Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160215042739/@comment-5430952-20160624223847

8.23.154.5 wrote: I don't think this is solid evidence of a tragic past, however if you pay attention to Cinder's expression change in vol 3 episode 11 where she first confronts Ozpin, it sounds like she truly believes he is evil or something along those lines. I believe this suggests Cinder felt she was wronged in some way by Ozpin, his associates, or the powers that be in Remnant. Possibly, it's brought up in her character song, Sacrifice. Essentially, she's saying her life isn't theirs, or possibly his, for the taking. And though I'm certain she didn't tear up, her expression definitely changed when Pyrrha asked if she believed in destiny. As one poster said on youtube, no one as young as her should possibly this hateful, unless something truly tragic happened in her past. I'm certain we'll find out the whole truth in the next volume or two, but we'll see.