Thread:The Devil's Advocate WP/@comment-24573226-20170123040730/@comment-28288412-20170125083625

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote: MiniDaggers wrote: She is staff, devil. She's a rollback, which is a staff position here. 1. It is silly to say rollback is staff. That would make me staff, which is dumb. All I or Hazel can do is sometimes revert people in a slightly more effective way than regular contributors. No special authority inherently comes with rollback privileges

2. On a wiki you can hand out rollback rather liberally and the only potential misuse is the same misuse possible for anyone able to edit the page.

3. nothing within the episode prevents them from later revealing one or both of his parents managed to survive. Were that to happen then we would obviously have been putting forward a false claim as true and I like to be as accurate as possible, which means allowing for doubt when there is room for doubt.

1. You mean besides access and the ability to weigh on the staff chat? Something that grants staff members, even rollbacks to my knowledge, a far greater awareness about the next decisions made on the wiki. The biggest example that springs to mind is the release of a new episode, page creation or large edits associated with those are typically left to staff members (regardless of position) as they have already sorted out who is going to do what. Making a normal user editing in that period ill-advised as they will more likely get in the way than assist. Or that how it seems to me, a person outside of it.

Besides, as said previously there is more to the position than just power. It is duty, responsibility.

2. Not the point. Besides, can't that be said for any position below Crat? More of a pain in the ass, but an admin can undo anything another admin does. Also imagine an admin can't ban a crat, worse come to worse they can take of it.

3. Pyrrha was teleported, Penny's in standby mode and Roman shot his way out. What? They none of that's the case? Well they're all possibilities so we can't say they're dead right?

Honestly if we had to wait for direct confirmation of a character's death only Tukson, maybe Pyrrha if you allow the commentaries which can't be checked by people without them (Tukson was confirmed outside one right?) would be classified as dead here. We have enough in-show evidence to say his parents are dead and it would be a surprise if they came back.