Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-24534644-20170213012304/@comment-26397825-20170410000131

Well, Imma catch up on stuff since I finally have a morning off.

@7thSalamander

Menace: It's basically hyperattuned precognition...but Someone is right in that 5 seconds is way too much time. When you're at Winter's level and can attack 3-5 times in a single second, you're basically saying that he is always 15 steps ahead of an enemy. And the death sight; well. If you mean you can see when someone who is perfectly healthy is close to death, it's weird and doesn't fit the semblance. And the 'how that thing died' aspect of Tier 2 is more Psychometry than prediction based, which sorta ties together with the future sight in a roundabout way.

In short, 5 seconds is too long, the second tier's past sight ability feels a bit weird when placed next to a future sight ability, and the third tier just feels shoehorned in for the sake of it.

Petrify: It's OP. Again, as Someone pointed out, you don't even need to petrify an entire person. The White Fang Lieutenant had no issues grabbing Weiss's face for at least two seconds, which would mean her face would be petrified and she wouldn't be able to breath. It only takes a few minutes of no oxygen getting to the brain for there to be permanent brain damage, even if you manage to resuscitate someone. In a few seconds of simply holding their hands to their enemies face they can incapacitate someone permanently.

@Piscean

It feels like my Centrifugal, which does the same thing. An artifical gravity centred around the user that pulls things towards them in a spiralling motion. It even gets the remote location effect in the later tiers. The major difference I can see is that yours needs dust to be able to push things away, whereas mine does it naturally.