Talk:Ruby Rose/@comment-71.86.152.110-20151213203941/@comment-27404453-20151215215259

You seem quite irritated by the notion that Ruby could be the Maiden. Why? How does it impact you to make you curse at me when I point out some things that make sense.

1. Ruby's is the only semblance seen thus far that gives a visual effect that doesn't connect to her semblance.

2. I could understand skipping one year, but they had Ruby in that office setting for a relatively short amount of time. You want to convince me that Ozpin managed to not only convince the Headmaster of Signal but also Tai-Yang, and that he got access to her school records from Signal, and that he managed to look through them with enough time to make a good decision about accepting her in what could have only been a couple hours? Yeah, I'm making a hypothesis, but that sounds a lot less likely than what I'm proposing.

3. "Some time off." Obviously one can master a scythe with what little time Qrow would have. Not. To master a weapon like that would take months if not years of continuous instruction to make sure she didn't cut herself open on it. Based on what we've seen of Qrow he doesn't appear to have enough free time to do that.

But if we take my hypothesis everything fits. Her semblance, her acceptance into Beacon, Qrow's ability to teach her. All of them fit.

You on the other hand are trying way too hard to deny the possibility.