Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-14909251-20181014193722/@comment-14909251-20181016205642

73.Anon.52 wrote: Personally I've just experienced better stories I guess, don't get me wrong, I've seen plenty of shit ones too, but usually when planning something so dumb as bringing back Cinder(if that is indeed what happens) the writers have the animators practice a conservation of detail that just didn't happen in V5... we were given clear indications she was rendered unconscious, and if you can't think you can't use magic, and if your ear canal's are frozen your sense of falling shouldn't kick in to wake you up. So in other words, she should be dead, and if she wasn't going to be the writers shouldn't have "killed" her the way they did, because the evidence shown should have been far more fatal.

I see two ways they can work around that. Either they argue the Grimm part of her was able to break free and saved her somehow or she fell into some pool of water at the bottom with said water being heated from geothermal sources. As a result she hits the water, thaws out, and then survives.