Talk:Pyrrha Nikos/@comment-179.43.147.30-20170621165313/@comment-25936766-20170621172810

The real problem with the idea of Pyrrha being revived isn't so much the act itself. The problem is what it would imply, and the fact that there is no way for her to be revived in a believable way.

For starters, she did not just die. She was incinerated to ashes, which inmediately scattered in the wind. Meaning there simply is no body to revive, to begin with. You cannot revive something when you don't have it. It's like trying to make a LEGO cube without any LEGOs.

Second of all, her death would simply not be seen as a good thing:

-It cheapens her death. It also cheapens anyone else's deaths since if Pyrrha can be revived, anyone can, thus no one would feel much if anyone died, because "they can revive them".

-It would make a good deal of the fandom think of Miles and Kerry as spineless writers who focus too much on cattering to fans than on making a good story. And their writing skills in RWBY are not exactly good to begin with.

-It would go against Monty's plans, which not everyone would simply accept.

Pyrrha coming back is a can of worms better left unopened. If she "comes back", let it be via flashbacks, or in side-material set before her death. That's the only way it won't cause too much backdraft.