Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-14138255-20151129182644/@comment-24994749-20151202021940

A false dichotomy! Now I'm mad I didn't see. I knew there was a particular thing that threw me off and had me so convinced that Winter's speech was not positive.... and so I went on my mega rant.

Yeah, the way the first option is phrased makes it sound like it's pretty easy to get the allowance back without really having to sacrifice the stay at Beacon. I, mean, I suppose having to explain repeatedly over the phone why she wants to attend Beacon can be tiring but sounds like a relatively small sacrifice in order to maintain economical stability at least some time more.

Which is why Winter's speech rubbed me the wrong way. Her previous line about Weiss taking a job from Mr. Schnee feels like a set up to make the idea of taking the steps to regain her allowance seem abhorrent.

I wonder if it was intentional and indeed Winter is being manipulative or a slip from Miles and Kerry when writing the dialogue.