Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-27082610-20160421142947

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote: Arkantos95 wrote: Why would a pod work when the door is broken? The glass is gone, it's no longer sealed, there's no way it still works. So even if Amber was still alive after taking that arrow, she's most likely drowning in her own blood. How do you know how this fictional technology works? It isn't outlandish to suggest that a civilization capable of creating this kind of crazy technology would also make allowance for things like the glass door breaking. There is no reason why certain processes, such as resuscitation, couldn't work without a seal.

And you completely ignored Sprit's entire post earlier. I don't see anything in Spirit's posts that wasn't in some way addressed by my post, even if I didn't respond to Spirit directly.

Sentry 616 wrote: I'll save you the trouble. I went back and checked both the transcript and the actual episode. There wasn't anything about how Amber might or should recover. That episode told us she wouldn't live. Obviously, there is no reason to believe she could have recovered simply from their technology or on her own. They were presuming that she would eventually die for one reason or another, but then we just come back to the whole fact this Aura transfer thing was completely unprecedented in-universe and explicitly noted as having unpredictable effects.

Even allowing that they meant she was dying within that little pod, there is no reason to believe they foresaw it happening imminently or even had any clue how long it would take or what damage was already caused. I believe their urgency regarding transfering Amber's powers to Pyrrha was more about the fact they knew plans were in motion in Vale. What. The Fuck. Is the purpose. Of building a pod when you don't need a door for it to work. If it wasn't necessary they'd have just left it open and had her secured to the frame by restraints.

You know what? I'm done with this. You're obvioiusly unwilling to accept the mountain of evidence both from within the universe and outside of it, and there's no point in arguing with someone who's stuck in a river in Egypt.