User blog comment:Lawrence.solomon.5/Cinder Fall = Fallen Summer rose Theory/@comment-4010415-20140908154429

Cinder Fall can't really be Summer Rose, who is Ruby's mother. You wanna know why? Monty said Cinder isn't much older than the Beacon students.

She's most likely in her early 20s, which is really awkward because Ruby is 15. Cinder was a child when Ruby was born.