Board Thread:Episode Discussion/@comment-14138255-20160117163823/@comment-14909251-20160119224847

Seum Dwa21 wrote: How would Cinder even know Amber is there? Qrow teaches at Signal and his being a part of Ozpin's group is a secret, so even though Cinder saw him she would have no reason to deduce that Amber is being kept under Beacon. Better is to ask how Cinder even knew about the Maidens, that Amber was one, and where to find her. The very existence of the Maidens is supposed to be a closely guarded secret and their identities would surely be even more closely guarded. Where to find one in the field would probably be something even people who are part of the secret group compartmentalize assuming they share that information with each other at all. Unless Cinder's boss is able to detect them, one has to consider that her boss has inside information about the Maidens i.e. that there is a traitor in their midst or that was in their midst.