User blog comment:Darkcloud1111/Good Idea, Bad Idea~Field Trip/@comment-9464517-20140930182953/@comment-24994749-20140930203149

I didn't take their reaction as "not liking this guy" but that he didn't fit their image of what a "real huntsman" would look like.

Aside form that they seem to only know him in the role of history teacher (not the most 'exiting' subject when you are studying a career focused in field work), the way he was dressed probably doesn't square with what Weiss is used to in terms of "professional", or Yang and Ruby when they compare him to Qrow, Blake is a wild card, but if her mentor figure was Adam...