Talk:Books/@comment-18396318-20140727060022/@comment-18396318-20140727220847

There are some wikis that do take that route. Wookieepedia would be a good example. But if we look at most wikis, Wikipedia included, there's a point where you have to decide if something is actually significant enough to warrant a page. And in RWBY's case, I don't think it is.

If we start to create a page for every book, every object, every food, every stock background character, the information becomes too cluttered, too difficult to maintain, and the valuable information is buried in all the random trivia. This works for Wookieepedia only because there's such a ridiculous amount of officially-published content that it makes sense to have a page for everything. The most important things are going to have a lot of content dedicated to them, and if they don't, they'll get buried anyway. For RWBY, we get 15 minutes or less each week, for only a small portion of the year.

I don't want to sound standoffish, but this page feels to me like it only exists because somebody saw a new episode and wanted to make a new page.