Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170708180328/@comment-34633327-20170913184346

Nikoli the rebel wrote: @KIng

1) Except we do know what their life was like.. https://youtu.be/u7uU_tKYHiM?t=2m55s

If you don't believe Blake is talking about Adam here then you should explain another male character in her life that went through such a change.

2) You missed one tiny scene. https://youtu.be/FFf7qoIDYuQ?t=5m47s   Its only a few seconds but we see that Adam ignores Blake's question and tells her what to do. This is right before the Blake trailer.

3) My headcanon is that Tuscon's book trade was a front for the WF. The WF/Tuscon would steal books for Tuscon and Tuscon would sell them. How else was he supposed to have "Every book under the sun?"

I alledge that Tuscon wouldn't steal "The Third Crusade" and so when Emerald asked for the book Tuscon knew that he was in deep trouble. Honestly, that scene is so confusing/nuanced its difficult to know much for certain other than Tuscon owned a bookstore and defected from the WF. But that is my theory. Please read my whole post and the post I was responding too before posting next time.

1) I said LifeSTYLE not Life. I know Adam did that crap. LifeSTYLE in what they lived in, what they ate, how often they moved around. None of what I was saying way reffering to Adam. Did they live in tents all the time, ate bare minimum and whatever they could get and were constantly on the move? Did they have bases that were accesible where they had rooms and decent meals? None of that has to do with Adam being an abusive jerk.

2) Again, LifeSTYLE. One scene of him ignoring a question does not tell if she was indoctrinated like 73 suggested, nor does it tell us anything about the way she lived.

3) Headcanon is just that though, from your head. There is no actual basis behind it aside from hypothesis and theories. "Every book under the sun" is like he said, just a catchphrase. Plus he didn't need to steal them, as they are USED Books, which one can easily find people threw away or have both for a cheaper price, fixed the binding and covers ala refurbishing, then sell them again as used. "The Third Crusade" is meant to be a code phrase in direct reference to the White Fang. Why wouldn't he steal one particular book out of thousands if he even did steal books? Think about, how many "crusades" have they had? The Faunus Rights Revolution (1st Crusade), the Ghira Era of the White Fang (2nd Crusade), and the Khan Era of the White Fang (3rd Crusade). Notice how he tensed up when they mentioned that particular "book"? If it was any other book he didn't have, I don't believe it would have been as severe, but it was only after that book was brought up did Emerald go in for the revelation that they knew he was WF. Before she mentioned that book, he thought they were just Teenagers, but notice after he heard that name he started to seem agitated.