Talk:Cinder Fall/@comment-4383890-20180501215519/@comment-4383890-20180501232145

I kind of see your point about Vernal and Lionheart not getting proper backstories (though we can pretty much imagine how Lionheart ended up where he is), but unlike them, who only appeared during Volume 5, Cinder was much more prominent from the beginning and was pretty much groomed by Salem to be her star pupil. From a storytelling perspective, unless they end up using Emerald in her place, it wouldn't make sense for Cinder to be written off so casually. Though even if she is dead, there are ways to flesh out a character's backstory that don't involve the character actually being alive.