Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-203.14.52.141-20151216011808/@comment-26872876-20160108005750

@Devin Camary

The theory is way too specific, and it pulls information and ideas that don't have any real basis from events we've seen. Some parts contradict with facts that we do have. If you want to theorize with some information that is pure speculation, you can't go into specific details. Otherwise it is less theory and more Fan Fiction.

The shortest version you should have gone for would be something like this: A witch made a deal with a demon. The witch would give souls for life. The people who lost their souls became Grimm. Summer got a mission to kill her, but the ordeal took her life.

Even then, it's a stretch. Demons and Witches have no cannon reference. We have mages, but there are only four: maidens. Possibly 5 with the man who gave maidens power. We then have to question how Summer even learned of the mission or why she specifically was given it. Not to mention why just one member or squad was ordered to kill the origin of Grimm. Not to mention as far as we know from World of Remnant, mankind knows nothing of Grimm origins.

A creative theory, but it isn't very strong. Sorry.