Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-25713341-20140905032400/@comment-3146930-20140908203209

However Michael from AH (don't even know what that is but whatever) does not have a 17 year old daughter. Cinder in order to pass as a student could at most be 30, which would make her 13 when she had Yang. The only way to make that less creepy would be if Cinder is 35 currently, but that still means she was together with Yang's dad probably before she was 18.

Also if Monty was replying to the picture the person sent to him, it asks if Cinder is their mom and Monty replied 100% nope. I wouldn't call it the middle ground so much as denialism. Blake being a Faunus and Penny being a robot were easy to guess based off Blake's song in her trailer and Penny's odd mannerisms and abilities. However those are isolated incidents, Cinder being Yang's mom involves 2 people and there isn't really a lot supporting it. In fact everything seems to point away from it unless you want to get into creepy pedophile territory.