Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-26397825-20160606214513

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote: Cimber is plausible, though I don't really think it would work the way you suggest. We don't know how her power-sucking ability works, but if it doesn't drain Aura then the only reason Amber's Aura would be in Cinder is if the Aura transfer bound up the Maiden powers and Amber's Aura in such a way that they were dragged together into Cinder.

As to Pyrrha not having any part of Amber, my suggestion is that Pyrrha got a portion of Amber's Aura and when Amber was killed her remaining Aura went to link up with the portion in Pyrrha. Then Amber gets revived so when Pyrrha is incinerated, Amber's Aura goes right back to a now living body. In essence, the soul returns to the body upon it being revived, though in this case since it was in another living body that one had to be killed or destroyed for it to happen. The draining effect for moving the Fall Maiden powers between Amber and Pyrrha is used for the absorbption effect between Cinder and Amber, though, right? And they specifically say the Fall Maiden powers are tied to the soul, don't they? So when Cinder stole Amber's powers, wouldn't she have been draining out Amber's soul too, which is why she was dying while Cinder did it?

It seems to me like the way Cinder stole the Fall Maiden powers drained Amber's soul from the visual effect that happened in both instances, so Amber's soul would be dragged alongside the Fall Maiden powers, which again have been specified to be tied to the Maidens soul, into Cinder. Even if Pyrrha did get a little bit, the majority would have gone to Cinder and therefore any Amber revivals would be in Cinder. At least, by my reckoning anyway.