Talk:Yang Xiao Long/@comment-26838620-20150901052756/@comment-25555436-20150903023535

Oh, so you believe that? I told you, atheists do believe. For a man who said that it stood for lack of belief, you sure are a believer.

You have got to be a bloody ignorant if you think that is all that it takes to be considered alive. But think. That is only the criteria from a biological point of view. You are ignoring most PoVs if you only believe in that one, or rather enforce that that is the only one that can be considered being right.

Let's say someone's Soul was ripped off from them. Their body would still be alive and beating, it would keep working like any other living person, except that it's just a husk. It can't do anything, it can't think anything, it can't even feel anything, because it lacks it's Soul, it's a human version of an empty box now.

If you believe in just the Biological criteria, then it would still be alive.

But from a diferent, less ignorant PoV, it would not be alive, or would be both alive physically and dead mentally.