User blog comment:FinalWholockianGrrlGamer/Analysis: Red Like Roses Part II/@comment-3257939-20151021022019/@comment-24113789-20151023023548

Guys, I'm a writer, and I lie. It's okay to lie about fiction stories. In fact, I'm inclined to like a writer better if he can tell a good lie in place of a spoiler. I get a kick out of it.

That being said, I'm not pulling an ad hominem here. I'm just saying you shouldn't take for granted that everything the writers of a story or the songs that go with the story is true.

You want proof? Well, I don't have that. But somewhere in my distant memory I seem to recall Monty saying that Yang and Ruby weren't half sisters. Yeah, that's not really much to offer, but it may or may not support my point.; my point being that my theory still stands, even if it's been outright contradicted by the writers.