Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-10390252-20150427084942/@comment-24993958-20150508145445

DiegoAnime3000 wrote: Nah. There is a difference between just utterly throwing the ending out of the window and not giving the community the happy shipping ending they want. True, but there is also a difference between setting up an ending and throwing one at us, and just like Betrothed, both fics utterly fail at it, although for different reasons.

Their endings had little…scratch that, they had no setup or indication that they were going to happen, and it’s somehow made worse in Inch, a fic that is dedicated to showing us important moments, yet fail to show, or even so much as hint, at the moments that lead to the current ending, oh it hints on the what, but never on the how…let me be clear I’m not calling it a poor ending, but I AM calling it poorly executed to the point it kills it for me.

In the authors own words he didn’t want to use Pyrrha because it would cheapen her character…but because he didn’t put the extra work on Ruby, her character felt even cheaper, and so did the ending. As far as I’m concerned. If he would have simply used Pyrrha I would have had nothing against the ending, but as we both are aware, he did not.