Thread:LiveandSound/@comment-25405817-20141214031121/@comment-25405817-20141215022405

I've read your insight, and I find it really informative. I agree with most of your observations, and some others I've disagreed. Let me elaborate with some of my responses:

I-Magician: Funnily enough, I was considering Jaune for this arcana, but sadly there aren't any other character that could fit on the Emperor. Thus, if I put Jaune as Magician, Yang as Strenght and so on, I would be missing the "troubled leader".

III-Empress: Fun Fact: Kathleen says that Glynda is a sexual goddess "She uses a riding crop! It's canon people." So, there's more going for her on this arcana... I guess.

VIII-Strenght: I totally agree with you on this one, that Yang is this arcana. However, there's the same problem when swapping the placements...

X-Fortune: Penny fits for the Fate part and trying her luck. She wants to take chances, prove herself, make friends; regardless to the plans other people have for her.

XII-Hanged Man: True, at first glance Weiss is a weird pick for this arcana and admitedly there's a bit of especulation on my reasoning for this place. But look at it this way: when Port gave her that speech back in Vol. 1, she found herself realising that she had everything on a silver plate and now she doesn't, and she choose to become a better teammate instead of pursuing her wish of leadership. Nothing huge, but it counts.

XIII-Death: No objections here. You could argue that she set a "change in tone" but that doesn't means much.

XV-Devil: I thought the same when picking the characters, but compared to the other antagonists (and Cardin), I found that he fits the role better. Also, setting off the plan early and then letting himself get arrested seem to fit the impulsiveness and comitment part, imo; though I guess that Cardin could also fit in this more easily.

It's true, I based myself on how the Persona games portrayed the archetypes of the cards with the characters, thought that's the purpose of the template. But, I do like your feedback, and I'll take it into account if I ever do a V.2.0. Thanks

Sorry for the double post, for some reason it registered as a "Wikia Contributor"

PD: The P4 Walkthrough you reccomended me was good, until the guy answered incorrectly Ms. Sofue first question "When does Anno Domini begings?" (His answer: When a nation is founded). Also, I found the pauses he made between dialogues a little annoying.