Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4830106-20131108040231/@comment-16502426-20140105044639

Wait a minute... When someone asked if we'd see any older students, they replied "maybe we already have". Now, I just assumed that (unless they were just messing with us) that could ONLY be referring to Velvet, since she was the only student not confirmed to be in her first year.

I never even thought about the possibility that Melanie and Miltia could be students. I actually now think that there's a decent chance that they are students, since the only other person who could be the "older student" was Velvet, and she's always been seen with first-years.

Again, they could have just been messing with us with that comment. But based on how quick and unanimous the crew's reaction was, I think it was genuine.