Thread:99.45.171.100/@comment-27404492-20170406212527/@comment-99.45.171.100-20170406215852

Even the elemental aspect is a bit questionable when you consider both Cinder and Amber have used Dust despite having those powers. Cinder used dust prior to V3, because her being half-Maiden was a retcon. Originally she was a raw dust user who wove it into her clothing. Monty came up with the Maidens and retroactively inserted them into the story during V3.

It's not a "theory" that she cares about humanity. SHE CALLS OZPIN SICK AND CRUEL FOR MISTREATING HUMANS IN HER IMAGE SONG. If she didn't give a shit, or if she was what Grey thinks she is, she'd be HAPPY with him for leading countless humans to their deaths.