Talk:Salem/@comment-28288412-20160613175741/@comment-28288412-20160613201051

I feel as though if we continue this further we're going to start going around in circles, if we haven't already. You can take that as giving up or however you will but I will concede that you have good points, although I stand by my statement of the Godmother connection being more strained than the Wicked Witch connection.

As for the decision, I think if there is suitable context and evidence that speculation should be allowed so long that it is clearly labeled as such. As with anything if a person is foolish enough to take wiki information labeled as speculation as canon then they deserve the same level of ridicule as the people going around saying Matpat's game theories are canon.

But I can agree with your stance and that the wiki should only show canon confirmed information on their articles. I would be perfectly fine with that approach, hell as a stickler for the rules I would prefer a more clear cut rule.

Nontheless, sadly the decision doesn't come down to us. Should the staff choose to come to a decision (still waiting on Qrow/Ironwood allusion confirmations from commentaries check) then we have to stand by it. At least if it is decided then a better defined policy that is agreed with across wiki staff can be implemented reducing confusion, if only slightly.