User blog comment:ChishioKunrin/Volume 3 Episode 3 Sneak Peek/@comment-27087951-20151107205543/@comment-27087951-20151110131351

IMO, they need to be more unique, the Semblances. Comparing them to people's personalities is not quite a fully convincing argument to me. People differ not just by personality, but by attitude, likes, dislikes, fears, fetishes, goals, skills, capabilities both physical and mental.....there are so many factors that can differ that even 2 identical people can be different from each other.

But, Semblances don't have that many factors. Andd here we have been shown a Semblance that is identical to Weiss's in every way. Not just the effect, even the visual effect is identical. There are no differences, at all. It's more than just very similar, it's a damn clone.

"Way it's used" doesn't count for me. If one kicks a ball with their left foot or their right foot, it doesn't matter, the ball will still be a ball, it won't change what it is. Sure, it was used differently, but the point is not how you used the thing, but about the thing itself. In this case, Semblance, which Winter also used in the same way Weiss does, for the same purpose even.