Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-4555743-20171116223520/@comment-4555743-20171118052610

 "Was it ever actually stated or confirmed that Emerald is from specifically Mistral"

Not specifically, but most likely. Mistral is Cinder's main area of residence, and the recruiting of Emerald occured in the past way before events in Vale (Cinder has shorter hair in that scene, and other details indicate that.) So it most likely happened in Mistral.

"You're ignoring my point about Weiss and Pyrrha."

Indeed I am ignoring this point as unimportant. I am going to continue to ignore this point, because Tai's words about "not everyone else's semblance being basically a temper tantrum" do shed enough light on the matter and should really end this discussion if you don't ignore them.