Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-24993958-20151106142232/@comment-26463535-20151107212753

Phantom has always been the extreme critic (with Live joining him occasionally) while Spirited, Vedran, and others are the nicer "how we can improve/salvage this OC, OC is not salvageable" critics and Ghost and I are practically greenhorns still. Sometimes an extreme critic is most effective and if he likes the idea behind the OC, he can be more mellow. It's only when you do something blantently against RWBY's in-universe rules or something utterly cliched or both that he really explodes. Vedran's Speculative blogs are a good resource for what conclusions can be made from what we know about Remnent.