User blog comment:Zathronas/Speculative author, Volume 3: Pyrrha Nykos/@comment-3257939-20141126180852/@comment-24218038-20141127054317

I'm sorry but there's a difference between defending and explaining. I will not defend the story I wrote but I will always explain my reasoning behind them.

In this case I see your own plots as those of a fan of a particular sort over another. It has glaring holes in them but for you it's Okay because it fits in your fandom.

And thats quite allright too.

On my end I always try to find if my plots makes sense and if theres any plot holes. Can they be rectified with just a small change or do I have to scrap that idea and start over?

When I disagree with someone and bring up my reasoning why, I'm just seeing where there could be plot holes and bring it up to see if you can plug them or if you even want to. It's nothing personal, That's how I work.

This is how I see RWBY.

Now for your complaints.

I see round 1 as a montage of the various character winning easily their fights.

Now as of Lark, he's still a student at the best Huntsmans school there is. So he has talent or he wouldn't be there.

I understand your point of view as a fan but do you really think fan servicing will make the show better? There's fans for about every possible characters out there and each would want theirs to be in the forefront or in a better light. It is simply impossible for the writers to please everybody so why try it?

I speak from experience here. You just write your story and hope it gets well received by your fans.

I will never, ever try and think from Monty's or any of the show creators perspective. That would be disrespecting them in my opinion. All I write here are from my perspective and where I see the show going. Not Monty and the others BUT I do try to respect the rules they set up for the show since it's their world and I,m just playing in it.

Finally, I really don't much care about the fighting sequence when I write my speculation here unless it's important to the plot. I'm not trying to guess the shoe scene by scene. I,m just giving my perspective on where I think the show is going in an intertaining way.

OUF! sorry for the long post guys but I thought it was time again to explain what are my reasoning to do what I do here.