Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-26397825-20160609071212/@comment-28288412-20160709212007

1. We don't know if obsidian or glass is a dust type and thus if Cinder's manipulation of it relates back to dust.

2. We don't know Cinder's semblance and I don't care if you find it a flawed argument, it is a reasonable one due to how it could affect this situation.

3. Remember that I am arguing against a person's ability to reshape/reform dust through the use of aura. Glynda can do it but she is telekinetic. Cinder can do it but her abilities are still very much a mystery. No one else to my knowledge has ever shown the ability to do it.

We have no reason to reasonably think another aura user can do what Cinder did without the use of a semblance variance that allows it. Especially as aura normally has shown only two basic functions: Protect (Shield) and Attack (Slash or Pulse). Neither of these basic functions suggest that aura can on its own do something as complex as reform a dust based object, be it in midarir or even not.