Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-226878-20140818053714/@comment-25936766-20170529012918

Phantomlink959 wrote:

1-He would have worn skirts and dresses as a child before his identity began to develop.

2-If he transitioned AFTER moving to Vale; he would be trying to train as a huntsman, while undergoing HRT (which causes HUGE changes to your body and would seriously fuck up your training efforts).

3-He would also need to have a gender reassignment surgery at some point, which is highly invasive and takes quite a bit of time to recover from and would further interfere with training.

4-Now, even if he DID manage to complete his training while completely rebuilding his body from the ground up (at best improbable), he would have to do at least part of these things while working as a deep cover agent for the freaking illuminati; 1-Not necesarily. Especially if he looked more "male" than "female" at the time, which happens.

2-Really? How big are these changes, exactly, since you seem to know?

3-He could...you know, do it after graduation or during a break. Some period of time where he wasn't busy.

4-............You speak as if it was a fact that he became an agent for Ozpin right out of Beacon, instead of, say, months after, years after. He could've done even most of these things before becoming an agent for Ozpin.

General-You're missing a very obvious fact, Phantom: Remnant's current tech in general is noticeably more advanced than ours in just about everything but some aesthetics and deliberately-questionable design decisions ("If 1 CCT falls, everyone loses the internet").

It is not ilogical to assume that HRT and Gender Reassignment Surgery in Remnant would be less problematic, more effective at it's job and/or faster. Even if you argued that only Atlas is truly advanced, the other kingdoms borrow from Atlas, making the point moot in this case.

I agree that Qrow is definitely not trans. But your points are not really the most convincing arguments.