Talk:Yang Xiao Long/@comment-2600:8807:1200:490:78E6:354:AA2D:C2F2-20171111043443

Since I can't seem to respond to RaijinRising I'll post it here.

The entire second half of the Personality section is interpretation and not confirmed. For example " she learns how to balance her carefree nature without overconfidence or agitation." She has yet to demonstrate the carefree nature from before losing her arm. Period. That is not a balance, that is a complete shift.

"she continues to struggle with her PTSD, which manifests in her left arm shaking when she encounters conflict." Not confirmed even if implied. I'd suggest indicating that.

Also, frankly this part is stupid, "   if they can evade or outlast the duration of her onslaught, she is left weak and tired, and vulnerable to a counterattack" as that is literally true of any aggressive attack. Mike Tyson had the same thing. As I showed in the previous comment, she can turn her Semblance on or off at will, so activating it doesn't mean that the opponents can automatically just wait for it to die out. Nor does her powering down necessarily leave her exhausted, especially as that's never actually happened in the many times she's used her Semblance.

Also it is a vast oversimplification to simply call her actions with Adam "anger". That was panic. Anyone who's been in a situation where a split second decision means life or death of someone you care for can tell you that 'thinking' doesn't happen in the same way it does when your calm. Armchair critics making judgements from the safety of their homes need to really think hard before making judgements.

Finally, you mentioned changing the description of Taiyang's comment. I very much hope that wasn't just platitudes as I still see it and don't dare try and edit it knowing I'll just be blocked again.