Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-25936766-20160615232810

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote:

1-Don't pay mind to the argumentative nitpicking by certain people in this thread. Most of their "logic" for disputing the Ambyrrha theory is built on so many assumptions and requires ignoring so many facts that at the end they have little more than simply not liking the theory.

2-I was composing a very long response addressing some of what you two said, but the site ate my post and I am not even remotely interested in doing it over.

3-However, fundamentally, all the Ambyrrha theory requires is that the equipment keeping Amber alive is also capable of reviving her, that if a person's soul is not in a body it returns to their original body upon said body being revived, that two Auras in one body creates enough healing power to undo the damager Cinder caused to Amber's body and that a person with the Auras of two skilled and experienced fighters is capable enough to escape Beacon alive.

4-Most of the arguments thrown in the way of this make assumptions about the number of Grimm, concentration of Grimm, ability of Grimm, skill of Amber, mental state of Amber, available means of escape, and so many other things that they just have no real basis for assuming.

5-Should either of you have an interest in discussing the theory for reason other than desperately attempting to find some sort of hole to poke in it, then that would be nice. 1-The Ambyrrha Theory in itself is built on many assumptions, and requires dismissing multiple facts as well. Such hipocretism. Also, yes, we don't like that theory, and yes that is the reason we argue against it. Wanna know why we don't like that theory? Because we think is absurd, not possible, and requires multiple assumptions to even be possible. Don't like people expressing disagreement with a theory they disagree with? Then deal with it.

2-I know how that feels.

3-We don't know if said equipment can revive a person. It was made to keep her alive and transfer Aura, nothing says nor hints that it could revive someone. We don't know what happens if a person's Soul is detached from it's body, for all we know it could return to the original, wander as a ghost, or disintegrate into nothingness. We have no idea of the effects having 2 Auras could have, and neither did Ozpin and co., for all we know Pyrrha's brain could've overloaded and died of brain hemorrage if the transfer worked.

And even if it didn't, Aura does not heal directly, it boosts the body's own regenerative capabilities. Aura doesn't heal wounds, it just makes the body heal the wound faster. And even then, the damage Amber got is not like any normal wound.

4-We haven't made any assumptions on the number, nor the concentration, of the Grimm at Beacon. Anyone who has seen End of the Beginning would agree with us when we say it's filled with Grimm, including tough Grimm, on both air and ground. And Amber would be at the middle of it. Everyone would find it hard to believe she could escape without Maiden powers, and possibly even with them.

You exagerate Amber's fighting skills, especially her Hand-to-Hand skills, to the point where she's more badass than Chuck Norris and Bruce Lee combined. You assume that Amber would just wake up and stay apathically cool once she sees Beacon's state and the hordes of Grimm, for no good reason other than even more assumptions.

5-So you are admitting, that you simply want people who disagree with that theory to stop expressing their disagreement with that theory for no real reason? What happened to freedom of speech? The right to express one's opinions?