Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170708180328/@comment-25936766-20170910165311

KingFubuki92 wrote: 1) Can we really even use Smile to pass judgement on her when, A. We don't have the full song,

2) B. The Songs we can't use too much for evidence after the whole B.M.B.L.B. fiasco,

3) and C. The Song could be her current mentality, not her current actions (How she wants to feel but not what she's actually done)?

4) @Someone Is it really right to say we have shitty taste? On what grounds is our taste shitty, Your opinion? 1) True, but it's something, and something says more than nothing.

2) But Bmblb was thrown in as a For-Fun "Consolation Extra", no? Nothing says it's the same with Smile.

3) That....actually changes nothing. If we based ourselves on what she's actually done and just that....well, read below:

---

4) Let's see, appearance-wise she's as flat as a board, has patches on her skin that make her look like a cow sometimes, and when she changes color she looks ridiculous.

Backstory-wise, we know she had a shitty childhood and that she beat the shit out of some girls for laughing over Faunus's miseries, and then became a terrorist, because apparently beating up humans is Justice just because it's for "a good cause".

Personality-wise, aside from what Smile implies, what do we know about her? She can't even bring herself to hurt Blake, unlike Adam, and while that makes her less of a bastard, it does make her seem more indecisive. She can't handle people saying she looks human, and she advocates disproportionate retribution.

Skill-wise she hasn't proven herself besides being agile, and sucking at Stealth.

Overall, what we've seen of her isn't too impressive, too charming and attractive. She doesn't have the looks, and we don't know enough about her either.