Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-32910370-20170830113709/@comment-25936766-20171001133055

Brainfriiz wrote:

1) All that training for the academy paid off! She still needs to take 10 seconds just to get her posture right. She doesn't even hold her rapier properly! And as I've postulated before, she never even shines in any 1v1 fight. She develops her support role in all the team training she does.

1) Before she even begins at Beacon, she's already taking out mafia hideouts. So much for not really having any training or real fight experience.

2) Rooster Teeth in general has toned down a lot of characters to add tension to their fights.

3) As I've said before.......... Okay, for starters, I thought that discussion was who would win between Current Yang and Current Weiss. Not V1 Yang and V1 Weiss. Fail there. That aside:

1) I literally said Yang (and Ruby) had more training and experience than Weiss, by the time they get to Beacon. I don't even see the point you're trying to make.

What I said was that Yang was less skilled, which is completely separate from training and from experience. Yang doesn't even bother blocking the simplest of hits, she just charges forward Leeroy Jenkins style thinking that taking damage doesn't mean shit since her Semblance will just make her win.

Also, just a sidenote, but, Junior and his henchmen are not a mafia in the slightest. Junior is an information broker, and his henchmen are literally the weakest characters ever fought in this show, even including the baby Beowulves in Ruby's Red Trailer. So, not really worth praising Yang for taking them out.

-

2) Well, they had to. There's no tension when even 1st-year Huntsmen in Training are so badass they can take on an army and win in seconds. That was the entire problem with the Breach: No tension due to Monty making everyone supreme badasses, especially Coco, all for the sake of "awesome".

--

3) Yeaaaaah, you failed. You already failed to make an argument here, since you're using V1 Yang and V1 Weiss as "proof", not current Weiss or Current Yang, or even V3 Yang or V3 Weiss.

You wanna prove Yang can beat Weiss? Then use Current Yang and Current Weiss in your arguments. Not the ones when they literally started. Not to mention that your "points" are completely unbalanced. Comparing V1 Weiss in her first battle with wild Grimm, with V1 Yang in the Yellow Trailer.

Did Yang defeat a giant suit of armor possessed by a Grimm, by herself, prior to actually starting her studies at Beacon? Nope. Weiss did, literally the fight that led to Jacques allowing her to go to Beacon.