Talk:Whitley Schnee/@comment-26258854-20180407043741/@comment-35555395-20181003025409

@73.Anon.52 Because nothing we've seen so far has proven it and we can't even go for the "it happened off screen" excuse.

Take the talk between Jacques and Weiss for example. When he brings up Beacon and Weiss' trauma the writers could've had him say, "Perhaps your brother was right. It seems the trauma you sustained at Beacon was too much for you." That way we show Whitley scheming behind his sister's back and manipulating the outcome in his favor. But he doesn't do that.

The only character's he interacts with are Weiss (99% of his appearance is conversing with his sister) and the one phone call to Klein. He doesn't ever interact with his father that we've seen or could've been referenced off-screen.

There's no proof that he's done anything to harm Weiss that she hadn't done to herself he's just as much a victim in that house but has less support and resources. Could he be a scheming gremlin? Possibly but nothing presented supports that just fans jumping to conclusions as usual.