Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-14909251-20160415010953

ACWeapons wrote: The arrow was made of glass/obsidian, not Dust. It was made like her swords with her Maiden fire powers. She was making those arrows before she got Amber's Maiden power as Cinder used one against Amber in the flashback episode. It presumably is made of Dust. Given what we know, she may use some combination of earth and fire Dust to make it. Lord Jaric wrote: I'm going to have to disagree with you on this one DA. Pretty much everything that has been presented to us about Pyrrha is that she is not coming back. And Amber is definitely dead taking an arrow to the heart. Did you do a chest X-ray and determine the exact placement of the arrow? Are you familiar with Remnant's medical technology and the limitations of Aura's healing properties? Were it a headshot or her body was obliterated it would be one thing, but people in the real word have survived being shot in the heart, so the idea that Amber could definitely not have been revived is based off nothing.

Regarding Pyrrha, I addressed that already. Even in this theory Pyrrha would not really be coming back and would still be essentially dead and out of the show, it would just be that her soul and Aura remains tethered to another person's body that is under that person's control. More than enoguh room there to allow for confirmation of her "death" with her still being sort of alive in a sense.