Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-27082610-20160416042420

You're right, it's not Mission Impossible, because that had a minimal grounding in reality.

Let's look at it this way: If (and this is a BIG if) some dormant bit of Amber's soul was wrapped up with Pyrrha's, why wouldn't it die with her? Why would it drag her down to a corpse that was injured in a way that no life support conceivable short of literal demi-god level magic  could possible save or even slow the process of its death? And even if that somehow did work, against all logic and with no canon basis for it, she would still be in a heavily injured body that hadn't moved for months, possibly years.

And so she'd have to drag this heavily injured body (while being incredibly disorineted by the fact that she was freakin' dead and the fact that she somehow has two souls that are probably not very happy at their proximity to each other) up a straight ruined elevator shaft to crawl through an abandoned hellscape of monstrosities whose sole purpose, regardless of confusion or fear, (something things without souls wouldn't even be able to feel) is to seek out and destroy all life. And I don't know about you, but I feel like if I got dragged back to life after getting shot multiple times by arrows and failing miserably at the one job I'd assigned for myself, I'd probably be feeling some pretty negative emotions, you know, those things that draw the Grimm in like chum to a bunch of hungry sharks.