Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-10048743-20160208024352/@comment-26397825-20160223081650

I don't see why any of the Maidens would get some super special metaphysical power when the Fall Maiden has been shown to be purely elemental. In fact, the story of the Four Maidens implies that the Maiden power for each season is purely elemental, and all Maidens get access to all elements.

To introduce a metaphysical and non-elemental power for one of the Maidens but not to have shown something similar for the Fall Maiden would be an imbalance of powers, which is not what the wizard did; he shared his powers equally between the four girls.

That being said, we don't know if there are other beings out there who are capable of regenerating arms. It may not be a Maiden, but that doesn't mean they don't exist.

I personally hope she doesn't meet someone capable of doing this though, as I would like to see her grow and learn to cope with this disability and ultimately come out the other side stronger rather than have the arm grown back and for her to go 'Oh, I have my arm back. Well, that wasn't so bad. Let's do it again!' I feel like she wouldn't grow or learn anything if the writers just regrew her arm for her.