User blog comment:SomeoneYouUsedToKnow/SYUTK's V4E7 - MEGAChristmas -Impressions/Recap/@comment-9090085-20161228142133/@comment-9090085-20170102200849

@MiniDaggers - So you don't read every comment in a chain like I do? How are you supposed to make an informed decision if you don't gather all the information you can?

2 - Overconfidence is never warranted. Do you even know what that word means?

http://www.yourdictionary.com/overconfidence

https://www.behavioraleconomics.com/mini-encyclopedia-of-be/overconfidence-effect/

3 - Um, what?

Qrow didn't toy with Winter because he was drunk, he toyed with her to piss her off. And the reason he fought her was primarily to piss Ironwood off. Besides, he never looks drunk when he fights - he's high-functioning, just like me.

4 - So you just admitted your method of analysis tells you nothing about his personality?

5 - What evidence do you have that Tyrian gets hit a lot on missions? Wouldn't his agile fighting style and reaction to being hit lead to the logical conclusion that he doesn't?

6 - ... so why don't you provide some? or at least acknowledge 73.Anon.52 at all.

7 - ... Why are you watching the show if not for the story? I mean, I know there's great action scenes, but Monty's previous work Dead Fantasy got really dull because it had no real story.

8 - *sigh*

My point when I blew my gasket there, was that despite claiming to want to talk about improving the scene, you were content to just call Qrow and Tyrian stupid until I asked you to provide some improvements. And when you provided changes that drastically changed the story, you provided no reason for why you think it would make for a better story.

And since you just admitted that the plot doesn't mater to you, that calls everything you've said until now into question. "I don't care about the story, I just don't want Qrow to get hurt!" Hyperbole, I know. But if character favoritism is your primary motivation for changing the scene instead of improving the show...

Well, that's naturally going to lead to flawed arguments, isn't it?