User blog comment:Zolnir/RWBY Volume 3: Theories/@comment-3257939-20151016032527/@comment-3257939-20151016051855

1. Sounds good but it does make more sense that Qrow taught her what he knows instead of him learning what she did so she can teach it to Ruby.

2. I see that more as Weiss trying to look the part and Winter judging with her look. Something like "Ok, Weiss. Back straight. Chin up. Good afternoon my older sister, Winter." And Winter's like "Good to see you again Weiss. *Explores her standing then turns and goes away*" Not that she thinks she's some sort of failure but that she's still has a lot to learn.

3. Yeah. You're over analyzing. My uncle usually has this cold look on his face but doesn't mean he's a heartless person with a troubled past. That's just how he usually is. Plus the thing about Yang smiling would make more sense if she didn't smile at all. Just read yourself: She doesn't smile until he turns back. Totally means she has some sort of hatred for him because not smiling at his face means not liking to see him. Which means she doesn't smile at all every single time he looks at her because she can't get over the past. She, the girl who's so care-free has a trauma over her uncle that doesn't allow her to smile in front of him........ Yep. Over analyzing.

5. Yeah. That's pretty much what I meant. Ruby did say her father was overprotective. However, you're looking too far into things. Just the idea that they kept Ruby locked away BUT not Yang is saying that Taiyang plays favorite and wouldn't care if her other daugther died out there. If we take thing as literal as you're doing then this is one possible conclusion. It's all based on the idea that adults can't move on but that's exaggerating things. I guess that what I'm trying to say is that you're forcing an idea way too much and forgetting how people actually work. It's like if you saw Taiyang and Qrow as dolls rather than people. I know I might not be making any sense but that's how I feel about this whole theory.

4/6. Already gave you actual proof. It's not that it can go both ways. You just prefer to ignore what might be a theory breaking point.

Sorry for sounding very bad but I can't read to your theory without thinking you're over analizing everything. Especially because the Openings have never been a good source of what's gonna happen in the Volume. Opening 1 and 2 had nothing to do with the actual series and what might be a good observation such as the Yang doesn't smile when she sees Qrow ends up being torn apart by the actual series with the character's fluid conversations.