Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-3146930-20140309012631/@comment-99.185.49.181-20140409024932

They seem to be sticking to older mythos and not more recent things. To the best of my knowledge, Sally from TNBC has no older basis (other than a zombie made of patchwork parts), so she's not likely to be the choice. Now if we saw a Slenderman character, that theory may hold more water because he's a more recent "myth".

I suspect the mystery man in the car is Penny's "Father" who, going with that train of thought, could be Dr. Gipetto Frankenstien, combining two mythos into one. Or she could have an unknown sibling by that name as well.