User blog comment:Rebinreburst/10 commandments of weapons, and why I'm not posting in the forums./@comment-29684190-20190830045649/@comment-36926079-20190830052354

None of these are hard set rules for me. I usually mention something if more than three of these things are violated.

1. Most of those at least look plausible in size comparison, except for Coco's weapon. I really have no arguement against that.

2. I was refering to things like bladed tonfas, which did not exist. I am okay with adding guns as long as the vague silhouette looks the same as the real life object. I dislike the scythe form of Crescent Rose, but find it more acceptable because it can and was used as an improvised weapon before war scythes. Tyrian's weapons aren't that great ideas in my book.

3. I think that three is fine. When I say too many, I mean like over five forms. Glitchee tried to make a weapon that makes every handheld weapon.

5. And they'd make terrible OC's. Weapons should be flavourful and say something about how the weilder grew up or acts like.

6. Myrtenaster is a rapier, but the blade is shaped in a way that allows for and necessitates slicing and blocking. Crescent is used in an appropiate way for an improvised scythe because decapitating Grimm would do less damage and be more dangerous.

8. They look cool, but the lack of practicality is hurting me so bad. Kinda how pointing out plotholes ruins a movie.