Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24934890-20180911200208/@comment-24934890-20180913204517

73.Anon.52 wrote: I don't think it adds anything to the narrative at all tbh, at best it would be the 2 deadbeat parent Siblings shuffling their kids off on their teammates and then raising the douchebaggery to 11 by even refusing to properly parent after even 1/half of their other teammates die, it makes Raven/Qrow even more important while stealing even more of the MC's thunder... it would just be all around terrible for the story RT is trying to tell about RWBY, and not about STRQ. yeah, not to mention he'd be a total hypocrite if he were her dad. He chews out Raven for being a bad mom, when he himself left his daughter with his teammate, and making her think someone who isn't her dad is, and spends most of his time away from her, and on missions. And if he were her dad, I'm pretty sure Raven would have said something about it to Yang in volume 5.

Why in the world people still believe this theory is beyond me.