Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-25266931-20161111003308/@comment-25936766-20161111024702

KNN005 wrote:

1-The Grimm aren't elemental because they are born from what's left after that element in the dust is used.

2-Never seen an Ao Kuang.

3-The Grimm aren't Power Rangers, they're not gonna have a color to match an element. They're being born from the absence of the element anyway

4-Why else would they not need to eat and only attack Faunus and Humans mainly leaving all else alone.

5-Yet we're told there's no magic for real line RWBY. So they're not demons. They're science based.

6-Dust takes many forms. Why not a living one?

7-I think the pools of ink the wolves came from was Dust crushed down into a fine paste. Like beating someone's head some much, with such pressure, all that's left is a goop. 1-Dust has been used for centuries. Logically, quite a lot of it has been used up entirely. Then, how come no one noticed, IN CENTURIES, that Grimm are born from empty Dust?

2-That's how I call Sea Dragon. Alt. Name is Qinglong.

3-Then, shouldn't they be completely colorless?

4-"Being born from Dust" does not answer that question at all in even the slightest way. Because being born from Dust, does not explain nor justify why they do that. At all.

5-Ugh....there IS magic in RWBY'''. Dust '''is just not magic. Magic is things like Maidens and Silver Eyes.

6-Water can take many forms, why not a living one? <-That cannot be called a rational argument at all.

7-.....Dude, we are flesh, meat and bones. Squishy and with a liquid running up and down inside us. Dust are Crystals, at most refined into Powder. You cannot crush a Crystal to turn it into a goop.