Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-25936766-20160606164529

Sentry 616 wrote:

I don't think the Cimber theory is likely since it seems like it was back to "normal" operating procedure when Cinder received the rest of the power, but I would agree that that theory is more likely than Ambyrrha. The reason I believe (comparatively) more in the Cimber theory is because, Cinder did not just kill Amber and take the Maiden powers like normal, but actually drained her with that Grimm Glove.

Pyrrha had, at most, a tiny bit of Amber's Aura. While Cinder has at least a big part of her Aura. So if Amber's consciousness is going to manifest in someone, it would make far more sense for it to manifest in Cinder instead of Pyrrha.

We've already seen what both Amber and Cinder were capable of with their powers as well, and compared to the average Hunter she would have an easier time escaping.