Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-27144409-20160226002630/@comment-4621444-20160714205845

SomeoneYouUsedToKnow wrote: Leathercock wrote: 1. Muggle? He comes from a famous, exhalted line of hunters. Even animals have aura. It was an infodump. He should have known, like come on!

2. Whatch the scene with the blonde hottie breaking the iceboulder again.

3. Sure, Qrow is a badass............

4. As I just siad. He saw them. Mercury promptly freaks out, when he witness his fight with Winter. Then goes on to fight in the tournament.

5. Sure, if she wants, she can be coy............

6. I think it's odd, because she could have just as easiyl stayed with Ruby. We don't know why she abandoned them, we can easily have a satisfying answer to that.

7. I was under the assumption, that Vale is a kingdom, not a city, thus transportation is cross-country as well. To be honest, I still haven't watched World of Remnant, so there's that. As on wasting resources, well, again flying stadium. 1-Just because things have Aura it doesn't mean it's existence it's known by everyone. It happens often in fiction. "Magic exists, magic is everywhere, all humans can learn and use magic. Too bad not everyone knows magic even exists".

Also, just because he comes from a line of warriors/heroes, it doesn't mean he will know. Look at Ruby. Silver Eye Warrior, and was never told anything about them, not even a tale.

2-You mean the ABRN vs RWBY fight? Dude, is it hard to be more descriptive?

3-Still not worth risking it. Just because you may be capable of winning a fight it doesn't mean you need to happily go fight. Emerald's Semblance only got them so far against Amber, Cinder was not as powerful as she became in Vol.3, and Qrow has many a hundred times more skill and experience than Amber. A possible, unnecesary victory is not worth risking the plan getting ruined.

He really could have, at the least, given a tough fight even if 3-to-1, a tough fight they did not need. Don't you know about the law of conservation of ninjutsu? Higher Quantity only wins if both sides are of equal quality. Otherwise, Higher Quality is what wins. And Qrow was far higher quality compared to them, except maybe Cinder, back then. Minimum, he beats Merc and Emerald, sees everyone close-enough to get a clear picture, and even if Cinder wins, her plans are delayed severely as a result.

4-Difference between "saw them" and "saw them clearly enough to identify them". He can't just accuse someone because they may be who he saw. He didn't a look at them clear enough to be definitively sure. There's a reason witnesses are not always treated as "definitive proof" of anything: they may be wrong. You didn't see someone clearly enough, so how can you be sure some random person is him/her?

5-Not quite what I was thinking, but sure, we can go with that as well.

6-You speak as if it was her choice. But it's obvious it wasn't. Papa Schnee just wouldn't allow anything even slightly rebellious, seeing how she, from his PoV, almost died and how Vale is no longer safe at all, not to mention Beacon is a Grimm nest now. She came with him to Atlas, and period. Back when she defied her dad to go to Beacon, he forced her to beat a tough enemy, expecting her to lose, and back then he had less reasons to refuse her.

7-Vale at least looks more along the lines of a city-state. Which makes sense. Remember that expansion is difficult. Mt. Glenn in fact is an example of that. At the moment, the only place where air transport would be necesary to reach, is Beacon, and they already got airships for that, multiple ones, so they don't have a need to make flying cars, because they already got vehicles to fulfill anything flying cars would fulfill.

As for the stadium, I already told you: International Wonder. It's no different than the Statue of Liberty, or the Tower of Paris, except only in the fact that it was made by the 4 kingdoms together, as a symbol of peace and unity. 1. Uhum. Not at all weird not knowing about it. Also, the silver eyes thing as well. One would think at the very least it would be like folk tales, like we know about made up people millenia ago, who fought gods and stuff as in the Gilgames epic, or Ramajana, and in Remnant that shit was not only real, it is still an everyday reality, the struggle against the grim and such. Silver eyes being a the sign of a OP grimkiller, I don't say people would everywhere still believe it, but I would think, thosse who have silver eyes might have, regardless of having actual superpowers or not.

2. Yeah, the very first fight of season 3, if memory serves me right.

3 and 4. Still, not worth risking it? The minute she got Ambers full power, she became powerful enough to take out Ozpin. Gamechanger. But sure, retreating makes sense to you. Whatever. Qrow is more powerful than Amber. If you say so. Many a hundred times more experience and skill. Yep. And of course, she needed them to her planes, like framing Yang, so... which was important, cuz... well, at least, she really did cares for them, no harm can come to those two humans. Getting Ambers powers are not that important, plus she def had to know about qrow, who was doing secret errands for Ozzy. Your logic is infallible. Should they somehow beat him, maybe that's a huge blow to their enemies, and it's not like they can hide her somewhere, or attempt to, I don't know, transfer her remaining power. That can only be done by buggloves. Plus, as a master of all jutsus, he might have beaten them by getting like 2 inches close to their face, and thus see them, as opposed to the enormous distance of a big effin sword. This way, they don't even have to change their outfits.