Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24934890-20180911200208/@comment-26018514-20180915190706

Lord Jaric wrote: …

And no matter how much you want this theory to be true it doesn't change that was debunked long before it even existed. Before there even was a theory Monty stated that Ruby and Yang were half sisters with different mothers. The only way for Qrow to be Ruby's father is if he was Yang's as well. Meaning he would have had to have an incest relation with his sister... Don't forget this would also imply Taiyang was taking care of 2 unrelated girls, where one of which not only had her mother cheat on him with her brother, but leave after said child was born.... and he apparently shut down at some point, so we know he's not collecting kids for the hell of it... why would he do that?