Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-25936766-20160618180031

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote: 1-People in the real world can and have been revived in such cases.

2-One thing I have considered is that the pod could jolt her body with electricity to try and restart her heart.

3-.I don't think it would take a whole episode. At most I could see four minutes, but I think it could be done in just one minute. You only really need to explain how Amber was revived and infused with Pyrrha's Aura, with the escape being so open-ended in terms of a necessary explanation that you wouldn't even need to focus much on it.

4-How is it outlandish? It makes perfect sense that something meant to keep a person alive would be capable of resuscitating that person as well.

5-Emergency functions such as resuscitating a person soon after death would not be much use if they were dependent on a glass door being shut. 1-But none of those cases have been long after the heart failure started. Heart failure is one of those things that need inmediate attention if you want the person to survive.

2-An option, but it didn't seem to have anything that could do that. Perhaps it was not an automatic function? Perhaps it needed to be activated manually? If so, there's no way she is alive then, because back then only Pyrrha, Jaune, Ozpin and Cinder were in the room. Cinder has no intention of reviving her, Ozpin is MIA, and J&P ran away. The elevator is also broken and no one would dare enter a place so filled with Grimm. In other words, there's no one to activate it, or even try to repair the machine.

3-It would certainly not be able to be done in just 1 minute, unless you want to butcher the writing and pacing like a victim in a splatter film. 4-5 minutes seems fine, by skipping the more minor details of the escape, yet still showing how she escapes. Leaving the escape open to interpretation would only be lazy, bad writing, and would accentuate the show's problem of not actually showing the stuff it mentions often.

4-It would not be nonsensical, but it would not be expected either. Just because a machine can keep a person alive it doesn't mean that actual revival of a person is among it's capabilities. The same happens in a contrary case; just because a machine can revive someone it doesn't mean it can keep them alive after.

And besides, there's still the issue of Amber's lung being pierced by an arrow. Even if her heart was intact and the machine jolted it to reanimate it, Amber would still die of asphyxiation, if not just choke in her own blood if the arrow was removed somehow. Hell, just trying to remove the arrow could kill her.

5-And what happened to those emergency functions the moment Amber died? Why did none of them activate?