Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-98.199.152.111-20150114055618/@comment-25555436-20150118012341

Interesting theory. Could work for a fanfic. But let me tell you this: Songs are not solid, canon evidence. Word of God and the show itself are, obviously, but the songs are not.

Let's take Time To Say Goodbye as an example. Read the lyrics, then watch the entire Volume 2. Nothing the lyrics said, happened. Same with Red Like Roses part 2; The lyrics seem to pretty clearly imply Ruby was devastated for her mother's death. Now, watch the show. Ruby doesn't look even remotely devastated or even sad, her mother's death didn't seem to affect her idealism or dream in even the slightest way, she doesn't even talk about Summer. Ironic, don't you think?

My point here is, that the songs are not a solid evidence to make theories. Using songs as the only evidence, it's not enough to make a theory, at most an hypothesis. Now, if you do have something said in the show or by Monty, you could use the songs to further analyze that. But by themselves, they are not strong enough.

Now, personally, I think your hypothesis there, it's too vague for the moment for me to take it seriously and give it actual thought. But if you later have anything else to add to it, do it, then I'll read it to see if it's enough to consider it a theory.