Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-1996340-20130815235115/@comment-4010415-20140814192039

206.47.215.226 wrote: I think that it is a momorial to her supposedly dead mother Summer Rose when in actuality Summer Rose is Cinder the leader of the Antogonist Group. Here's the problem with that: If Cinder was Ruby's mother, Ruby would've recognized her the moment she saw her in Beacon.

And don't say "Maybe she was too young to remember." If you have a song all about how angry and upset Ruby was over her mother's death, I'm sure she was old enough to comprehend death.

Don't say "Maybe they waited a few years to tell her when she would understand." If she had been too young to remember her and was told about it years later, she wouldn't have been so distraught.

Ruby's part of the lyrics speak as if she knew her mother and loved her very dearly. "All the joy I had known for all my life was stripped away from me the minute that you died" sure as hell sounds like she knew her mother.