Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-73.91.2.197-20161222044456/@comment-80.192.6.40-20161224174238

What other hints do you have? The current ones aren't great:

Suspicion of ages - can be explained by ChishioKunrin's suggestion that it was an unplanned pregnancy. They're also about 2 years apart. A lot can happen in 2 years.

Qrow's drinking - he may be naturally susceptible to alcohol or uses it to cope with his job.

Taiyang doesn't seem to be the kind to fool around - just because he doesn't seem to be doesn't mean it isn't possible. Plenty of people commit crime who don't fit the common perception of a criminal. Perhaps he just suffers from "a weakness of the flesh" (he was also possibly a much younger man at the time, like early 20's. By current estimates he's at least 38).

Authors lying to pull a Red Herring - absence of evidence. One just has to think "they're lying". They could also then be lying about lying (absence of evidence again) and so on. And this would also cast suspicion on anything else they've ever said about the show, which is a huge can of worms that'd be very risky to open.

Evidence for the claim Qrow is Ruby's father is currently thin (and I would argue can scarcly be called evidence) and there are alternative explanations that carry at least as much weight and probably more.