Thread:Kirito Rose/@comment-99.156.168.24-20170610214602/@comment-25936766-20170611031921

99.156.168.24 wrote:

1-But this place doesn't seem any different from r/RWBY or the Discord servers; people are so sick of hearing theories they get mad as soon as they hear I've got one.

2-You people are so burned out on RWBY, the show you're supposedly fans of, that you've become antagonistic to the very *idea* of hope...

3-...which is apalling considering it's the exact opposite of the message I believe the show is trying to send.

4--I don't understand why so many people are so proud of being dismissive and pessimistic.

5-I believe I misunderstood SomeoneYouUsedToKnow making a dumb pun on their name and thought they meant they might be open to listening, but they deleted the thread I started on their page in reply and that sunk much of what I'd started to write to them.

6-They basically dared me to post to the current Penny thread

7-with the statement that no evidence that Penny is coming back exists,

8-and I'll admit I took a long hard look at that thread, but I'm way past being willing to perform for people who try and goad me into dumping my information for them while they salivate over the chance to rip it apart.

9-It doesn't matter if I prove them wrong on a few concrete points I've got solid material for;

10-the real battle is getting people to *want* there to be a happy ending, and to look forward to what's to come in RWBY, and I've already lost that battle. You are making so many assumptions not just on this community, but on the fandom as a whole, it's ridiculous.

1-People don't mind theories. But people do mind it when someone comes with a "theory", about something that has already been answered and/or simply cannot happen. Especially when weak, or no concrete evidence, is given.

RT already said that Pyrrha is dead, and even if she wasn't spiritually dead, her body became ashes, scattered in the wind, so there's not even a body to revive anyway.

When Pyrrha died, many kids cried in anguish everywhere and posted theories with ridiculous logic and arguments to try to convince themselves that Pyrrha could be alive, or be revived. These theories stand on no solid ground, and most in the fandom have already gotten tired of those theories.

2-Complete assumption, fallacious and generalizing. Besides, being "burned out on RWBY" has nothing to do with someone "being antagonistic to the very idea of hope" (which is not the case here or anywhere at all, either way, unless we're talking about the Writing). There's literally no connection.

3-And what message would that be?

4-There is no pessimism here. Only realism, accepting the facts for what they are, as negative as they are. We are dismissive of "Pyrrha is alive" theories because: Read point 1.

5-Read point 1. Trying to discuss such bullshit like "Pyrrha is alive" theories on my wall, is like trying to respond to spam, for me. Since I'm not forced to have spam on my wall, I deleted it.

Meanwhile, with the Penny-related question, I'm more inclined to respond, since at the very least it can happen, she can come back in a believable way.

6-No I didn't. The most I said about that thread was that we had already discussed about Penny, mainly her revival, in that thread.

7-Which is a fact, because (and you happily avoid mentioning this bit) you said that she is coming back. As if it was a fact that it would happen.

Since no one can see the future, and Miles and Kerry can fail at using up the show's good potential, nothing says it will happen. When you consider her nature as a robot and how Atlas can at least make another Penny, she can come back, which is literally what I said: She can, but nothing says she will.

Learn semantics.

8-Take a look at the second pic in this post.

9-"Concrete points". "Solid material". That's, in your opinion, I take it? What is solid for you could well actually be a gas for anyone who bothers analyzing the theory.

10-You didn't lose the battle. Because there never was such battle. Some people want more drama, others want less drama. Some want a happy ending, others want something more "mature and bittersweet".

But: First of all, that happens with nearly every show. And second of all, it's irrelevant to these theories.