Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-9058532-20130807182204/@comment-84.128.184.90-20140128180434

Bippwatt wrote: Several things here. One, Word of God has said that Ruby and Yang are not adopted and are full sisters. Therefore they both have the same parents. If Ruby lost her mom, so did Yang.

Two, I posist that the Red Trailer and and White Cloak are both future events.

Reasoning? Well, mostly supported by the one thing I'm surprised that no one else noticed or mentioned. The fact that White Cloak is a white cloak, lined in red. IE: The same exact coloring of Weiss' bolero jacket.

My full theory: The Cliffside Altar and White Cloak are both future events...The former is a memorial for the latter (Duh)....but White Cloak is not Summer Rose. White Cloak, rather, is Weiss Schnee.

Yes...my theory involves the great Weiss dying. I will has a sad. But it's my prediction and I'm sticking to it.

A bit of flavor here. Ruby blames herself for Weiss' death and as a result, Weiss haunts her dreams. Red Like Roses fills my dreams... And that explains White Cloak's presence. And the fact that it is a cloak instead of a bolero...might simply signify a heavier weight.

Anyway. that's my theory. Weiss Schnee dies....*crys himself to sleep now* (in support of the theroy summer is ruby's mother)

but in red like roses part 2 (album version) the second singer says "but baby please don't do what i did" do you think weiss call ruby "baby" also  the first singer (probably ruby) says "all the joy that i had known for my life was stripped away from me the minute that you died" "to have you in my life is all i ever wanted" ALL her life, ALL she ever wanted, ruby was 15 when they meet and they had problems getting along at first. 2nd singger "i tried so hard just to protect you but i failed to" sounds like a mother protecting her child. " i wanna tell you that your all that ever matttered, want you to know for eternity i'm shattered" wiess hated ruby. " i never planned that i would leave you there alone i was shure that i would see you when i made it back home, and all the times i swore that it would be okay" BACK HOME possible to refer to their dorm but more than likely a house. a mother will tell her child it will be ok."your not the only one who needed me i thought you understood" "you were the one i needed and you left me and i always feard you would"  the one i needed, dosn't sound like she blames herself, also ruby and weiss' relation ship isn't this deep to where they NEED eachother the way the song sounds, though ruby would be very sad at the loss of her friend, the lyrics would be diffrent.

though i admire your creativity and imagination, the current facts don't support your conclusion