Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-107.167.112.74-20170228120401/@comment-25936766-20170410032237

Phantomlink959 wrote: That's just because you are  disturbingly good at analyzing and assembling small pieces of information, though. Relative; most of the "twists" in Vol.1 were painfully obvious even from the get go. The problem is that the fandom is blind at certain areas.

You know as well as I do just how many people, even now, still spit the idea of Pyrrha being alive, or Summer being a Maiden, completely alien to what those ideas, or their implications, mean.

What Chishio "deduced" was obvious if you put simple thought into it: If Weiss was an Idol Singer, and that Snowflake was her symbol...why would said symbol be pasted on boxes of cargo on a train, heavily guarded by robots?

Even if one assumed that they really were stuff related to said Idol Singer, it leads to the question of "why would people want to blow up a train and possibly kill people in it?", because Weiss would be nothing but an Idol Singer.

The question is more justified in a work where the Idol Singer in question is more than just an Idol Singer, which means that Weiss herself wasn't just a simple Idol Singer, even leaving aside her apparent fighting skills shown in her trailer.

Though sure, the part of her family being rich and/or part of a successful company that Blake and Adam had a beef against was more of a lucky shot.

TL;DR: It's not that Chishio is "amazingly amazing" at analyzing and deducing. She simply uses the most basic trait of Science: Logic. The moment you think about things, the questions appear and are reduced, or answered. If something is Ilogical, you know it can't be right until shown to be.