Talk:Cinder Fall/@comment-98.15.148.176-20130923184948/@comment-4010415-20130923211725

From the lyrics, it sounds like whoever the song is about died during a time that Ruby could actually remember it, not when she was a baby. Though, you're right, her mother could have ended up leaving or being fought off or shunned/banished away from the family, and they told her that she died. But if it was at an age where Ruby could remember her, then she probably would've recognized Crimson.