Thread:SpiritedDreaming/@comment-29010798-20160712111215

Hi, I'm the one who write the possibility that Pyrrha is not dead because it was Emerald trick. I would to reply on the discussion but for some reason I can write anymore. So I was going to respond here if he's ok with you.

You're right, for Emerald's Semblance to work, she would be on the top of the tower with the other girls. Now, I'm not sayng that Emerald was already on the tower, maybe she followed Ruby and Weiss, and so she climb to the top just like the girl without being noticed. After all her semblance help her conceil her presence if you saw the fight with Amber you know that it is.

For the other question, don't forget that Cinder was following Pyrrha and Jaune inside the beacon, so probably Emerald and Mercury would know too about it, so when they saw Ruby start to climb the tower they think to not make her see what they were going to do, and also, this could be an opportunity, if they would know that Pyrra was kidnapped, they would try to search for her, but instead if they believed she was dead, then there wouldn't be problem. Ruby was the perfect eyewitness for the set up.

Also, why they would Pyrrha? I don't know that, but if you remember, in the second season Cinder ask Mercury to put her name on a list. What is that list? Maybe there were other they would take, I don't know mine is just an assumption.

Now about Ruby, the plan was to make her believe that Pyrrha was dead, but their only miscalculation was the mysterious power she unleashed in that moment. They didn't expect that to happen, and I'm sure that would be somehow damaged too by the attack, so they only thing they could do before the arrive of reinforcement, was to take Cinder and Pyrra and flee away. They couldn't take Ruby even if they wouldn't.

Well this is my opinion. Thank you and see ya^^ 