Talk:Semblance/@comment-28713246-20171121021821/@comment-25936766-20171121032907

Oh, sweet summer child, don't copy-paste my words and throw them back at me to try to sound smart. They just make it more obvious you couldn't make a good comeback.

You literally said that Weiss "can reincarnate into" a light-form warrior of anyone she kills. Quite obviously, Weiss doesn't reincarnate at all, even less into those "warriors".

So yeah, you have no idea of what "Reincarnating" and "Into" mean. Get a dictionary before trying to talk shit back to others.

Or learn how to use the Enter button. It's very simple-stupid, but apparently you're so high and mighty that you're so above doing something as simple as separating a wall of text into multiple paragraphs.

I'll explain it to you again: Only the enemies that led to Personal growth on the user can be Summoned. Or to put it in Winter's words, "The ones who forced you to push past where you were, and become who you are now".

In theory, even an insignificant mook could fit that criteria. But not every single enemy they kill will fit it.

Now, regarding your argument at the end, you're looking at it backwards. It's not "Personal growth, then kill random enemy". It's "Kill random enemy, that led to personal growth".

It's as vague as it sounds, but at the same time, it's clear enough that it's not just any random mook one kills, but specifically the ones that led, one way or another, to personal growth as a person. It's not convenient, if anything it's inconvenient.

The Knight did it, more-or-less directly, as it was effectively a Rite of Passage, a test of her skill to see if she could really defy her father and choose her own path.

The Boarbatusk more indirectly. The fight itself didn't involve Personal Growth, but it's related to Weiss's first real character development in the show, and the moment she decided to become a better Teammate instead of just a rich bitch.

Now, all those random Beowulves she killed in Mt. Glenn? They didn't lead to or cause any sort of Personal Growth on Weiss at all, so they can't be Summoned. They were just enemies she killed, with nothing special to them or the situation.