Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-27082610-20170624011641/@comment-27425734-20170714234316

TheoldStone1000 wrote: By removing Dust: I've managed to create the base attack and Audible Que in one great big sound barrier breaking whistle, even I'd be deaf from it, without hearing, you don't have control over your awareness rendering you vulnerable. What do you mean by "create the base attack and Audible Que in one great big sound barrier breaking whistle"? I thought the base attack of this Semblance was converting Aura into a totally random element by whistling a tune. Unless, you mean that the user activates their Semblance and emits a whistle as an attack that renders them deaf along with converting their Aura into a random element.

This Semblance is giving me a headache with these convulted mechanics you've come up with.

By adding Dust: it makes the Semblance work with a lack of actual soundwaves when it's produced

So if I'm reading this correctly, using Dust negates the need for the user to whistle a tune in order to cause a random elemental effect in addition to an effect that corresponds to the type of song whistled. However, that makes it pointless for the user to even bother whistling in the first place.

Causing some sort of combined effect... Whenever another Elemental attack would be produced in this process, the elements in this combination would have a chance to either Self-Destruct in the User's face or Cancel each other out.

That depends on the type of Dust and whatever random elemental effect the user conjures upon using their Semblance. But, if the user doesn't whistle a tune in the first place why would the Dust cancel out the elemental effect at all? The mechanics of this Semblance contradict themselves.

So, if there aren't any Elemental Attacks present, the User has less of a risk of either of these things happening, making it a luck based semblance.

This Semblance is needlessly overcomplicated. I think you're adding too many constraints to this Semblance that make it useless in most situations. Though that might also be because the way you word things is confusing as heck (」゜ロ゜)」