Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-27963514-20160417124134

Thunderbringerstormbrook wrote:

They are clearly referencing my absurd theory somehwere. If someone took that serioiusly? I mean it could be true in some manner. Zwei could use some awesome power-up and become a faunus... I was just being stupid... no idea what your absurd theory was.

The Devil's Advocate WP wrote:

The soul returning to its body after the body is revived is not exactly an outlandish prospect. Wait, I thought the soul returning to the body and bringing the aura healing powers with it was what revived the body... The body that was already mortally injured before being shot through the heart with an arrow. So something else revived the corpse that was trapped alone under the school at the exact same time that Pyrrha was killed, drawing both souls back into the body? Was someone hiding in the basement performing the most impressive CPR ever? Was it Zwei? It was Zwei, wasn't it?

Look, I can buy the idea that Pyrrha got a little bit of Amber's soul before the transfer was cut off, even though it begs the question of why Pyrrha wasn't more powerful during her final fight. I can buy that this Doublemint Soul would be able to superheal a body, maybe even a mortally wounded one like Amber's. But why the hell is this spiritual Voltron jumping into Amber's corpse anyway? Is that just what they do? Did I miss World of Remnant 5: Fused Souls? And what happens when someone manages to kill ultra-huntress? Does the soul jump into another corpse, or does it just reconstitute the ashes of Pyrrha?

The Devil's Advocate WP wrote: Pyrrha's Semblance would not make that a difficult obstacle and it would make sense for Ambyrrha to have that Semblance given it is a product of one's Aura a.k.a. soul.

Pyrrha rode in the elevator car when she went up the shaft the first time. And it was clearly taxing. Now the car is gone, so what does she manipulate to get up the shaft this time? Are those sparse bandages that she's dress in made of ferrous metal?

The Devil's Advocate WP wrote: You act as if it is unreasonable to suggest it might be easier for someone to merely escape from an area when they have no time limit, no set destination, and don't have to care for anyone else, rather than try to reach a specific high point in the epicenter of a monster horde in time to prevent someone from being killed and then lug said person all the way back through said horde. That's what I am talking about with that whole "shoddy rebuttals" comment. You act as if it's unreasonable to suggest that an armed, experienced, and highly skilled huntsman would have an easier time dealing with hoards of Grimm than an unarmed, half-naked, disoriented huntress who's trying to make sense of her dual personalities and dealing with the trauma of having just died. Twice. But they have the power of two.