Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-14138255-20141031002615/@comment-73.42.187.52-20141203071814

Zephyrcoil wrote:

The only way one can say something doesn't belong is if there's enough defined rules to say one way or the other. We've only the rough outline of everything.

We don't know who Adam grew up with. We only know that Adam was her Partner/Mentor. And I'd find it rather skeptical to believe that Yang's mother had Adam before her without that point coming up somewhere. And she certainly couldn't have him after her, given the whole situation of him clearly being older than Blake.

while it is true the rules are undefined, that portal came out of nowhere, no-one had mentioned or used such a world-breaking skill before, and the practical applications are such that technology would attempt to replicate it and warriors could be expected to complain about it(dang... I sure wish we could just "teleport" there). That being said, no-one is arguing it as an impossibility, just that it seemed an odd placement.

As for Adam, I wasn't trying to start wild Speculation, I was actually saying that because of other speculations made earlier on this thread(that Raven and Qrow are Faunus/half Faunus, that Yang is also by extension). I was attempting to illustrate that any known Faunus could actually be half-faunus. It would actually make sense for Adam specifically because since Blake can be considered Beauty & the beast, Adam could likewise be symbolic of the Gaston Character(the human who acts like a beast) and not just the Prince Adam/Beast character. As far as age goes, I never really could tell with Adam, he seems to act both older and younger than Blake, and the Relative age of all 3(Blake/Yang/Adam) is unclear. The only ages we know are that Ruby is 2 years younger than Yang. Yang could be in the oldest normal range for their entry year, while Blake is the youngest(or perhaps even a year early as a prodigy like ruby or due to transcript misinformation) that would still leave Adam a year for conception/birth before before Blake, yet after Yang, unless Raven was raped/in a prior relationship and had him first.