Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-24993958-20160721222431/@comment-25936766-20160730160854

Phantomlink959 wrote:

Your argument requires that we assume first name must be used to fulfill the CNR (which has never been stated) and that the writers took into account the existance of space rocks or ghost ships when naming characters.

Now, since i'm fairly sure you're going to find a way to justify ignoring this argument in some imaginary technicality, i am doing trying to explain basic logic to you. Have fun being incapable of admitting when other people are right, Live. -Yet has it been stated that it can be fulfilled with only the family name? Even though it doesn't fit what Ozpin said in the show, that people started naming their children after colors? Trying to argue that it can be fulfilled through only family name, means to assume that people in Remnant were willing to change their family names when the CNR was implemented.

Or you could just assume only the given name must fit, which fits how every character has a given name that fits, and when they don't, they fit through given + family name, like that reporter guy from the 1st episode. This even includes the minor characters, like Lisa (a fish).

Now tell me, which one of these 2 requires the least assumptions? The one that requires one to think people of Remnant decided to change their family names to fit CNR? Or the one that doesn't and is supported by the fact every named character fits CNR through first name, or first+last names, alone?

-Ooh, calling me Live, are you. Feeling better after calling me by the name of a banned user?