Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-14302856-20131005224013/@comment-96.42.20.50-20141127202633

I think I'm gonna break this down and over-analyze.

Ruby Has a mechanical scythe/gun, and a semblance that boosts her speed like infinite times.

Maka Has a magical human/scythe, and hunts that greatly increase attack power, and can merge her soul with her weapon, greatly increasing power, speed, and strength for both parties.

Ruby is very fast, and could likely block/dodge everything Maka throws at her, however if Maka used one of her more powerful hunts, Soul could likely destroy Crescent Rose, since Crescent Rose is mechanical, and has many moving parts.

The gun half of crescent rose would likely be inconsequential to Maka's health because as shown in her first fight against Medusa, she is very agile, and can dodge fast moving objects easily. This probably applies to bullets as well.

Then it gets more complicated as they move to Melee combat, as both Ruby and Maka specialize there.

I bring up that Ruby has speed on her side again, and Maka has power. If Maka landed a blow on Ruby, or broke Crescent Rose, Ruby would be done for, but if Ruby came close to harming Maka, Soul would likely turn human form again and take the blow for her, though that would damage or even kill him, and then maka would be weaponless.

Weaponless Maka Vs Weaponless Ruby would be absolutely no contest. Maka would beat the living shit out of Ruby.

Weaponless Maka Vs Weapon wielding Ruby, Ruby would win

Weapon wielding Maka Vs Weaponless Ruby, Maka would win without batting an eyelash

Weapon wielding Maka Vs Weapon wielding Ruby, I'm gonna go with Maka because she has similar speed to Ruby, but much more power.

3-1, Maka wins.