Talk:Scarlet/@comment-4010415-20141025160916

Okay, so... I've pretty much decided that the explanation that just might be the most plausible in my mind is that Scarlet is mtf (male-to-female) transexual.

Think about it. The eyes say male, since male characters have small slim eyes, while female characters have big round eyes.

But... the round bump on Scarlet's chest looks like a boob.

I could be wrong, but people don't usually rearrange their face when they change sex, so... maybe Scarlet's eyes are shaped like a guy's eyes because she used to be one.

And maybe people in the RWBYverse don't really take much notice to the whole "Eyes are different depending on sex" thing that we can see. So, while some characters could maybe get a vague "guy" vibe from her, they're mostly going to go along with her identifying herself as a girl.