Talk:Remembrance/@comment-4023909-20161031021013/@comment-4010415-20170110123649

Except sound tends to carry when the air is still. The only noise up there at the time was Cinder and Pyrrha. There were no Grimm flying around stirring up the air. There was no sound of fighting or gunfire because the students and White Fang had already left to evacuate. Ruby could've heard it, and it could've been quiet and distant enough that she couldn't quite tell what they were saying, but the sound still replayed in her dream. Honestly, Ruby got there pretty damn soon after that exchange, so obviously she wasn't that far away from the top.