Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-73.91.2.197-20161222044456/@comment-4010415-20161222064700

1. Monty didn't even have to tell us that they're half-sisters, but he did anyway. The question he was responding to had literally absolutely positively nothing to do with whether Ruby and Yang are really sisters. It was

Fan: In the Yellow Trailer, Yang said she has many names. Is one of her other names Summer Rose, and she dies sometime in the future, leading to that gravestone we saw in the Red Trailer?

Monty: No, Yang is Ruby's sister. Summer is her mother.

He could've just said "No, Summer is her mother" and left it at that!

2. The RWBY crew has never intentionally lied to us.

When we ask them a question that would spoil something, they either

A. Say "We don't answer spoiler questions" or "Watch the show" (or ignore the question if it's a text-based Q&A)

B. Make a joke in response

C. Tell us only half of the truth or give us a little tease, like when asked about half-Faunus ("Maybe we've already seen them." - Monty. Could've been a joke, could've been a tease, we'll see)

So, when anyone on the RWBY crew outright says "Ruby and Yang are sisters", that means they're sisters, period.

The day that they intentionally lie to us is the day that we stop listening to them, and they don't want that. Rooster Teeth is all about their community. They don't want to lie to us, and they don't want us to stop trusting them.

And when I talk about "intentionally lie", I'm talking about things like... They once said we wouldn't see Ozpin fight any time soon. At the time, they were not lying. At the time, they had no plans of having Ozpin fight on-screen until much later. The shots of Ozpin fighting Cinder in End of the Beginning were added late in development. They hadn't originally planned it, but then they decided to do it.