Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-4555743-20171116223520/@comment-25936766-20171118134818

1) We don't know if Cinder herself is from Mistral. And even if she was, it does not mean that she was in Mistral when she recruited Emerald or Merc.

Especially given how her mission was in Vale, and she even meets up with Adam's group in Forever Fall, located in Vale (right beside Beacon, actually).

Cinder's hair only shows that this is a flashback. Not that she was in Mistral at all. She had the same short hair when talking to Adam and fighting the Fall Maiden.

2) You're taking Tai's words excessively literally. The reason he called it a "temper tantrum" is due to it's mechanics: Yang gets hit, she gets energy, then can use said energy to hit harder back.

For it to be useful, she must be beaten up sufficiently, at which point she can "explode" and beat them back in anger. Justified anger in some cases, since being beaten up is rarely anyone's hobby. That's what Tai means with "Temper Tantrum".

The thing is just that Yang has anger issues that lead to unconscious activation of her Semblance even without having been beaten up.