Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-4555743-20171116223520/@comment-4555743-20171119062131

"they are evidence that people can accidentally activate their Semblance because of negative emotions"

I understood your implication pretty clearly from the start. IMO, you are artificially complicating things here to make them suit your theory. (don't take that hard, we all do at times :) )

What Weiss have done activating her semblance in outrage is no different in nature from taking out a pistol and shooting a few bullets into the ceiling in outrage, for example. Or throwing a good punch in someone's fat face. There is no need to look for specific connection between semblance and anger here, because there is a more simple and natural logic: Weiss had no pistol (and no habit of using one), she did not have the physique or training to throw a good punch in the face, but she had a natural weapon in form of her semblance. So that's what happened.

Same goes for Pyrrha episode (though in her case it was not outrage, but the desire to be left alone).

Semblance is a part of an individual, so there is nothing strange that it can be used in outrage in forms that can cause regret later. Just as arms, and legs, and carried weapons.

Yes, and one more thing. The idea that Yang's eyes turning red = Yang's semblance activated is absolutely NOT certain, you just kinda pull that out of the thin air as a fact. It is not. It might easily be just her personal quirk that her eyes change color when she is truly angry, and might have no direct connection to semblance whatsoever - if the primary trigger of her semblance is indeed received damage to her aura, and not anger.