Talk:Cinder's Weapons/@comment-29684190-20190906210625/@comment-29684190-20190907081814

By that logic the page would definitely have to include Anisedora considering the actual weapon parts are made out of hard-light dust. No different to how Weiss conjured an ice dust sword, using a physical object to conjure a fully dust weapon. And what about Raven's sword. It's made out of dust. Not in the way you were thinking, but it is. It shatters and has to be replaced, just like Cinder's. It is "made out of Dust"

Also wouldn't making a page for "Dust and Magic weapons" diminish how special magic really is. It's only been used by two people, while anyone can (and do) use Dust. Honestly, that sounds more like a category to me, I don't know why it would need a shared page. We already have a Dust and Maidens page, why not keep it there? It' just feels such an oddly specific page to make. Like we would make a "melee weapons" page. Or like a page dedicated to people who use weapons with their sembalnces like Adam, Cinder, Weiss.

I would prefer a category like "magic users". Because it's an ability that certain characters can do. (Branwens, Cinder, Salem, Ozma) And it is a nice and concise. You know what you're getting. Putting Magic and Dust on the same page sounds like a mess.

Seriously, if you want a page to describe both Raven's and Cinder's magic swords, we have a page for that: it's the Maidens page. It fits there perfectly well, we all agreee it's a Maiden ability. This page analyzes and catalogues Cinder's weapons.

While maidens are capable of creating weapons, Cinder is the only one consistently seen to be doing so and has become her go-to weapon of choice. Like I said: Any huntsman can built their weapon, but we still have each page seperate for each weapon. Why should Cinder be any different.

Anon, do I have to add a citation to "see Beginning of the End" for Cinder burning her swords? I mean it happened in the show, I don't think we do that, only if the info comes from outside the actual show, like a panel, or commentary or twitter, still you asked for a citation, so idk.