Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4830106-20131108040231/@comment-22580009-20140103060954

Except Pyrrha did cut off it's tail. Blake managed to jump on and attack the Nevermore, even if it was too strong for basic attacks to hurt (this applies to all, not just Blake). Jaune blocked a hit from the deathstalker, not much but couldn't have been easy, especially for him. Yang jumped into the Nevermore's mouth to shoot it. Finally, Ruby, In the end, was the one with enough force to actually kill the Nevermore.

Overall, I would say they are all at about the same skill level. Weiss has a bit more versatility, considering her semblence and weapon, but they seem to be generally near each other (except Juane). Which makes sense since they are all first years.