Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24901923-20150922051229/@comment-25555436-20150922205848

If he failed at explaining it, he failed at building it. It's not enough with just saying "this is Remnant, there are 4 kingdoms, and lots of shadow animals". He needed to explain, establish or even better, show in some way how each Kingdom was, and how Dust is, at the very least.

But:

-We don't know at all how Atlas, Vacuo or Mistral are. All we have is just hypothesis and theories with barely any evidence to back some up.

-We don't even know how their economies or cultures are. Is Atlas a police state? Is it a monarchy? Is it a democracy that just happens to have great technological emphasis? We don't know, nothing at all.

-We have like a dozen colors of Dust, and multiple forms of each. And we barely know what some are.

He failed at world-building. Even with WoR, he failed at it.