User blog comment:Varzan Deodinm Beldinm/What if We're Right?/@comment-24218038-20131231171515/@comment-23790511-20131231180416

I don't care if people want to speculate on a few things. But when many, many, MANY people guess a major plot-point and end up correct, I blame it on mediocre-writing.

You and I may not see eye-to-eye on this, but this wasn't made to spite you or anyone specifically. I made this blog to ask everyone if they felt that RWBY was predictable and it's story's impact was lessened because of those predictions and speculations. For me it's a "yes" but I could just be in the minority here.

When Volume 2 comes out, I will simply avoid looking at Blogs dealing with future events of the show. It may have been fun for me to look at everyone else's guesses on what would happen in the next episode if Volume 1. But in the end, I couldn't help but feel like I was ruining the story for myself by doing so.

And you're correct there have been a lot of tiny, intrinsic, and outright ridiculous speculations that don't affect my feelings of the show whatsoever. I remember one person claiming that Cinder Fall was blind in one eye because her intro silhouette had hair covering an eye. Things small like that don't bother me, neither does theories on why a certain character acts a certain way.

I guess I can sum it all up in one question: If RWBY turns out exactly as you predicted, would you be amazed by your speculation skills, or would you be disappointed that you knew what would happen the whole time?