Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-25396609-20160319212213/@comment-26463535-20160324233910

Neill: The character's great overall, fine backstory and weapons, but the semblance doesn't sound RWBYish or even plausible. As far as we know, body parts don't just break off and come back on even with the aid of a rope. That also makes the rope necessary for the semblance to happen, a questionable thing since logically, if you can't have a semblance rely on Dust, you can't have a semblance rely on a random, everyday item in order to function at all. Polarity acts on anything metal and Nora's semblance can handle any kind of electricity.

Maybe a Plastic Man-style semblance would work better in order to do what you want Woddy's semblance to do. I can't think of any real way to make the real semblance work as is, but done right, an elastic power would work.