Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-26397825-20160528034745/@comment-24993958-20160601135848

Yes but Physics and Psychology on Remnant still utilizes the same principles as the ones in our world.

Fire still burns, water is still liquid, birds are still birds and hypnosis is still hypnosis, and it working without the cooperation of the other user would be like if someone started a run of the mill fire while submerged in water.

That isn’t to say we haven’t allowed persuasion styled semblances before, but as a separate semblance from one that influences emotions, as the semblances needs to be catered to target those specific areas. What you are trying to do is brush off established rules of an element you are using with “its fictional x so it doesn’t have to follow the rules x normally has to”

