Talk:Scarlet/@comment-4010415-20141113085419

If Scarlet turns out to be non-binary, then will we change the pronouns to gender neutral pronouns? Because, seriously, one of the appropriate ways to address a non-binary person with pronouns is gender neutral ponouns, since they are neither he nor she. He and she are both binary.

I still don't really see the problem with setting Scarlet's sex/gender to "unknown" since it has been questioned so much and using gender neutral pronouns for now. It's not like we're calling them an "it." We're using legitimate pronouns to address someone of unknown sex/gender, and it's a completely appropriate way to address them.

If someone says "My teacher said something weird today," and you don't know the sex/gender of that teacher, you ask "What did they say?"

Also, it's kind of rude to assume one's sex/gender. I know that Scarlet is a fictional character, but still, some people may find it kind of rude that this page addresses someone of uncertain sex/gender as a male under a mere assumption. We also shouldn't get used to addressing Scarlet as male, in case they turn out to actually be female. There is reasonable doubt that they're male.