Board Thread:Administrative Requests/@comment-29684190-20191016013522/@comment-26397825-20191016041529

73.Anon.52 wrote:

New mission statement; A page for locations without clearly defined dimensions, improperly named locations, or not clearly identified in present Remnant as a location we'll see likely see again.

Things like the Nucks cave should just become their own pages, especially as it is defined by proximity to a known City. I agreed with 73's suggestion beforehand.

Basically, we give it the same treatment as the Minor Characters, which I believe are currently


 * Do they have a name


 * Do they have an appearance


 * Do they have a voice actor


 * Have they actively appeared in media beyond name dropping/photos

I believe that if three of those are a yes, they get a page. The same can be applied to locations.


 * Do they have an identifiable name. I say identifiable because we can call Miss Malachite's Bar "Miss Malachite's Bar" even if that's not the in-universe name. It's an identifiable moniker that people will know to look up. I doubt they'll ever give us the actual names for these kinds of locations, which is why I'm not suggesting restricting it to official names only.


 * Do they have a general location in modern RWBY. We know for a fact that the Nuckelavee Cave is in a mountain near Mistral and Kuroyuri. We can give a general location.

That's a good baseline for whether something should have its own page in my opinion. Using these guidelines, places like the First Era Kingdoms would be on the Minor Locations pages as 73 suggested, while places like Junior's Nightclub and the Crow Bar have their own page.