Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-26397825-20161227080015/@comment-25936766-20170111144713

1)Aria of the Soul by LiveandSound

2)Armor Master by HookshotHotshot

3)Asp Royale by Phantomlink959

4)Assemblage by Phantomlink959

5)Astral Shredder by Blu3 Fir3 – V2.0

6)Audio by ACWeapons

7)Augment by JadenLan

8)Aura Reserve by Master Moridin

9)Aural Spark by LiveandSound

10)Aurasmith by LiveandSound 1) Basically a sound-based Allure. YES

@Phantom: Too long? The name's like 6 sounds at most. And made of very short words, bisyllables at worst.

2) The T1 and T2 of that Semblance are good. The T3, not at all. One cannot make a functional handgun just like that. So overall YES, but update is needed.

3) Not a complete fan of the name. Sounds rather silly. But the effect itself is good. YES

4) "Welding" feels way too general.....there's different kinds of welding. Leaning on YES, but some extra clarification wouldn't hurt.

-

5) I like the effect, but....I'd prefer if the activation cue got updated. I mean, at the very most I can only picture is as someone having their arm surrounded by a bit of light and suddenly can slice things up without any kind of blade-like element.

I'd prefer something more...obvious-looking. Like, a blade or 2 of Aura appearing on the arm, and being the ones that slice instead of seemingly the whole arm/leg. So Yes, but update/clarification is preferred.

-

6) I see nothing wrong with Audio. It's one of those "so simple and practical, how can it not work?" kind of Semblances. YES. Though I'm not sure it's really a "Physical" Semblance.

7) ....Mmm....2 questions: 1) Can't people already envelop objects, like their weapons, in Aura? 2) Didn't I post a Semblance once, long ago, that was basically the exact same thing as Augment once?

One that pretty much got rejected on the grounds of "It sounds like an Aura Technique, something people can do without Semblance". Sounds very unfair. If mine got rejected for those reasons, why should Augment be accepted when it's the exact same thing?

---

8) Sounds good, but the limitations seem...excessive. T1: "25% of user's max. Aura, takes 3 days to form"? I say YES, but those limitations should be made less...heavy.

-

9) Mmm....I think this one is from before this community reached the consensus of "If Blade Beams can be done with Aura, other kinds of Aura Beams can be done too".

Or at least, that's what I assume, given Spirit there said she liked it, Phantom didn't point out any problems, and Vedran himself said it was "so safe", "balances itself out", "can be combined with Dust so respects canon", with the only thing he said he could really comment on being the fact it has the form of a lightning bolt.

So whether it's accepted or not depends entirely on whether this community thinks Semblances of that kind are possible, or it's just a glorified Aura Technique that could in theory be done without Semblance.

PS: I also discovered Vedran knows how much is the attention span of a cat having an orgasm.

-

10) I see no real problems with Aurasmith. Yes.