Talk:Cinder Fall/@comment-172.56.39.39-20151216164400/@comment-4010415-20151221082344

I agree, a soul stealing Semblance does not make sense and would not fit.

People generally have Semblances they can use to aid themselves in combat situations.

Ruby uses her speed Semblance to quickly charged toward and attack an enemy, hopefully catching them off guard.

Weiss uses her glyphs for a number of purposes - being too quick for her enemy to hit, speed boost to attack or catch up with an enemy, more precisely manipulating Dust, time dilation, and someday summoning.

Blake uses her Shadow clones to distract her enemy, dodge their attacks, for better mobility in the air and around the battlefield, and even to take hits for her (she actually even did that in Black and White. Roman punched a clone in the face instead of her, at the last second).

Yang... Self-explanatory.

Nora, also self-explanatory.

Pyrrha uses her Semblance on her shield quite often, to get it to return to her arm. She also uses it against anything else she can to help her attack or dodge.

Sun's clones attack for him.

Someone can produce illusions or hallucinations, which can confuse and distract their enemy.

Basically, so far, we've seen that Semblances are things that come from the user in various ways. A soul stealing Semblance does not match. It would be taking something from someone else into the user.