Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-190.47.114.141-20170910035917/@comment-27684451-20171011004554

ChishioKunrin wrote: SomeoneYouUsedToKnow wrote: Except:

1) Pyrrha was barely able to even whisper that to Cinder. It was nothing noisy that could be heard like 10 feet away.

2) Ruby was dashing at full-speed up the tower. The air would not be still at all. Even if she had moved slower the moving air would've still made it very difficult for Ruby to hear something someone could barely whisper meters away.

This last bit is the most noticeable. Anyone who's sitted by the window seat in a moving car has experienced that at least once in their life.

Overall, it was pretty bull. Ruby wasn't just not there, she couldn't have even heard Pyrrha with such clarity, if at all. 1. Pyrrha didn't whisper it, though... She spoke at a normal level. Just looked Cinder right in the eye, sat up, and said, not whispered, "Do you believe in destiny?"

2. Which is why I said in the post you quoted: "No matter what we think, the writers have decided that she did hear what they said." 1) Yeah. She didn't really whisper it. However, she didn't yell it. When Pyrrha was saying this to Cinder, Ruby was a good 8-12 stories down around the corner. Even if it happened in Ruby's line of sight, it was perfectly quiet, and Ruby was standing still, in that open air environment, with nothing to echo the voices, Ruby still probably wouldn't here them well enough.

2) Do you have any sources for this? I haven't been able to find anywhere that says they said this.