Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170918133425/@comment-25936766-20170930150338

KingFubuki92 wrote:

1) By "Outside the Kingdom's" she could have refered to one of the numerous villages not under a kingdom's watch, as the Academy's are all literaly in the actual kingdom's center.She did say "If you can't fight, you can't survive."

2) However Menagerie's only place to fight is in the deserts, which she would have no reason for going in since the areas that were hospitable had already been settled in, i.e., Kuo Kuana was already established.

3) As for her referring to Menagerie as home, it could be more she considers where her family is to be home, and knew they would be there from when they stepped down from the WF. 1) But the she wouldn't call Menagerie "home", since then she would've had to move around a lot, and thus has no set home to speak of. Like in Vacuo.

At most, she would've called Anima, or Mistral (the Kingdom's territory, not the city), her home, if that was the case. Which she didn't, she specifically said "Menagerie".

2) Not necesarily. Blake said the wild-life was pretty dangerous, and I assume that's excluding any Grimm in the island or any aquatic Grimm that reaches the shore and tries anything.

Why would she speak with such matter-of-fact tone about the wildlife in Menagerie, if she hardly spent any time in Menagerie before V4?

3) And how did she know that? She hasn't seen her parents in years, and the last time she did she left them while she went with the new WF. Kali and Ghira both react surprised at even seeing her again.

And Menagerie has no CCT, so don't try to use it as an argument.