Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170918133425/@comment-34633327-20170930153619

SomeoneYouUsedToKnow wrote:

KingFubuki92 wrote: 1) But the she wouldn't call Menagerie "home", since then she would've had to move around a lot, and thus has no set home to speak of. Like in Vacuo . At most, she would've called Anima, or Mistral (the Kingdom's territory, not the city), her home, if that was the case. Which she didn't, she specifically said "Menagerie".

2) Not necesarily. Blake said the wild-life was pretty dangerous, and I assume that's excluding any Grimm in the island or any aquatic Grimm that reaches the shore and tries anything.

Why would she speak with such matter-of-fact tone about the wildlife in Menagerie, if she hardly spent any time in Menagerie before V4?

3) And how did she know that? She hasn't seen her parents in years, and the last time she did she left them while she went with the new WF. Kali and Ghira both react surprised at even seeing her again.

And Menagerie has no CCT, so don't try to use it as an argument. 1) Refer to Point 3). In addition, assuming she did live in Menagerie, she should have known then that the WF held a presence there, seeing as her Dad was the former leader, unless they suddenly established a presence there after Ghira stepped down for whatever reason. And no, she didn't know, neither did Sun, and Ilia's flashback is not evidence as that looks like Forever Fall in the background.

2) It could be common knowledge and Sun just didn't know about it (He isn't really that bright for a guy named Sun), or because it was given to the Faunus, she may have learned the idea of it being slap in the face while in the WF. Like a common idea Adam could have preached was:

"This small island where our kind call home: Menagerie. Some of our people see it as a gift from the humans for helping in the Great War. But we know what it really is! A backhanded insult disguised as a gift! This island is filled with the most nightmarish of Grimm and feral beasts, so much so that 2/3rds of it can't even be explored without risk of death! Menagerie is no gift! It is a gilded cage! It may offer Faunus safe haven from Humans, but it also pens them up like a dog that disobeys its master!"

The whole idea could have been preached to her by him, and she is going off what he told her. Though the common knowledge seems more likely, what with Qrow even calling out the "slap to the face" thing, and Sun is just very ignorant of Faunus stuff. (Again, Sun is really dim)

3) We know she did yell at Ghira and Kali before she ran off to stay in the WF, they could very well have told her they were going to Menagerie and asked her to come with them before she yelled at them.