Thread:HazelQuill7445/@comment-5430952-20161212222946/@comment-24573226-20161213014636

Hi Alhazad,

Are we talking about the edit or your theory?

As an edit, is inaccurate to describe that scene as Ruby being livid because she learned Cinder is still alive. Nevermind not being a focal point, it didn't even go down that way. Which means, and I say this as gently as possible, it's providing misinformation to add it to an article.

As a theory, since Tyrian acknowledges he knows Cinder by saying "only in her wildest dreams" Ruby, et al might be able to conclude that he knows her now as opposed to only before, but even that would be drawing conclusions on little information. Also, since Tyrian said that after her hostile mentioning of Cinder's name she certainly wasn't reacting to confirmation that Cinder is still alive.

However, if I were attacked by some random dude who mentioned a familiarity with the killer of my friend, I would move forward slightly more inclined to believe that killer is still around somewhere.