Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-31098022-20171029034247/@comment-31098022-20171101225927

Are you saying that Qrow wasn't already going all out? He even ordered the kids to stay back. Plus Qrow can't control his semblance and we probably shouldn't assume that the bad luck is unrealistic like meteor comes out of the sky. Tyrian has had a lot of tough fights too we can assume. In fact he was sent to acquire a maiden and one of those killed Ozpin. Neither would have any qualms about killing the other.

I think Tyrian would win because first of all we can assume they both started the fight with roughly the same amount of energy as Tyrian fought RNJR and Qrow took on many Grimm along the way. They both also had their aura broken at roughly the same point but Tyrian took a hit from Nora and I doubt the Grimm were able to touch Qrow.

Tyrian disarmed Qrow and when Ruby distracted Tyrian Qrow got those punches in.

Qrow only lost because his semblance had affected Ruby but that doesn't mean he would have won without her there.

Also we don't really know what Tyrian's semblance is.

That's why I think Tyrian would ultimately take the fight.

What do you think about my points?