Board Thread:Episode Discussion/@comment-34633327-20171229202410/@comment-2602:306:32AD:9C0:9065:727:3DDF:79F3-20171230220103

2601:440:8401:2590:6129:4989:D955:7D82 wrote: Lord Jaric wrote: Weiss wound is serious but not fatal. Jaune's semblance doesn't have to do anything to safe her. It's the writing of the show: 'How do we save this character who's dying? We have an mysterious power that we haven't yet explained of shown - let's use that' and that would be Jaune's semblance. They can't have characters react, develop, or heal normally, this is a fantasy world! It HAS to be by magical means! It HAS TO! EVERY TIME!!! I feel like that's insulting the writers too much. Any power they have revealed in the past has at least been foreshadowed and they haven't really saved anybody in particular. Ruby's silver eyes were foreshadowed by Ozpin's interest in them and they were activated by Pyrrha's DEATH it didn't save her. I can't really think of anything else that you might have been thinking of with that line of thought other than Blake's semblance being used to save Yang or Weiss's summoning which both were explained. Also people have healed normally in the show. Look at Yang, she healed like any normal human being and even got a prosthetic. And Weiss got a scar from the white trailer.

I really think you should respect the writers more. Yes, the writing is far from perfect, it's had odd moments and poor pacing but writing is hard and I think CRWBY has done an amazing job of creating likable (and purposefully detestable) characters as well as and interesting world and storyline. One thing that I really like about the show is the world building. Unfortunately, a lot of peices of fiction don't do a very good job of it but I think CRWBY has.

Of course, this is all my opinion and you are perfectly entitled to disagree.