Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-24218038-20131202202153/@comment-14909251-20131205185639

I don't think she is still in the White Fang, but I firmly believe that she is lying or misleading the others to some extent. She talks of sabotage and arson, but not murders, yet Weiss indicates the White Fang has murdered people. The key thing to remember with the Black Trailer is that the crew members would be low-level employees with little connection to the broader conflict. Her desire to not see them killed does not mean she left because the White Fang began killing people. I do find her response of not wanting to believe the White Fang were behind the robberies a bit peculiar, though I suppose when one thinks about it, it makes a bit of sense. Robbing major company shipments and even killing high-level corporate officials may have seemed acceptable to her as a part of revolution, but robbing random shopkeepers makes them little different from those they are fighting against.

Overall, I think there is yet more to Blake's involvement with the White Fang that she is keeping hidden and that it would make her team a lot more leery of her than just finding out she was in the White Fang. Basically, I have a feeling Blake has killed people and is not mentioning this detail because she has a strong amount of guilt over it. One has to keep in mind that she was essentially a child soldier and it is unlikely she would be completely forthcoming about her experiences.