awkward interaction came from them both 'riding the high' of the moment when it seems like they each have great plans that will go well.[7]
  • The writers struggled with where to put the reveal that the waitress was actually Neo.[8]

See Also

Image Gallery

Main article: As Above, So Below/Image Gallery


  1. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary - Chapter 9
  2. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary – Chapter 9
  3. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary – Chapter 9
  4. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary - Chapter 9
  5. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary - Chapter 9
  6. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary - Chapter 9
  7. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary - Chapter 9
  8. RWBY Volume 7 Crew Commentary - Chapter 9