Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-26900424-20150926220031/@comment-207.171.217.160-20151025012415

It depends on the setting. Morals off and no discrimination with a memory wipe of their relationships with each other would be the fairest. So I'll just assume that's what you meant.

KEEP IN MIND MOST OF THIS IS SUBJECTIVE AND MY OPINION BASED ON WHAT I HAVE SEEN

Yang: Seems like a clear winner with her op semblance. Of course it only works if she has her endurance up. As seen in the episode where she fought Neo after fighting grims all day. I doubt her semblance would be able to keep up with fighting atleast 2 of her teammates. However she has the shotgun gauntlets, but they lack proficient range compared to her team's weapons. Then again she has shown to have the highest durability feat wise.

+Most Destructive Semblance

+Most Skilled in melee

+Has the most durability based on feats

-Low endurance is greatest weakness

-Lacks long range compared to team

Blake: Has the highest agility. A quite shadow semblance allowing for added agility. A quick and skilled fighter. Uses a varied arsenal. Of course she seems to be the well rounded one. Besides agility she doesn't seem to shine in anything else.

+High agility

+No particular weakness

+Most varied arsenal

-No particular strengths besides agility

Weiss: Probably the most intelligent. Her rapier style weapon in combination with dust makes her the most skilled combat wise (And by comabt skill I mean the ability to use a melee weapon to attack and counter well). Of course this is where her advantages kind of end. She is shown to have the lowest durability and isn't particularly powerful. Her glyph semblance does give her some nice agility. However, Weiss is more like a support class in an RPG. She works best with her team. She mostly uses her dust to help teammates.

+Highest Intelligence

+Most Skilled Comabt Wise

+Uses a wide array of Dust to Power Attacks

+Glyphs give high agility

-Works best in team

-Low durability

- Low power

Ruby: By far the fastest. The best at ranged combat with sythe-sniper. Of course this is about it. She doesn't shine particularly in durability, or striking force. Her agility is decent but out done by other teammates. And while the leader, most of her strategies are team based. She doesn't have much skill in individual strategies besides speed blitz.

+High Speed Semblance

+Best at Ranged Combat

-Not particularly durable

-Not particularly strong

So, with the fight. We have the problem of who fights who. We already established they won't remember their previous relationships. So, Weiss being the most intelligent would most likely fight Blake first. Looking at her opponents Blake SEEMS like the least powerful and carries a swords which would be easier for her to fight. Yang being the daring one would most likely fight Ruby first with that threatening weapon. With this in place lets look at who would win.

Weiss VS Blake

I have to give this to Blake.

The wide weapon array and higher agility help her get around Weiss's dust. Also her semblance could get around Weiss's ice dust, which is her most common attack. Though Weiss's glyphs could help her match Blake's agility, once the fight closes to a melee Blake has a clear advantage. Weiss may be more skilled in terms of combat skill but Blake is skilled as well and can use her sheath as a weapon which would much harder for Weiss to keep up with. Weiss would be more than skilled to enough to strike Blake multiple times, however we established she doesn't have much power behide those strikes. Blake would be skilled enough to get hits in. Not as many, but enough to eventually put Weiss down with her lower durability. So, my favorite dies first. Great start.

Ruby VS Yang

This close, but I have to go with Ruby.

Even with her OP semblance, Yang lack agility and speed compared to Ruby. Ruby would simply overpower her with speed. Yang could use her semblance, but it adds the attackers strength to her own. Meaning she still has to make contact with her strikes. Ruby is too fast and has access to far superior long range tech. Yang's also struggles with opponents that have high agility, like Neo. Granted that was after she spent all day fighting Grims and was exhausted, she also fought a giant robot in "Painting the Town" and needed her teamates help to land a strike on a GIANT ROBOT and it wasn't even moving that much. If she couldn't land a strike on her own against a robot using her semblance there is no way she could hit Ruby with it.

Ruby vs Blake

Ruby

After considering the previous fights, Blake would be in a much worse shape. Even if she wasn't, Ruby is faster, granted Blake is more agile. Ruby had better weapons, Blake had more weapons. Ruby was more durable, Blake has more combat skill. How ever Ruby had the highest damage output. This is combination with the damage taken earlier makes her the most likely to win in this scenario I laid out. Of coure the 3rd volume could make this completely wrong. We'll see. But as it stands in think Ruby would be the most likely winner.

The winner is Runy