Talk:Summer Rose/@comment-82.31.69.200-20150830224903/@comment-25555436-20150831145834

Urano, I don't know where you have been living, but a possibility existing does not mean that it would not be surprising if it turned out true. Hell, in this case it's not even obvious.

It's been made clear in and out of the show that Summer's dead. It may be another of their "telling but not showing" issues but still, she's dead. Or at the very, very least she's supposed to be dead. So if she appeared, it would be more surprising than if she was just missing, because a missing person can easily come back someday, a dead person....not so much.

It would not be obvious either, not at all, unless Miles went dumb-mode again and made any hint painfully obvious like he did with Blake and Penny.

If Summer came back, in some way that wasn't a flashback, one would still be surprised, even if not shocked, even if the surprise comes from being right, from having said "nah, she'll come back" despite lack of evidence and later "oh, I was right".