Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-70.64.83.111-20151103022126/@comment-1458758-20151106001439

SpiritedDreaming wrote: Before anyone pipes in with theories of Ruby and Yang not actually being half sisters, read this. Monty himself said that they are half sisters, and that Summer is Ruby's mum. This means that Taiyang must be Ruby's dad, since Summer is not Yang's mum. This means Qrow cannot be anything more than an uncle to Ruby, which means that the Qrow/Summer pairing is incorrect.

For God's sake people, we've been saying this for years by now. ... Not to be murdered for saying this, but that's no guarantee. Qrow and Summer could have easily dated back when they were a team, but broke up. The pairing isn't strictly 'incorrect' it'st just that we know Ruby and Yang's parentage, there's nothing to say that various relationships couldn't have cropped up before then. Maybe Qrow's gay and Taiyang's Bi and being a massive slut he made his way through the whole team fathering two children. We can't say just for the pairing besides the order in which Taiyang fathered Yang and Ruby with Raven and Summer.