Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-35941743-20190304195312/@comment-14909251-20190321235634

73.Anon.52 wrote:

1. since you haven't been paying attention, I must direct you towards the early volumes... her MO has changed drastically, that should tell you she's trying something different, like involving a level of honesty she never has before.

You are still ultimately speculating and have no grounds to argue that they know her plan and that therefore revealing it wouldn't somehow turn Cinder against Salem.

2. A. you are straw-manning my argument entirely, I'm not saying she's a moron

I didn't say you did, but to think she is still pushing the same plan after it failed and not having any clear way it could succeed without Oz is basically making her a moron.

3. Is it? just how much anime have you watched? the secret organization saving the world rarely gets revealed to the public, even during/after the apocalypse, they don't need to know about Salem to know the world is ending, much as humanity 1 had no fucking clue the gods were about to destroy them because a girl with a deathwish got a few kingdoms to rebel.

Heavily implied already that she is going to be present for some kind of attack involving Atlas. Plus, it would be quite hard to imagine any attack on Salem in Grimm central that wasn't backed by considerable force.

I don't doubt Tyrian will die, but I think you wholly over-estimate the # that need to live, and 50% being remotely believable far outstrips necessity.

I'm not talking about the number needing to live or die, but that having the ones who live and getting accepted be exactly the ones who already show clear elements of virtue doesn't sell the message.