Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-174.135.62.244-20160603201323/@comment-29137170-20160722100446

SomeoneYouUsedToKnow wrote: It would not be automatically forced. It depends on how well the whole thing is written. It would not make them seem childish nor generic either. "Father issues", they don't have that in common. Jaune doesn't even seem to have any family issues. What they have in common is Legacy; they both have big names to live up to. Jaune has the Arcs, Weiss has the Schnees.

-jaune paired with the girl he liked at the beginning (which was constantly rejected) by mainly superficial reasons would seem childish and has not matured and moved on. -"Mainly superficial reasons". If it happened in Volume 2, they would be superficial. But White Knight did not happen in Volume 2. And in future volumes, any reasons they can have for entering a romantic relationship are not going to be necesarily superficial.

-"Would seem childish and has not matured and moved on". Childish? Nope. "Not matured"? Wrong. The fact that Jaune stopped hounding all over her is proof of maturity. See, the problem was not that Jaune was interested in Weiss and tried to court her, the problem was that he was reaching into harrassment territory while at it.

I would like the typical hero cliche, instead a human character that does not always achieve their goals and not always live up to their expectations I can't tell what exactly you're talking about. Are you saying you want a character that doesn't always achieve their goals or live up to expectations? Cause that's not the "typical hero cliche". Nor would it necesarily be the case here. (And if you meant that, don't say "instead"). Killua102RWBY probably have a duration of 9 to 10 volumes .jaune and Weiss will probably not be until 6 or 7 volume. I mean that their relationship, which has an amount of negative connotations as I put above, would virtually develop from 0 at a time where the whole screen time this probably dedicated to fit the facts accumulated throughout the series, based only similarity they share a concern for their family lineages; which certainly bet that part of the development of character jaune is to overcome this.

Devils could also say jaune should join emerald, based on having / had a mentor figure in cinder / pyrrha that support when nobody believed in them and emerald probably have an arc of redemption at some point; or ruby ​​on the grounds that both had a good relationship from the beginning, both want to be heroes, both lost someone they wanted during the volume 3 and both are going to spend enough time together for the next volume. That really would be a more interesting and less forced romance; and that I'm not even a fan of those ships.

about wanting to jaune not achieve all their dreams to the letter and that his life is not always what he wants. want that because that's what makes it interesting and human, of course I want him to improve himself but in a slow and steady, not sudden and definitely not to the point of becoming a Mary Sue and ends with weiss (the girl already made it clear that is not interested in) would feel like that to me, it would feel as if he was the same insecure boy fulfilling a childhood fantasy come out with the unattainable girl who did not give her the time before, that sounds bad fanfiction for me.

seriously after years of character development, the death of a mentor / romantic interest, a bloody World War / end of the world as we know it and it is assumed that jaune even have to get together at the end of the story with weiss its pseudo love of school, someone told him he did not like from the beginning would appear that Weiss along with out of pity or because she thinks that he is unable to get someone else. jaune would seem obsessed with weiss and unable to move on with life. It sounds like what someone would write when the girl who likes rejects it as an escapist fantasy.

that's why I do not like jaunexweiss