Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-75.162.230.203-20171102052825

I would like to share a perspective of the Qrow is Ruby's biological father theory. It is not my intention to cause any problems, so if you don't like what I have to say, just ignore me.

All this is just spectulation. Qrow's semblance is misfortune. As stated on this page, it makes him distance himself from the people he cares about, so they don't get hurt. If Ruby was his daughter, his semblance would make his hesitant to raise her himself, for fear that he would end up hurting her. The bad blood he was shown to have with Tai could be that he asked for him to pose as Ruby's father, forcing him to act like he was in love with Summer (he probably did love her by the time she died, since Yang said he "shut down" after her death). Qrow is shown to have many traits shared with Ruby, including her behavior (Yang shares some behaviors with Raven despite not having been raised by her, so some of it can be genetic), colors (clothing, aura), and weapon choice. Qrow also taught Ruby how to use a scythe (he is mentioned to care about family, and wouldn't want to outright abandon her), while Tai taught Yang to fight. Qrow also seems to be more protective of Ruby, following her during volume 4 to look after her and keep her safe. Qrow also had enough authority over Tai to kick him out of the conversation where he told Ruby about her silver eyes, even though it was a situation where Tai should have held authority over Qrow. But what really makes me question is why Yang recieved her surname from Tai, but Ruby got her surname from Summer, if they were both Tai's daughters. I think that could be because Tai didn't want to give his name to someone who wasn't his blood, and she didn't recieve Qrow's because he didn't want her to know she was his, so she got Summer's instead. Not to mention Yang and Ruby are only 2 years apart, so if Tai was Ruby's dad, he would have to have gotten over Raven and slept with Summer give or take 15 months after Raven left him with newborn Yang. This explanation makes Tai and Raven Yang's parents, and Qrow and Summer Ruby's parent. Monty's comment that Yang is Ruby's half sister would actually still be true as they are half sisters through adoption, and that would probably be how they would always see themselves even if they found out they were actually cousins. No other information has been explictily given to disprove this theory, so for the people who say it has already been disproven, that is also just spectulation. Thanks for reading!