Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170918133425/@comment-25936766-20170930232003

73.Anon.52 wrote: 1- Assuming she somehow didn't know about the influence there further indicates she didn't live there, if she had, she would have realized sympathisers like herself could be there.

2- Who said anything about Menagerie not being one of the many places she lived before?

3- "This small island where our kind call home: Menagerie..." quoted by you earlier from the script.

4. ....In Menagerie where Blake was certain she wouldn't encounter the WF? or literally "outside" the kingdoms, in villages the WF controls/protects, or facilities like the one in Mt. Glenn. 1) That argument falls flat the moment it begins once you read what I actually said.

"It's logical that the "WF in Menagerie" stuff is more recent than expected. Why would a group that used to protest for Fair Treatment of Faunus go protest in the Faunusland of the world where Faunus Discrimination does not exist???"

The WF only turned violent around 5 years before RWBY begins. And before turning violent, they protested. And why would they protest in the Faunusland where no Faunus is ever discriminated at all?

2) Not "who". "What". Because if she lived in many places throughout her life, why would she call Menagerie specifically her "home", and not say her home is "Anima" or "Mistral", for example?

3) Absolutely wrong quote. Volume 4 Episode 3, when Sun and Blake are on the ship. Read the transcript.

4) .........Or, Menagerie, which is, quite literally, outside the Kingdoms. Even villages like Kuroyuri are within Kingdom Territory. Menagerie is literally separated from the other kingdoms by the ocean, and they don't even have a CCT.

She has a father, she has a mother, and she lived on an island whose wild-life, let alone Grimm, were dangerous. You'd think she would've been taught how to fight, even if Adam polished whatever skills she had later. Like she said, "if you can't fight, you can't survive".

And in any case, there's a difference between "I was raised outside the Kingdoms" and "I was trained by some guy".