Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-27082610-20160415052224

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote:

Lord Jaric wrote: I'm going to have to disagree with you on this one DA. Pretty much everything that has been presented to us about Pyrrha is that she is not coming back. And Amber is definitely dead taking an arrow to the heart. Did you do a chest X-ray and determine the exact placement of the arrow? Are you familiar with Remnant's medical technology and the limitations of Aura's healing properties? Were it a headshot or her body was obliterated it would be one thing, but people in the real word have survived being shot in the heart, so the idea that Amber could definitely not have been revived is based off nothing.

Regarding Pyrrha, I addressed that already. Even in this theory Pyrrha would not really be coming back and would still be essentially dead and out of the show, it would just be that her soul and Aura remains tethered to another person's body that is under that person's control. More than enoguh room there to allow for confirmation of her "death" with her still being sort of alive in a sense.

The hell do you mean "based off of nothing"? She took an arrow to the heart, and received no medical attention whatsoever unless Cinder just stood there for 15 minutes while Ozpin pried the glass casket off of her, pulled out the arrow, and desperately tried to stop the bleeding, something that definitely didn't happen.

Secondly, how (and I feel the need to add why here because I don't get the reasoning behind that either) would Pyrrha transfer her soul into Amber's corpse? Which is what it is, by the way. She was left with an arrow in her heart for the duration of the fight between Cinder and Ozpin, so she's clearly dead. The ashes of her body flew in the exact opposite direction of the elevator that would lead down to Amber, so that's a no go. They didn't exactly share a deep spiritual bond, so I don't see why Pyrrha would go to her instead of the great beyond or wherever the hell people on Remnant go when they die. Plus, coming into contact with Amber's aura seemed to cause Pyrrha immense pain (not that having the equivalent of a second soul shoved inside you could possibly be pleasant), so that's another point against her going to Amber's body.

Thirdly, Amber had her aura, including the bit Pyrrha may have collected by that point, sucked out of her and straight into Cinder. There is absolutley no way she survived being shot in the chest and having her soul ripped out when she was already in such bad shape that she needed life support.

TL;DR this "theory" doesn't make any sense, has no basis in logic or canon, and even if something similar DOES happen (which it most likely won't because it's ridiculous), it's going to be Cinber, not Ambyyhra.