Talk:Dust/@comment-26317073-20151009010457/@comment-25555436-20151009020439

I can't believe such delusional bullshit.

-Like I said, the glass swords can easily be excused as her Semblance. Hell, I could go right now to the Semblance thread and make that shit. It would be so easy it's almost hilarious.

-Weiss made an Ice Sword with Ice Dust. But that was less of a weapon and more like a stylish spell. I've seen the same thing done a million times in fiction, a spell whose visual effect involves the summoning of a big sword before the spell actually takes place. The sword itself only appears for rule of cool.

Cinder's weapons, however, were true weapons, not just swords but also a bow and arrow. Or what, did I miss any part where Weiss used that Ice Sword to skewer and hack someone to pieces with her own hands?

-The "splash sounds" and that shot splashing like liquid can also work with my point: Use Fire Dust to create liquid-like fire that in practice looks like lava and may well be considered such.

Also, there was fire when she summoned those swords. Obsidian is made when lava cools relatively quickly, with minimal crystal growth. So shouldn't she have used ICE Dust instead? There should have been ice or water, not Fire, when she summoned them, to form Obsidian.