Thread:Megadracosaurus/@comment-39235796-20190611144055/@comment-24018437-20190611150307

First of all, Roman is dead. He can literally do nothing. If Salem could resurrect people, literally nothing in the show would have happened because she would have just brought Ozma back to life. So the entire scenerio of replacing Roman with Tyrian makes absolutely no sense whatsoever and is, quite frankly, dumb.

Second, its OOC for Salem to allow this to happen. Look at all the times she dealt with failures. Cinder was merely exiled and Hazel was threatened for arguably WTCH's biggest failure in the series. To execute Tyrian for his very first (known) failure while he was still usefull to her and genuinely loyal (as Salem seems to appreciate and reward genuine loyalty) would be a waste of resources.

Third and last, Roman wouldn't nearly be important enough to replace Tyrian. He was merely a replaceble pawn who wasn't all that well-informed about what Salem's plan was, and it seems likely he didn't even know the true identity of Cinder's leader. People often like to think that Neo, Roman or Adam would become part of Salem's inner circle, but none of them are even important enough to consider. Even if Roman survived, he'd just remain a pawn. Roman himself even admits that the only reason he'd Also, Tyrian is an excellent fighter, even without his stinger. I doubt he would be defeated by Roman so easily.

And before you bring up Cinder again, she failed even worse then Tyrian. Because of her own pride and stubborness, the assault on Haven failed, the White Fang was defeated and disbanded (and as a result, Salem lost a lot of influence and pawns), their goal and organisation nearly revealed to the world, she lost Lionheart (which, again, caused her to lose a lot of resources) and it cost her the Relic of Knowledge. Cinder's failure was far, far worse then Tyrian...and she got exiled.

We see Salem's followers fail and none of them (with the exception of those that aren't true followers and have nothing to offer anymore, like Lionheart) have been executed. So its unrealistic that Tyrian would be brutally executed by a dead guy who Salem doesn't give a rats ass about while others have failed much, much more.

Its clear that your hatred of Tyrian and your love of Roman is overriding your common sense. This is the type of fanfiction you'd exspect from someone who never watched the show, is extremely attached to a character in particular and therefore looks at everything through rose-colored glasses. Its easily one of the worst and dumb RWBY fan ideas and fanfictions I've ever read.

My advice: Move on. Its been years since Roman died and he isn't coming back. To cling so much onto a fictional character to the point you beg CRWBY to let him return years after he died in a way that makes no sense whatsoever is nothing short of pathetic and a waste of your time.