Talk:Nuckelavee/@comment-70.164.250.74-20170921180915/@comment-25936766-20170922230734

That idea assumes that in years, maybe more than a decade, no Huntsman worth something ever tried to fight it "smartly" or with a team, like RNJR did. Which is stupid.

Do note RNJR are, at most, only 2nd Year Huntsmen-in-Training, in terms of power, training and skill.

We've seen what Profesional, Graduated Huntsmen can do. Qrow is an example, and characters like Tyrian, Cinder and possibly Adam are on the same/similar level. They all have far more experience, skill, training and/or strength than all of RNJR combined.

Your idea implies that none of those people with years more experience and power than RNJR ever fought the Nuckelavee, and it also implies that those who did couldn't beat it.

Meanwhile, 3 people who didn't even finish their 1st year at Beacon, + 1 who's barely starting to be worth something in battle, killed it with no casualties or injuries.