Talk:Neopolitan/@comment-104.32.56.83-20141027022413/@comment-24891101-20141027034055

I'm pretty sure the song lyrics suggest she's actually dead and buried. At the very least, they seem to have recovered a partial body.

RLR: ...brings me to the place you rest.

This suggests that she is actually interred at the gravesite (or at least Ruby thinks she is).

RLRII:

... the minute that you died

''I made a sacrifice ... ''

...don't do what I did; 

''I don't want you to waste your life in vain. ''

...it's your blood that's red like roses

All of this suggests that Summer is actually dead. Some of this can be argued to be Ruby being misinformed, but mind that all of RLRII is an impossible conversation, and Summer seems to acknowledge her death. Besides, the whole "Should I Stay or Should I Go" is more Yang's mother's schtick.