User blog comment:KingFubuki92/The Issues with RWBY's writing, and how Volume 6 can possibly improve on them./@comment-71.30.17.231-20180123235423

A good and optimistic analysis.

As for the maiden powers....

There is no difference between the spring, fall, winter, and summer maiden powers. So how did they get their name? Wouldn't it have made more sense if 50 years ago Ozpin had renamed them Creation Maiden, Destruction Maiden, Knowledge Maiden, and Choice Maiden after the relics they access? That condenses a whole lot of exposition AND removes the maiden naming plothole AND helps prevent audience confusion.

Think about it. Why would you name maidens after the seasons when you already had characters named Summer, Winter, and Fall in the show with Vernal planned?

V5's fights were a mixed bag for me. I liked Weiss vs Lancers, Yang vs Bandits, Blake vs Illia, and Cinder vs Raven.

I was lukewarm or hated the rest of the fights.