Talk:Pyrrha Nikos/@comment-27302898-20160215061449/@comment-80.116.167.129-20160215073324

Sorry, but as much as i like Pyrrha (favorite character) i don't believe Emerald did anything of that sort.

First reason: for what we have seen, we don't even know if Emerald's illusions can  work on multiple target. Even if that's the case, i don't see why the illusion should have hit Ruby too, in those circumstances.

Second: Emerald feeling guilty and betraying Cinder just like that... they would need to give me some solid explanation for that, because from what we have seen until now it wouldn't make sense. She knew they were doing bad things, and she already killed people. A sudden change of heart just to save Pyrrha sounds like lazy writing.

Third: If Pyrrha was saved by Emerald thanks to an illusion... well, where is she now? why didn't she come back to her friend? Or why shouldn't she be able to do so in the near future? And having Pyrrha come back saying "hi, guys, i was actually ok, sorry for making you worry" is just... bad...

Maybe there is a chance that Pyrrha will be back, somehow. There are interesting theories on that, and while i think that she is most probably dead for good, i'm not going to assume she is 100% deceased only because of her name, just as i don't expect to see Jaune get burned at the stake. On the other hand, if we put together what her name alludes to and all the death flags she raised... well, her death has been predicted for a long time.

That said, it's true that there are some interesting circumstances about her death and Cinder adding her to some kind of list, so we never know. Acutally, i have a funny theory (99.99% wrong, obviously) that could potentially bring Pyrrha back... or even make things even more miserable  XD