Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-27144409-20180525193802/@comment-44248215-20191117062014

Sentry 616 wrote: Finally got around to reading/skimming his backstory and I see some problems.

1 Atlas is the only nation with a military.

2 Atlas just drew more wealth and people. There was no coup, it (Atlas becoming the new capital) was peaceful social change.

3 Atlas academy was never overthrown or overtaken.

4 Atlas doesn't seem to have problems with free enterprise.

5 Grimm don't really have the coordination ot coherence for a true siege.

Remnant need someone to balance Atlas' overwhelming strenth or Atlas will control everything.Onle Vale-the blank Kingdom-is capable to do that.To balance Atlas,Vale also need a military to do so.From geography of Vale we can know that Vale has a urgent demand of Navy to protect its coastline and coastal capital.A single huntsman is not capable for naval combat,only a professional navy can.In conclusion,if Vale is capable.to do so,Vale will build a Navy.

For Atlas Academy,the Clausewitzs opposed it because they lived in Mantle and respect faunus.Atlas being too powerful harmed Mantle residents,including the Clausewitzs.The Clausewitszs also opposed SDC for their questionable behaivor and faunus policy.In fact,after the foundation of Atlas,the Clausewitzs became the centre of Atlesian oppositions.To run away from contious pressure of Atlas,the Clausewitzs ran to Vale,like what Snowden have done,just without being wanted.

For Grimm siege,my expressions is not very precise-in fact,it was a massive horde of Grimm that cut off all land transportation and kept assaulting Crescent port,trying to torn its apart,like what happened to Beacon.

This is the first concept of my under construction AU like the Mantle Guard we have seen before.