Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4141313-20181128141152/@comment-26018514-20181129033557

BlizzardDragon wrote: 73.Anon.52 wrote: BlizzardDragon wrote: So, right now with the revelation... 1) I have never seen this theory....

... Okay, first, you can cut down the text so it doesn't quote so much.

1) Clearly you haven't been on tumblr or reddit then cause the theory keeps popping up there. Even then, the reincarnation curse is bs because how would a reincarnation curse be passed genetically? Unless you're saying its tied to the magic, except half of the reason they had magic is thanks to ​​​​​​Salem's genes, not just Ozma's.​ Even if it was genetic, then that would mean anyone with a smidge of Ozma magic would also Reincarnate, such as the Settler's kids, or Qrow and Raven.

2) Except that is heavily different. The most you could say about Pure Human Salem and Tainted Salem was that they were pallette swaps of each other, so it wouldn't be hard for him to recognize her. As for Salem recognizing him, call it instinctual, call it sensing he had magic, call it the False God having a similar enough face, I don't know. But I doubt an old man having lived several generations would be able to tell four random sisters are his daughters just by sitting with them for one day.

3) Except I already explained how the four sisters being his daughters makes no sense due to his timeline. So it doesn't matter if his daughters were born with the magic, the sisters weren't. And even so, if the sisters were his daughters, why didn't they exhibit magic?

4) ... No. It doesn't fit perfectly. Ozma's kids and the story of the seasons only have two things in common: Ozma's presence, and four sisters. A cabin that he and Salem lived in before his daughters were born and that said daughters never lived in does not equate a random cabin four teenagers chose to visit. We can't even say one has anything to do with the other! ONE SHARED DETAIL DOESN'T MEAN THE STORIES ARE CONNECTED!

Salem had no role in the creation of the maidens. Wanna know how?

OZPIN'S MAGIC IS NEARLY GONE.

His magic is finite. And he said the reason its so low is because he gave the maidens his powers. He may be a pathological liar, but in this case he's telling the truth. Ya know why? If he wasn't, WHY DID HE DIE TO CINDER, of for that matter, '​​​​​​​HOW DID CINDER EVEN WIN? 'Or why did him in Oscar's body have such a hard time against Hazel?

His magic is all but gone, and what else did he use his magic on if not the creation of the Maidens? He didn't funnel it all into Qrow and Raven.

For that matter, if the Maiden powers were from the Daughters only, ''how in the gods name did Ozpin even find out about them? ''Did he just randomly sense magic coming out of some random woman?

There's also the fact Jinn didn't identify them as the Maidens. She was spilling Ozma's past, and if the conception of the Maidens was related to said past, why didn't she bring it up?!

The Daughters and the Maidens are not one in the same.

5) Eww, double negatives. I cannot figure out what you mean here. I don't cut down text that much because when you do you are misrepresenting what was said, like;

1. I have seen the theory, I have NOT seen the theory tied down with the baggage you are saddling it with and then using said baggage to dismiss it.

It's like me telling you I was watching YT video's and like MLP, then you tell me well obviously to watch MLP I must be seeing porn because this is the internet, when I never told you I watch MLP on YT... they are completely unrelated stories and neither disproves or proves the other.

The "curse" is both Salem and Ozpin's, Salem cannot die, and Ozpin cannot pass on, a co-mingling of both curses would likely present itself just as the presence of magic did, now personally I don't think it manifested as Oz's did... I think they were stuck "between", Ozpin then found them and used the relics and his own power to finish the process

2, 3, & 4. We were told a MYTH, we were not told Ozpin's version, how many times have you read a true Grimm version of a Disney story with as much in common?

5. I agree with you the theory is unlikely, but do not think it can be dismissed.