Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-14138255-20140926004722/@comment-25399914-20140928072914

MetallicArcher wrote: -Mercen-X wrote:

--Blake is the only character for whom I'm really not sure.

I headcanon she is from Atlas. A child worker at a Dust mine until the White Fang took her in after her parents die din an accident or due to disease associated with poor working conditions. It's been stated Blake isn't from the kingdoms and the World of Remnant ep 2 stated that this isn't uncommon.

Also if people are from the same kingdom it doesn't mean that they attended the same combat school. Ozpin when asking Blake about the pier mentioned she hadn't been to "one of the many combats schools" meaning there are possibly a couple of dozen per kingdom.

I don't think clothing is going to be a great indicator of where someone comes from. Ruby is vary uncomfortable on formal dress like Sun whilst her own sister embraces the opportunity to turn heads.

So far we can have a pretty good guess at or already know

Vale - Yang & Ruby (Patch & Signal are part of Romans map of Vale)

Atlas - Weiss & Winter (+family), Penny

Mistral - Neptune & Pyrrha

Vacuo - Sun

Other - Blake

I'm going to guess

Vale - Taeyang, Qrow, Glynda, Summer,, Zwei, Junior & the Twins, Ren & Nora (I don't know why but I just get the impression that Nora has known Yang since before Beacon so she's one of Yangs friends from Signal)

Atlas - James (I think he attended Beacon but isn't from Vale and Ozpin was a fellow student or if immortal teacher), Penny's farther

Mistral - Mercury, Cinder

Vacuo -

Other - Juane (the cities have walls so why was he stuck in a tree whilst his friends were for there lives), Adam