Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-14138255-20151206164217/@comment-27356929-20151207021902

Zolnir wrote: AlphaSSB wrote: Personally, I'm more than fine with Phyrra being selected as the Guardian. Definitely unexpected, as Ruby would've made a bit more sense. I'm certain that Phyrra won't last long as the Guardian though, as I'm expecting the final round to be her against Mercury, with the outcome having a lasting effect on her. Also, people are thinking that Phyrra is going to die? Uh... no. I very strongly doubt it. Uh, no. From our standpoint Ruby makes sense because we see her as THE protagonist who will eventually grow awesome in the series, but from a completely objective point of view Pyrrha is the obvious and better choice. As of now Ruby is fickle, playful, prone to curosity and in general too young to properly understand the burden of a Guardian even if she has the heart to become one. She's also somewhat a famous troublemaker (2 Atlas officers who met her the first time, Winter and Ciel gave her the following comments: "Suitably inderwhelming" and "Questionable". Even Weiss would be a better Guardian than her right now. Yeah, when I said that Ruby as the Guardian made more sense was when I was looking at it from a writer's view. Supposed main character getting an important role makes sense on paper, but I like how Ruby has been sitting on the side a bit. Now, looking at Ozpin's choice from his perspective, Phyrra was a really good call