Talk:Neopolitan/@comment-26466954-20160103192156/@comment-26466954-20160106023226

Then what do you suggest, Urano? No theories whatsoever and to take the fun out of the mystery in trying to guess what could happen next?

Some fan theories were DEAD ON... from Penny being robotic to mirages being Emerald's semblance. They put these little hints in to see if us fans will catch them, so why should we ignore them?

I admit, the whole Cinder origin about her power coming from the Fall Maiden was impossible to determine by anything they revealed to us prior to the chapter "Fall". But by your logic, you're saying that everything in the show is designed to twist ideas and plot points around to make the next event unpredictable, so we might as well forget about speculation.

There is no reason at all to be such naysayers about theories, and I've seen it on this RWBY board in many other places. Would it kill you to have an open mind and humor us for once?