Talk:Jaune Arc/@comment-29933641-20161023174911/@comment-82.31.6.26-20161024144646

On the whole I still prefer the head canon that it was Penny's metal as well as Pyrrha's. It seems like something that Ruby might want, to carry a little of her friend in rememberance, after all it's what Jaune has done for Pyrrha and when after a year it had become useful for their/her cause using it would be a fitting memorial in her eyes. Even if Jaune hadn't been her friend Ruby could have told stories of her during the last year and all of RNJR might see her as someone worth paying their respects to especially since her presumed death was at the hands of Pyrrha herself, they might even have seen it as something Pyrrha would have wanted. I think it's a nice symetry for the two beloved characters, who both died in season 3, who have an intimate past to be joined together by the people closest to them in order to serve a purpose they'd likely have both been supportive of.

What I meant by 'no other explainations' was 'no canon explainations' your theory could be right but there's as much evidence for it as for it being Penny's metal, Occam's Razor supports your version how much in RWBY has had only the one simplest explaination? I understand that there's no real on screen cannon for it which is why I was asking for speculation, and that you might not like it, but I'm not forcing you personally to accept it. For me unless RT make a statement denying it outright I'm allowed to have this opinion and ask does anyone else think this could be the case.