Talk:Jaune Arc/@comment-27470870-20190727223925/@comment-24018437-20190727233153

...Yeah, I don't think so. This theory doesn't make any sense, none of them. First of all, while its true that Ozpin had four daughters, they're not the Maidens. Ozpin stated he gave the Maidens their magic. But he was just as surprised as Salem when he discovered his daughters had magic. And he even stated that the fairy tale is true. So no, the daughters are NOT the Maidens.

Plus, that's not how the Maiden's powers work. They go to the last female they thought about, or otherwise to a random person. So even if somehow the four girls were Maidens and their powers went to a random woman (Salem was to old to inherit the powers), then she would have only gotten the powers. Not the DNA. The powers and the bloodlines of previous Maidens aren't connected. Its either the last person able to gain the powers who gets them, or a random person. Either way, the Maiden powers aren't connected to DNA. At all. And if they died, then they can't become part of the Arc family. That's basic biology. A dead 8-year old can't reproduce.

Second, just because they have blonde hair doesn't mean they're related. By that logic, Jaune should therefore also be related to Sun, Yang and Taiyang. Anything else you mentioned is either ridicilious (like the virgin birth. Plus, why wouldn't a girl be able to carry on the legacy? Remnant is very equal when it come's to gender.) or irrelevent.

Literally the only way for this theory to be even possible in the slightest is if one of the daughters did survive and is the ancestor of the Arc family. And even that needs a lot of streches to work and has plot holes.

I'm sorry, but this is...stupid. Really, really stupid. Its like saying that Cinder and Blake are related because they both have black hair, or that Weiss and Ruby are related because they both have sisters.