Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-98.249.185.89-20170613040727/@comment-4010415-20170614024533

I feel like you're twisting it by saying that Monty was only speaking in context to what Ruby and Yang believe, when it is entirely likely that he was speaking literally, that they really are half-sisters. The fact is that Monty had absolutely positively no reason at all to tell us that Ruby and Yang are half-sisters at that point. All he needed to do was say "No, Yang and Summer are different people." Instead, he told us that Summer was Ruby's mother and that Ruby and Yang are half-sisters.

You can't blame people for taking the Word of God (the word of the series' creator) as a fact, especially when he and the writers never intentionally lied about anything in the show, and when they tell us something from a character's perspective, they make it clear that what they are saying is from the character's perspective.