Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-25991826-20161121231310/@comment-26018514-20161122200751

190.166.130.125 wrote: MiniDaggers wrote: 1) Why only take one kid.

2) Why wouldn't Tai hunt down his kid who was essentially kidnapped (Raven just left without a trace, not with warning Tai in advanced).

3) Why would Qrow just let her do that and not help Tai, Qrow is a still a decent guy despite there being suggested animosity between the two.

4) We already have enough surprise family members for one volume. 1) As Grey said, maybe sho took the one who looked healthier, or maybe Yang was born weak or something.

2) I kind of like the theory that Raven was in a relationship with Tai, then she just left one day and 9 months later she left Yang at Tai's doorstep, maybe with a note or something. That seems to me like the only explanation as to why Taiyang wouldn't know that he has another daughter somewhere.

3) There could be any number of reasons for Qrow not telling Tai about his other daughter, assuming that he even knows about her of course.

4) Am I right at assuming that you are not very fond of the theory that Adam is Qrow's son either?
 * 1) 1-3... there is an obvious answer,  Raven's clan could be Racist(Specist?) faunus, meaning Yang and Taiyang were dumped for being human, and Adam could have inherited their mindset/teachings.

Clans of Faunus outside the kingdoms make a lot of sense if the racism the WF fight exists, and likewise Raven's mindset also makes sense in this context.

4. I am likewise not a fan of that theory... Specific heritage ties to auxiliary characters like Adam make a work far less inclusive... not to mention how little evidence exists.