Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-14138255-20151206164217/@comment-27356782-20151206211702

The flaw I sew in this discussion is that everyone seems to think that "the guardian" is the ultimate big role and that if Pyrrha took it it will put Ruby in the shadows.

Like someone said somewhere, Guardian is something that involve some kind of "stationnary duty" which, for me, does'nt fit very well team RWBY. I think in the futur they will travel a lot around the world.

Pyrrha could be the Guardian as long as she want and protect Beacon. Ruby will probably save the WORLD until the end of the show.

Now about "futur Pyrrha fail" I think it seems obvious for these reasons :

- The opening

- Cinder plan seems to works way to well to fail totally

- Pyrrha needs a defeat in her story.

But I don't think she will die, or be permanently injured. She will fail HARDLY in the worst moment as a guardian, probably causing the kingdom to suffer greatly. She will fall in depression, she will doubt herself and want to quit her role. But Jaune will back her up. He will help her to stand again on her legs, take her weapons again. Growing more. And come back to kick more.

In the meantime, RWBY will achieve something great on their own. Don't assume that because a "side character" took a "great role" means that there is no other role by which Ruby can shine magnificiently.

ps : Sorry for my bad english, It's not my first langage so ... I hope you can understand what I am trying to say.