Talk:Lie Ren/@comment-128.151.150.18-20170220171437/@comment-25936766-20170503010930

@Anon: 1-No, you are assuming. Because your entire argument talks as if Ren could definitely do X if he combined his Semblance with a physical attack, when X is completely different from what he could do with his Semblance. You don't speak with an "I think" tone. You speak as if he actually could.

But you are not theorizing. A theory is an hypothesis supported by reasonable arguments and evidence. Not proven (thus not a fact), but has some foundation.

You, meanwhile, ignore the fact that your ideas don't follow what he's been shown to be able to do, by canon, or assume different things about how X works, what X does, or what he could do. Hoping he could do something else changes nothing.

That we've seen Semblances do things we didn't know they could do before, changes nothing, due to this thing called "Experience". If we have never SEEN, and never BEEN TOLD, that this guy could do X thing with his Semblance, we cannot assume he can.

At most, if it's something that said guy could logically do through creativity. For example, if Ruby's Semblance is Speed, making her move fast, she could logically make "tornadoes" by running in circles.

Your arguments lack all that. They do not follow what is known, have no evidence to support them, and thus are not theories, they are wild assumptions.

--

2-Did you seriously interpret the parts where I said "sad, angry euphoric" as somehow directed at you? I was clearly just mentioning what Ren's Semblance would do to you if you were sad/angry/euphoric: Calm you down. Because that's what it does, or at least possibly does: Calm the target down.

Learn to read.