Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170417075739/@comment-28522425-20170509051453

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote: Terminus99 wrote: Jacques was most likely trying to take her to a quiet place to calm down. That seems to me like the appropiate action to take when your daughter starts yelling at the guests at a fundraiser about how horrible human beings they are for no apparent reason. I don't think we have much reason to believe he would ever do what is appropriate as a parent. Nothing we have seen up to this point shows him to be anything but a controlling and hostile figure who is quick to use physical force against his children, while showing no real compassion or understanding towards them. Nothing about his reaction betrayed a better nature or anything reasonable like you suggest.

I'm not suggesting anything about a better nature or anything.

I said that taking her to a calm place to calm down, and then explain the situation about how her reaction was due to trauma to the guests, would have been the right action to take in that situation, and is likely what Jacques would have done if Weiss hadn't almost killed someone accidentally.

Regardless of Jacques' intentions, he was doing the right thing at the moment.