User blog comment:Zathronas/Speculative author: The Schnee Company/@comment-16241789-20140824055458/@comment-24218038-20140824181116

One thing you have to think about when you're doing a theory is that who is the central figures of the main story. My own theory above isn't the major plot of the series. It's there to divide everyone who will need to work together when the real threat shows itself.

Then the central figure (RWBY in this case and Ruby in particular) comes along and unite everyone against the threat.

Your theory is good but your forgetting something crucial. Your relegating RWBY as a support role. This story is ultimately about the coming of age of 4 young girls and their friends at school under extraordinary times. They are the central figures of the story.

Your theory is still good but it needs adjustment to reflect the main plot and the main protagonist.