Board Thread:Episode Discussion/@comment-34633327-20171216025048/@comment-4010415-20171219195739

40.133.161.229 wrote: 2. Why did Ozpin have to talk to Qrow?

So Qrow can tell him that all the huntsmen are dead? That doesn't make any sense and it didn't need to happen. wtf. There could have been a lot more condensed version where Ruby just walks up to Oscar and asks him about the Beacon relic. Remember, Oscar has all the memories that Ozpin has. We know this from when Oscar described the tea set at Haven. Very convoluted scene.

3. The kali fight scene doesn't even count as a fight it was so crappy.

6. Ghira punching the fox's fists are entirely unrealistic and uncool.. What would have been better is if Ghira was left handed and the fox was right handed. They both punch and Ghira's punch breaks the fox's arm.

9. Ship captain?!!!?!?! What?! How do you know where he is? The CCT is down! How is he still in Menagerie? WHAT!? How are you going to contact him???!!! I hate that last line SOOOO much. 2. Not convoluted. Qrow was updating Ozpin on the situation. Also, is it so hard to believe that the two of them would hang out and discuss what's going on over coffee/hot chocolate?

Besides, previously in this volume, they did not do a great job making it clear that the Huntsmen that Qrow was looking for were all dead. They only hinted at it, but it went over a lot of people's heads, and those people insisted that it's possible that Qrow just meant he couldn't believe they were all on missions and unavailable. In this episode, he finally comes right out and says "They're all dead, which doesn't make sense".

I'd be very interested if this is foreshadowing that the person or thing that's been killing them all will be at the attack on Haven.

3. It was also the dumbest part of the episode, in my opinion. Why was she standing in the middle of the room during a gun fight, while the guards were hiding behind pillars like sensible people? Why were the White Fang members too stupid to shoot her legs while she held that tray up? What would've made more sense is if they had that table they drank tea at in Volume 4 turned on its side and broken to where Kali couldn't completely hide behind it without lying on the floor.

6. Corsac's Aura would've prevented Ghira from breaking his arm. Ghira, meanwhile, did not have any Aura left, hence his Aura shimmering in the previous episode and Fennec actually being able to create a wound on his back.

9. Ships have courses they follow and ports they regularly stop at. Considering Blake has been there for apparently months, she may have learned the captain's schedule and knows when he'll stop by Menagerie's port again.

Wouldn't it be fucked up if destroying one of the Relics also destroys the gift in mankind that it represents? Like, if you destroy Choice, they no longer have the ability to choose. I know that'd be kinda weird and dumb, but it just popped into my head.