Talk:RWBY: Amity Arena/@comment-29907776-20180607140308/@comment-24202917-20180616120832

Ironwood would have enrolled Penny in Atlas Academy in order for her to be allowed entry into the festival tournament, and we know from Volume 5 that Emerald was given access by Lionheart, implying that she, Cinder, Neo and Mercury were listed as students of Haven. I love Qrow, but we already have a scythe-wielder in Ruby and plenty of swords to fight with. Besides, I think it would have been fitting to keep to the show and only have students competing.