Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-28745050-20160614060931/@comment-184.4.62.124-20160727215339

Don't put it past them to tell you something and then surprise you later with the "truth." Whatever truth that may be, there is obviously some cover up going on in the family, that we can pretty much take as fact. This could be a number of things, and one of them happens to be the Qrow is Ruby's father theory. (Yes I support it, but I also see a few different things that could be true, that would make this false, or well semi-false) We know what the girls know, they tell us what the girls know, and that tweet is not evidence that can support the Ruby and Yang are just half sisters anything else said is completely false, because it was directed at a different theory. Now Im not saying I'll never believe they're half sisters, but this just can't be used so non chalant to say this particular theory is wrong. I always support the canon evidence. So I support that what we know is true. But I don't believe it's true. Example (Summer never returned, we are lead to believe she died, I don't believe it's that simple, I don't think she's exactly dead, or something majored happened (this was just an example to show I will support the canon while I wont believe it until we are shown exactly all of the truth around the mystery of team STRK, and there's A LOT)) There is a lot of evidence to support Qrow being Ruby's father theory and I believe that, I like the theory, I also have an alternate theory, that Qrow was indeed in love with Summer, wether it was unrequited love or not yet to be seen. Something just seriously rubs me the wrong way when it's stated Summer and Taiyang got together after 2 years, something is definitely weird about that, not neccesarily Taiyang isn't the father, but something. And that is a short time to find a second love, especially we know, that he shut down after Summer dissapeared, it's reasonable to say that he might have shut down after Raven left? At least for a little bit or was so depressed while taking care of Yang that he couldn't think about loving someone else for a few months something. Not sayi it's true but no matter the theory you believe in something weird is going on with this family, that much is fact. I mean what we know we're told from the Yang & Ruby's point of view, Yang was about 2-4 when all of this happened (It's implied Summer didn't just dissapear right out of the blue after Ruby was born so) but still that's so young, you can be told something and believe it while something else entirely is true, at that age you don't believe someone would lie to you, what reason would they have. We don't know, but there I'm sure we're and are reasons. (This is more directed at any theory pertaining to team STRK then directly to the Ruby/Qrow father theory) Now I personally believe, either Qrow is Ruby's father, he was in love with Summer (unrequited or not either way), maybe him and Summer were in love or best friends and she betrayed him by turning sides(highly unlikely though I might add but possible/or was the one he couldn't save), or Ruby is the daughter he never had but always wanted (which considering his character it would be hard for me to believe he always wanted a daughter, but it's a possibility never the less). Why do I believe one of these is true, well take the picture he shows Yang, there are tear drops on Raven (his sister) & on Summer but there is also a coffee mug ring stain completely covering Summer's face almost her entire body in the picture, almost like he just couldn't bare looking at it, like it was too painful. Which leads me to believe they were closer then just teammate friends like we see Ruby and Blake for example but actually close best friends (possible lovers, or he was in love with her). He obviously plays favorites with Ruby, and there is probably more to it then "he's her mentor" (no offense guys). Does that neccesarily mean father daughter, no, but is it a huge possibility yes. All I'm saying is don't just exclude this theory just yet. The writers can be handing the truth from you to do a big reveal. Seriously even the writers you think NEVER would, will and can do it. A reveal this big if the theory is true would be something you hide and would say no or lead people to believe anything but this being true. And why they might go to an extent to hide it, instead of saying something like spoilers, or watch *insert next upcoming volume* would give it away that you should be doubting. Look I have more evidence to which makes me personally think Qrow is Ruby's father, but I don't want to bother you guys that don't support or believe it even more then you already have to deal with. Because I know that can be annoying. All I'm trying to say is keep your mind open to the possibilities. Don't believe on blind faith that they would never pull a trope like this, they can, they might (even if it's to a completely different theory, or something else in the show). Someone I read that Monty (RIP) told us what the girls knew, that we would know what they knew as they learned it. Now I don't have a link so yes I realize that it's not credible, if I had a link I'd share it, but I read this last week and the link to where I read it at is not in my history anymore. There is just so much mystery involving Team STRK and Ozpin. All the questions we have will be answered by Ozpin, Salem, Cinder, Team STRK. :/ please don't think I'm attacking anyone I'm not, I just tend to try and think very logical, and what makes sense given the facts. I'm also usually very good with theories and am often right, even though I have been wrong a few times, and could be wrong now. But I try to find more then on route that could explain everything, and if you read all of this you know that. Also bless your souls for baring with me on this long ass post XD!!! Anyways I'm up for debate on what I believe, I enjoy seeing other sides to the arguement. Helps me understand more possible outcomes. Have a great day guys!!! :)