Talk:Cinder Fall/@comment-144.13.39.237-20151026194924/@comment-24113789-20151107074718

Sentry's got a point. Her calling it a success is a key factor here. From what we see, it looked like a total failure. Ruby said that "a lot of people were hurt", but never said that anyone was killed; if anyone had been, I'd expect Ruby of all people to remark on it. Casualties are unfortunate, but without fatality it doesn't do much for the enemy. There were some damages to the city, but not much of a disaster. So at what, exactly, did they succeed?