Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4830106-20140725003808/@comment-24994749-20140803030901

If "yhe thief and the butcher: were them hinting at their usual roles for Cinder, we can safely assume Emerald is the thief. .. which leaves Mercuw for butcher. .. that sounds at least mildly disturbing of a nickname. .. speciallt when you put it together with the "I told you to stay clean while in Vale." Cinnder gave them.