User blog comment:BenRG/The Chosen One/@comment-3387274-20130825155736

you realise that if this is the case Ozpin's made a fatal mistake? How's Jaune going to react when he finds out that the cute girl who outright asked to join his team is just doing so because of some grand plan or prophecy and not because of who he is? Therein either his good nature or any confidence he might have perishes, and with it everything Oz would be working towards.

also, to quote Blake, the world is not a fairy tale. Things like Chosen ones just don't seem likely in the slightest. Especially now that much of the magic needed to arrange it has been nailed down into more material things.

Anyway, in terms of hard facts, Ozpin didn't know  Crow was teaching Ruby at all, we have no confirmation that the vision ever happened, or where and when it happened. There's two of your pieces of evidence shot down. Also the fact that his chosen one just happened to be trying to do exactly what he wanted of her without him must be pretty low. if Glynda was tailing Ruby, then why the heck didn't she just bring down Torchwick as soon as he made for the same shop as her? and why did they go through the whole foiled robbery-Torchwick escaped-interogation routine before bringing her to Beacon? Given how many hunters/huntreses there must actually be, it's not infeasable that one of them might be in town and possibly hear all the noise torchwick and his goons made, or investigate reports from all the concerned citizens he was strolling past at the time. And also that town seemed to be the nearest one to Beacon, explaining why it was her specificly.

Finally, how could he possibly plan Pyrha rescuing Jaune, or get them on the same team when eye contact is crucial? If Pyrha had been any slower (she pretty much freefalled all the way down to the forest by the look of things) the so called healer might just have met a horrible fate. If Weiss had actually found him cute or something (yes, unlikely, but you can't dismiss it without knowing them) she might have looked him in the eye when she saw him pinned to the tree instead of running back to Ruby. And it's even more likely that if Weiss hadn't been on hand Ruby would have run into Jaune and possibly done the same.