Talk:Blake Belladonna/@comment-28171999-20181120155724/@comment-4136655-20181121234825

How many times do we need to tell you old man, that we have two instances of fall within the series? You keep ignoring the passage in time of RWBY, time and time again. Volume 3 is in fall, and ends in late fall/winter evidenced by the snow on the ground. Yang, Blake, and Weiss were all confirmed to be 17 by the start of the series (assumed for Nora, Ren, and Jaune as well), meaning they were 17 before fall. Volume is before the Fall Semester, and Volume 6 starts right at the beginning, so we know that it's currently fall, and a year within the show has passed.

Also, again to what Phantomlink959 said, the number of months is irrelevant to this (hell everyone is simply say a year, never saying months). Even if Remnant's revolution (the time it takes for a planet to make it around the Sun once) is longer than the Earth's, it would still have the same seasons, and it would be impossible for the seasons to repeat while Remnant is in revolution in such a short amount of time anyway. The seasons occur due to the axial tilt of the planet, which while it does oscillate (Earth's axial tilt slightly oscillates between 22-24 degrees), major changes would take millions of years, even more with a moon. Earth's axial tilt is not expected to reach 90 degrees for billions of years. Remnant having an axial tilt that oscillates that quickly and drastically would be impossible.