Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-65.37.32.42-20140609015333/@comment-174.101.83.226-20140611181153

I just have one wonder how can one do a deeper meaning Lyric Analysis and then completely ignore lyrics like “With a doubt in our minds why we chose this life and at times we can’t help wondering… Were we born to fight and die? Sacrificed for one huge lie? Are we heroes keeping peace? Or are we weapons? Pointed at the enemy so someone else can claim a victory” these lyrics was the very first thing to strike me about the song. This sounds like there will advinchaly be reason to doubt what the fighting is about has the enemy they fight (Cinder maybe) stats looking questionable, also supported by “one huge lie” has in all they have been told is a lie and what there fighting for the justice is not even real as it is based on a lie and there reason to question “Are we heroes keeping peace?”. Also on the “Or are we weapons? Pointed at the enemy so someone else can claim a victory” might be stating the fact that they will be fighting a fake enemy (Cinder or Roman if Cinder appears pretending to be good infrunt of the heroes but that would be less interesting as we the viewers all ready no she works with Roman) as the puppets of a grater evil so that this evil can win as the everyone is ignoring them on the fake threat. This other evil alluded to in “Pointed at the enemy so someone else can claim a victory” is open to your idle of the government holding team RWBY bake, the enemy in this line is most likely Cinder who will be made out as the grate threat but will end up being a “one huge lie” and the someone cod be referring to an evil government or corporation that is using their influence and power to control people in there favor so that the situation of the fighting agents Cinder will only serve to make them win as they hid in secret and let the other characters be there puppets and sacrifice themselves for their lie so that they can obtain their goal. Also to me at lest the appearance of the people in the Penny shot during the song definitely lead its self open themselves to maybe being an evil government or corporation and the man in the sinter I can see being the animay tip character that first apers as a nice law abiding good person who ends up being secretly corrupted but bake to the lyrics “Pointed at the enemy so someone else can claim a victory”. Cinder too might be one of their unknowing puppets (the “someone else” part) or I have two other theories on these lines: 1.	Cinder is working under the evil government or corporation or whoever the “someone else” is and was ordered to for a group (Roman, Mercury, and Emerald) to give a face for evil so that the people and their heroes wood focus all there utinchin on this evil and thus ignore the true evil as it wins because everyone is targeting just Cinder. 2.	The more interesting plot twist of Cinder not even really being evil at all but misunderstood as she knows of the true hidden greatest threat of the true evil of the evil government or corporation or whoever the “someone else” is and is trying to stop it but do to its influence it has painted her out to be the enemy to the world as a distraction to protect its self. One must note that the reason Cinder is having Roman steal Dust is not yet known and it cod be to use it to destroy the true evil of the government or corporation or whoever the “someone else” is or some dooms day weapon or monster that the group plans to use to win but they just need time to complete it and see putting every ones focus on Cinder as the way to buy the time. In this version Ozpin might be unknowingly helping the “someone else” or he cod even be the “someone else” or working for it as the main way to spread the “one huge lie” thus his main preppies of his school is to get people to think there heroes of peace win there just really weapons and to get them to sacrifice theme selves for the lie so that they (the “someone else”) never have to worry about any one trying to stop there evil plan. These cod be easily over analyzed and too much of a plot twist as the “Or are we weapons? Pointed at the enemy so someone else can claim a victory” cod just mean: 1.	That Cinder is evil and doing wrong for evil but is unknowingly being used by a unseen evil that is using the fake of every one targeting Cinder’s group as an opportunity to win. This cod be the Wight Fang, Adam (I don’t trust him as he is the only character thus fare to ever laugh like a mad man and conceive killing people in the show this fare. Also I expect him as vary powerful and the villains are always the ones who start out the strongest. Plus dos "scatter and wilt." sound one bit good) or someone yet to be shown. 2.	Cinder is the true evil how is hiding in the bake ground as she has Roman go out and be the known evil. So the “Pointed at the enemy” is Roman and the “someone else can claim a victory” is Cinder. As I said before I find this cind of boring as it is to be expected that Cinder is the main antagonist of the show and it has already been shown that Cinder is working with Roman, I would prefer to be as surprised at the “someone else” as team RWBY is than have already been shown it so if this one is true and Cinder is using Roman in this way then I would have preferred it to have been a secret that she works with him. 3.	Also on a similar note: Cinder is the true evil how is hiding in the bake ground as she uses the Wight Fang as the distraction from her. In this version the “Pointed at the enemy” is the Wight Fang and the “someone else can claim a victory” is Cinder. Once again I have the same problem as the above, Cinder is expected to be the main antagonist, the Wight Fang have been shown helping Roman as of the most recent episode and once again this is not surprising to the viewer but is only surprising to team RWBY. It must be noted that there is hardly an animay were the first shown evil antagonist is ether the main antagonist or even riley evil for that matter, also Cinder’s bases ideal flows the same pattern as of the rest of team RWBY. Sadly “Time To Say Goodbye” is too long of a song and the opening theme end before the lyrics even reach the very interesting lyric “With a doubt in our minds why we chose this life and at times we can’t help wondering… Were we born to fight and die? Sacrificed for one huge lie? Are we heroes keeping peace? Or are we weapons? Pointed at the enemy so someone else can claim a victory” for it is at 1:58-2:38 in the song meaning you only get to hear this part if you lesson to the full version of the song. Your analysis on the other part of the song was good and interesting.