Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27684451-20161121042030/@comment-27082610-20161212160109

70.198.47.251 wrote: 1) Debating generally entails offering a counter theory as well as just shooting down theiress, the over all point is there have only been three theories posted, and the main responders seem to be offering no theory of their own on the thread just tearing down the others which is counter productive to the conversation. 2) It's not the questioning of theories that bothers me it's the lack of any counter theory, why read arrogant nd respond if you don't have arrogant nd theory of your own, additionally is it not childish to respond with insults and calling some one childish.

3) And alright we'll do this another way, had cinder flash fried her as such she should based on relevant physics turned to ash not magical glowing particles.

4) Secondly qrow is bit always straight forward he could have been insinuating raven had the spring maiden, but why is the spring maiden so important why wouldn't raven have the summer maiden or winter maiden is that not another valid possibility? Or perhaps some as people like to point out unrelated character.

5) Thirdly, you can draw the conclusion that qrow beleives raven has information about the spring maiden but not necessarily that the maiden is with her, the powerful people could have been a continuing jab at her being there and letting someone else do the work similar to his jabs about being a bad mother

6) Next, the relic being discussed wouldn't make springer see to be ozpin cane necessarily since they were all springenseearching for it signifying that it's where abouts was semi unknown where ozpin cane was clearly out in the open for quite some time and presumably had it been the relic cinder would have taken it after her fight with ozpin, sje seemed pretty confident she had killed him initially or at least confident in her abiliteis at that time, so in theory she would have taken his cane sonce qrow didnt seem to have any problem finding it and he was halfway across the city at that point so surely were it important cinder would have taken it 1) No, no it does not. It entails arguing the points brought up by whatever the other person said. Saying one person's theory is wrong by using your own theory as evidence against is asinine.

2) Again, you do not need to make counter theories to question theories that are submitted. All you really need is a subscription to Occam's Razor.

3) That was ash she disolved into, it's just that there was a touch of glowing because of artsy-fartsy reasons.

4) Because maybe each maiden lives on within their own continet/kingdom. Winter dwells in the frozen wastes of Atlas, Spring in the lush greenery of Anima/Mistral, Fall in the vibrant reds of Vale, and Summer in the burning deserts of Vaccuo. And since taking down Vaccuo and Atlas present fairly difficult problems, the next target would obviously be Mistral, so the Spring maiden would be the new priority. And since Qrow knows Raven knows about the maidens and would be able to recognize the powers of one, it stands to reason she'd know if one was in her tribe.

5) Qrow explicitly said that he wasn't talking about Raven. The fact that the jab was followed by a request for information on Spring implies that she's with Raven.

6) Okay I can't even understand what you're saying in this paragraph.