Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-75.162.230.203-20171102052825/@comment-4010415-20171102065631

The thing is, Monty outright stated that Ruby and Yang are half-sisters, and the members of the RWBY crew never intentionally lie about anything. There was no reason for Monty to have told us they're half-sisters, as the question he was asked wasn't about that. He was asked if Yang is Summer, since Yang had said she has many names in the Yellow Trailer, and he decided to go further than just saying "No" by clarifying that Summer is Ruby's mother and Yang is Ruby's half-sister.

Then anyone on CRWBY, including the writers (even Monty, back in the day), is asked a question that would spoil a plot twist or anything like that, they don't give a straight answer. If it's in a text-based Q&A, they just plain don't answer it or they make a joke, like in the recent Tumblr Q&A where someone asked what plans they have for future seasons and Lindsay (Ruby's voice) joked about real life seasons and said she's looking forward to winter because of Christmas. (Link to that) If it's an in-person Q&A like at a convention panel, they tend to either make a joke or say "We don't answer spoiler questions."

So even the argument that people have tried making by saying "Well, writers lie in order to protect plot twists!!" is ineffective because CRWBY hasn't done this. It's just not Rooster Teeth's style to lie to us about their shows just to hide a plot twist.

Part of the annoyance, at least around here, is people editing Qrow's page to say that he's Ruby's father, when that is only a theory, whereas the show has presented him to us as Ruby's honorary uncle. As long as the show is presenting him as being someone Ruby considers her uncle, his wiki page is going to continue saying he is her honorary uncle. But some people want to change the page to reflect their theory.