Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-14061097-20160425214902

Sentry 616 wrote: 73.Anon.52 wrote:

Ambyrra lacks too much context for any meaningful speculation to be made.

At best for this "what if" to work we know almost nothing about how aura would work in this situation, we know almost nothing about Amber, we know almost nothing about maiden abilities, and we know very little about Pyrrha's soul. We do however know her VA and body are gone from the series as far as her character are concerned. This is all true. I was just feeling bored and indulgent.

There are multiple reasons that this wouldn't happen. A person's Aura/soul doesn't appear to do anything after death. Amber was shot around twentyish minutes before Pyrrha was flash-incinerated. We saw the Maiden powers leave Amber, which is only supposed to happen when a Maiden dies. Even if that body was somehow still functioning, there is no reason to believe anyone's soul would seek out a new body. Even if something created by the experiment survived down in the vault, the academy was overrun, and the elevator out of the vault was destroyed. If some sort of entity was down in the vault, it would be trapped in the deepest sublevel of a building in the middle of a stronghold that has been taken over by the enemy. This entity would be without food, water, coverings beyond what Amber was wearing, weapons, armor, and a means of escape. To top it off, it has been confirmed that Pyrrha is dead.

I suggest that we accept her death and move on. Plus I feel its just to complicated a theory for a show who's run time is just roughly 2.5 hours per season; Not to mention it really doesn't contribute to the story at large. Those are 2 things I think should be considered in bringing anybody back in this show, make sure the ressurection work and make sense but also simple so you don't spend half the season explaining it and also make sure it connects to the story in one way or another.