Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25266931-20161228230634/@comment-27082610-20170107000124

KNN005 wrote: Arkantos95 wrote:

And goddammit there was nothing in V2 to suggest to the cast that Cinder, Emerald, and Mercury were evil. You only feel that way because, again, you apply your outside knowledge gained from watching the show to characters that have no way of knowing what you know. What about Qrow seeing Em, Merc and Cinder when they attack Amber. Sure Cinder used heat to hide her face, but what about before she noticed Qrow had arrived? Didn't he see them attacking Amber when he was running up. Em, Merc and Cinder only noticed him when he came down with his slash. So fastforward to when Merc sees Qrow in town beefing with Winter. Why not write it so instead Qrow goes and gave a complete description of the attackers as best he can describe so that people can be on the lookout out for:

Tan (black maybe) girl with green hair and two guns.

Blue/gray haired boy with kick-based martial arts.

Black hair girl with golden eyes and fire powers.

Qrow should've described the trio attackers when he brought Amber in anyway. At least have Qrow go into the stadium, see the 3 of them in the same team and flashback.

Qrow: "Holy shit! Those are the three who attacked the fall maiden! I gotta tell Ozpin!"

Drunk or not, sooner or later he should've seen them on TV or in the stadium and flashed back to that moment since it was such an important one as it was the first time he found the Fall Maiden.

Because he never got a clear view of them, and because that would screw with the narrative.