Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-24993958-20151027072937/@comment-26023629-20151031004030

No, something you describe can still not make sense. You can describe how holistic medicine is supposed to work, but it still does not make sense.

What I mean about abilities just happening is that in the universe, people do not actively create them. Therefore any rules or restrictions they have would naturally be defined by concepts that exist outside of human arbitration.

All the abilities in RWBY are based in something measureable that exists in the world. Polarity, magnetism. Speed, velocity. Yang's thing, force, action, and reaction. Blake makes another one of her. Weiss is the weird one, but aura can make tangible objects (passive aura protection) so that's what I assume they are.

Without someone to make it up, your concept of "action" does not have any inherent basis in the reality of our world or RWBYs.

Aura doesn't regenerate that fast. Look at every occastion in the entire series that aura levels have been shown. There is absolutely no visible regenerating of aura going on. Aura does regenrate, but it's much too slow for someone to regain 45% of it mid-combat.

I get that it's not for anything. I get that it's just an idea. I'm saying that this is the RWBY wiki. We're talking RWBY here. The fact that you posted it here implies that you wanted it analyzed in the context of RWBY.

I've got nothing against the idea, but I think it's not a good RWBY idea. That's why I criticise. But if it's not supposed be in the RWBY world, then there's no point in me discussing it here any longer.