Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-98.249.185.89-20170613040727/@comment-27312496-20170613043445

He didn't have to say Ruby and Yang were half-sisters at all. He could have just said no Yang isn't Summer Rose. But he went further then that.

There is no evidence that Qrow is Ruby father. At no point has it so much been even hinted at. It also would serve no purpose to the plot other then drama for the sake of drama. It would diminish there current relation that despite having no blood ties they are still family.

Then there is the question of why the lies. Why would Summer, Tai and Qrow keep this a secret from Ruby and Yang? There would be no reason for them to do so.