Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4830106-20140921022402/@comment-173.58.251.107-20141214034945

LiveandSound wrote: @73: Now let me ask you something: What is Jaune's semblance? How do you know it's a perfect counter to Cinder?

Unless Word of God revealed it (which would be a bad move, ruins the surprise) beforehand, his semblance is unknown.

It's been implied (like, once) that it's defensive. However, like I said, it's been implied. Nothing's written in stone yet. For all we know, it could end up being offensive, or defensive in a way that does not counter Cinder at all.

Also, he still wouldn't be able to beat Cinder. Even if he could endure her attacks with his semblance, his skills are so low Cinder can just get up-close and kick his ass. The objective is to beat your oponent. You may be able to take shit, but until you KO your oponent, you can't win the fight. To win the match, Jaune needs to attack Cinder, but if he tries, Cinder can, and will, kick his ass. Jaune can't win, he doesn't have a chance against Cinder, while Pyrrha has bigger chances, even if she would still lose.

Any other idea you have to counter my point, 73? If you don't, please shut up or at least don't try to argue. Don't try to fight fights you can't win. I think that last bit could have been more cordial, Inquisitor, but other than that, good argument.