Talk:Jacques Schnee/@comment-2602:306:805D:8C10:90C5:8D83:1D75:A7AC-20171221232032/@comment-25936766-20171228023041

^4 things:

1) Jacques has no reason to frame RWB as if they kidnapped Weiss. For starters, they're rookies by Huntsmen standards, and 17 at most. And Weiss hadn't seen them in at least half a year by the time she left.

So not only is the idea of them kidnapping Weiss ridiculous on it's own, it would make Jacques look like an idiot, letting a bunch of meddling kids steal her daughter from under his nose.

Jacques is not an idiot, so why the hell would he use such a counterproductive "tactic"? It would be out of character.

At most, he frames Blake and only Blake. Which is far more reasonable because she has ties to the White Fang, quite personal ties, and the WF has been tormenting the SDC and the Schnees for more than a decade, and Weiss knows it, she even explained it herself.

--

2) "Disowns". Can one disown their own parent? I'm pretty sure it was the other way around. As for "tainted beyond repair", that's just on you. It's literally Weiss's goal to un-taint it, to restore the decency of the Schnee name. Thinking it's "beyond repair" is out-of-character for her.

3) All that sounds more like some fanfic idea you have, not like something that will actually happen.