User blog comment:Braden Wong/A Visual Critique of the Volume 3 Clip from a film school graduate/@comment-4010415-20151009222017/@comment-11188061-20151010001532

... You know, this is told from the point of view of a film critic, so his points are quite valid and professional.

You demand realism (no dust kicked up when people fall on ground etc) when more often than not people who watch films don't care about that. The fact that every actor on every film show manages to look suitably sexy/handsome after going through the apocalypse is already unrealistic. People are willing to suspend their disbelief as long as the show is awesome enough. Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann is fucking ridiculous and yet it's hailed as one of the best animes of its year.

This is not to say that they shouldn't strive for realism since there are some elements of sci-fi in the show that demands it. But for RWBY, whose selling point is its awesome-as-fuck fights, perfect realism to the show's universe isn't exactly what we need.

Not to mention that your tone is bloody offensive at times, and you only pick images that you disagree with. Why don't you talk about the images that you do agree with his point of view? The guy was really professional in his critiques, and your review of his critque feels more 'he's Reddit so he's shit'. Not in this instance.