User blog comment:BenRG/The Chosen One/@comment-24113789-20131212232806

Hmm, that is a rather massive theory... It seems unlikely that, after only half a season, one fan could hit the nail on the head. On the other, It does not have any major inconsistencies with canon yet, so It has a good deal of likelihood. I do not think he knew as much about Ruby as you think he did: "...You have... silver eyes..." in an unsure manner, implying he did not already know. "Where did you learn to do this? . . . They taught you to use one of the most dangerous weapons ever designed?" Why would he ask if he already knew?

On the other hand, he might have been asking to see if she would tell the truth, because if she would not that would be a pretty early give-away that she was not the One. Still, the unsureness in his voice when he notices her eyes... he was clearly looking for it, but was it for the reason you think? Did he really know so much about Ruby?

Well... we shall see.