User blog comment:Zathronas/Analysis by an author: Beacon Ozpin/@comment-24116665-20131210183047/@comment-24218038-20131211014612

It's not thats it hasn't been done before 98 but why do it? what would it bring to the story, Ozpin would still be there with one arm missing still protecting Ruby. Explain to me how it would help the story. That's the difference between analysis and speculation. Analysis can be speculation based on verifyable facts.

When I explain Ozpin's character, I base myself by what I have seen of him and my expertise in creating a story. I decided to do this blog because I saw a lot of speculation based on nothing but wishful thinking. Now don't take that as a reprimand 98. it isn't at all, speculation can be fun too but rarely will you turn out being right. Now give me your reasoning behind Ozpin losing an arm. How will it affect the story? How will it affect the other characters? I've changed my mind before when somebody gave me proper reasoning.

I used to say that Blake lied to her teammates but the evidence showed otherwise. Now I changes my reasoning there. Go for it 98! :)