Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-26397825-20160419024928/@comment-24534644-20160423013426

@Hookshot

I was about to say that myself, too similar to Dust talents, before you made that edit. That's why elemental powers are so iffy to me. The air compression thing was feasible in my eyes because so far as we've seen, Wind Dust only generates air currents. But resemblances that straight up allow control over hot and cold when there is a miracle powder that lets anyone do that as is just doesn't sit right.

@Arkanto

When I first read that post of yours, I though "so Songbird from Marvel?", until I realized they weren't generating actual objects, only mimicking the sounds they made. If it's auditory illusions as Hookshot says, then it'd be better to say THAT instead of "sculpting", because Sculpting implies a physical, tangible object more often than not. Other than that, illusion semblances are already a thing in Canon, so I see no problem with it. Given that Hearing is the human's second most-relied-on sense for things like navigation, I can imagine how it'd screw with people's heads when properly applied. For maximum effect however, try not to restrict it to simply mimicking noises. Hearing has deep psychological effects on the mind if you get the right sounds going, and you could potentially disorient someone and throw off their equilibrium until their literally tripping over themselves. Of course, that seems like more of an advanced usage for the Semblance, but it's there.