Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24934890-20180911200208/@comment-27312496-20180915184609

You know it is possible for children not to pick up any quirks from their parents. I would say I don't share very many with mine. Tai can be an intensive father and Ruby still wouldn't pick up on his traits.

Ruby looks nothing like Qrow. She is identical to her mother. Having the same color scheme in no way says he is her father. And if you say "well they have black hair" that would be like saying that Tai is really Jaune and Sun's father just because they are blond hair. Tai leaving the room because he knew Qrow would tell her was a begrudging thing because Tai knew she was going to find out any ways.

And so what if Qrow semblance is bad luck. Why would he have to keep being her father a secret? Clearly he could be around enough to have an impact on both Ruby and Yang's lives with how they are with him. No need for any secrecy.

Which now brings me back to what I must always ask about this theory. Why the secrecy? What is the point of Qrow, Tai, Summer and even Raven keeping Qrow being Ruby real father a secret from Ruby and Yang. What is the point?

And no matter how much you want this theory to be true it doesn't change that was debunked long before it even existed. Before there even was a theory Monty stated that Ruby and Yang were half sisters with different mothers. The only way for Qrow to be Ruby's father is if he was Yang's as well. Meaning he would have had to have an incest relation with his sister. Miles and Kerry have also out right stated that Qrow is not her father that she just looks up to him. The theory was dead before it even could crawl.