Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24.162.174.19-20150329014940/@comment-25555436-20150329132121

...I have big problems understanding what 24.162 meant in the original post. Or maybe, I understood it too right.

Esentially, Jaune would sacrifice his (currently non-existant) Semblance, to become a half-faunus (which is in itself, quite full of bullshit), yet can still use his Semblance? From a writing PoV, that is the biggest shit-out-of-your-ass pull I've ever seen RWBY-related, no matter how you look at it, both in-universe and out-of-universe.

If he losed his Semblance, he losed his Semblance, there should be no way that he would still be able to use it. If he could, it would be shit writing, just plain stupid. Not to mention, he becoming a half-faunus, would be stupid on it's own.