Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-6500074-20130310094020/@comment-28277272-20140315052040

Thanks for the welcome. And I've figured I wouldn't start a new thread when one is already talking about what I wanted to talk about, so..

Oh, I haven't seen this intro? Is there anyway I could see it?

But I don't think the fact this fight is a real training actually changes a lot to my theory. Of course, it adds a lot to take account of, but I don't see think it goes against the basic idea. As I said, Weiss's father putting a lot of pressure on her shoulder would explain why she'd punish herself for not meeting her father's expectation (and her own, at the same time). And do you mean he put her through a rough training to show her that life as a huntress would be rough? (I am not going against this statement, I just want to make sure I understand it right). Though, I don't agree with the "Weiss didn't know what aura was" thing. The way I see Weiss, she would totally be studying about it, trying to know as much as she could on the matter. Also, she seemed really competent while fighting the armour, so I believe she had been training/studying to be a huntress for a while. That being said, I still need to watch this unused intro to have a proper opinion on this, I'm just based on what you described.

Even though psychology is important considering the matter, it's still hard to base theories on this, since it's all about interpretation. I admit my theory is mostly based on the fact she is sitting after the hit then falls down. Everything seemed to add up while I was looking for more proofs. But I've also known a whole lot of people (including myself) who have done what I believe Weiss has done, and I think it would totally fit her personality and storyline.

And since I haven't seen a lot of people coming up with this idea (actually, none, I'm just assuming someone out there thought about it and never wrote it down), so I thought it was crazy. Huhu.