Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-70.164.250.74-20180322215425/@comment-24032889-20180327032951

SomeoneYouUsedToKnow wrote:

1. And then in Vol.5, Oscar outright confronts her about how she doesn't give a damn about what's going on or even about her friends's deaths, and her response boils down to "Eh, didn't know them very long, so whatever". Because apparently watching a friend die in your face doesn't matter shit to you if you only knew them for like 6 months.

2. Found out she has Silver Eyes, a power so strong it severely weakened Cinder for months, a MAIDEN, and at the same time petrified an ancient Grimm in a single flash.

And yet, she never shows any interest in this. Even when Qrow says that Tyrian went after her for her eyes, she doesn't ask him anything about them. Even when she asks Ozpin questions personally, and Ozpin even asks her if she has any (more) questions, she doesn't ask him about them.

3. Saying "she's an honest and simple soul" does not justify her lack of development, even less when everyone else, even secondaries, get noticeable development. 1. She says she does care, but not just about herself. She said she didn't know them for long, yes, but she said Pyrrha and Penny's deaths let her know that she has to prevent future tragedies, not turn tail and run for her own sake. Her reaction was literally the opposite to what you said.

2. Normal kneeeeessss. (but also shitty writing because CRWBY wanted to save talking about that for later/keep fans asking for more even though fans have to ask for too much at this point.)

3. Don't shoot the messenger. I'm not justifying it.