Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-27082610-20170424154014/@comment-25936766-20170524012643

MiniDaggers wrote: 1. You can't take missions off a mission board it seems without the permission to do so. While students are limited by year, I can only imagine Huntsman would be limited by whether or not they have a license.

1.1 Can you still do shit without a license if you find a person who needs that kinda help directly? Sure, but you wouldn't be doing it as a Huntsman. Nor any other job really, you'd be doing it because you have skills suitable for the job despite no qualifications or license.

Also, they weren't doing it as official Huntsmen, just as people wanting to help out and earn a reward. Any Huntsman reference to them is due to them being in-training.

2. You can practice as anything but without the qualifications that doesn't necessarily mean you are that. Huntsman need a license to offficially be Huntsman.

3. If someone is injured or sick and you medical knowledge to help them, it doesn't matter if you are a doctor or not if they believe you they will accept the help. Still doesn’t make you a doctor if you don't have the qualification, helping people with Grimm doesn't make you a Huntsman if you don't have the license.

4. How is being a Huntsman "in practice" relevant. Anyone with the knowhow can practice anything (if they aren't caught doing it if it is illegal to do so unofficially anyway), that doesn't make them that profession.

5. That applies to a shit ton of professions if they believe you have the capability. But once again, that doesn't make you that profession.

6. Alright, how do you know Hunters in general can kill Grimm to the same capabillity as trained Huntsman? Li Ren did jackshit to the Nuckevalee while four trainees (who had their asses handed to them by Tyrian who is around equal to professional Huntsman Qrow in power mind you) were able to beat it? That's just one Hunter who is certainly not comparable to a Huntsman.

7. In our world but not necessarily RWBY due to the distinction made between the terms.

8. Going by your whole ignoring the license and formal training................... 1-Who said they had to be on a mission board? Mission boards are not the only way to get a job involving Grimm, you know.

1.1-And since those "demanded skills" are basically just "can you kill Grimm without being eaten?", a title or not is irrelevant.

2-But all Huntsmen will be hired to do simply requires their combat skills. You don't need a pretty title, just those combat skills. Thus whether you're an official Huntsman or not won't change shit.

--

3-Which changes nothing, since all it means is that you are esentially a Huntsman in practice, even if not in title. And what people care when it comes to Grimm, is that you are one in practice.

--

4-Read points 1.1, 2, and 3. People won't give a damn about titles, only skills.

-

5-But it means you can exercise it in practice unless you're legally unable to. Now, with something like Medicine or Engineering, a title would be necesary. But to deal with monsters, titles are irrelevant for anyone.

--

6-Are you fucking kidding me, did you even read my points? Anyone, from the lowest scum on the streets to the most spoiled rich brat on the planet, can learn to use Aura, can learn their Semblance, can become strong as hell and go kill Grimm if they feel they can.

I'm not saying every Hunter is as strong as the average Huntsman. I'm saying they can. Roman and Neo are an example that you don't need to go to an Academy and get a pretty title to be as strong as, at least, Huntsmen in training.

Yes, Hanzo-wannabe was a weakling, maybe, considering it's just 1 old man with a cheap bow fighting that beast, not 4 guys who have more appropiate weapons and skill.

But I'm not talking about the rule, I'm talking about the potentials.

--

7-Technically it would still be correct. Distinction changes nothing.

--

8-You fail at reading my points:

With a doctor, or an engineer, a license, a title, something, would be necesary, because, at least in the former case, you need proof that you are competent.

With killing monsters, all you need is combat skills. Titles, race, anything, is irrelevant, only that. All a title would really change, is just make things simpler: Just show the title, "BOOM" a graduated Huntsman, which would imply you're competent from the get go. But besides that, nothing will change.

Hell, at most, it would be to join the Atlesian Military as a Specialist. And that's it.