Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24934890-20180911200208/@comment-24934890-20180916135003

W4rma wrote: Ltmaroon57, Qrow didn't "ask" to speak with Ruby at all. Qrow was already speaking with Ruby and Tai. Qrow gave a polite order in the form of a rhetorical question, "mind if we have a minute?", to Tai that he wanted to speak with her, alone and without Tai in the room. Also, I already covered Miles' statement:

Now, I know exactly well what Miles said, and my wording takes what he says into account. Again, I think that he SHOULD let Qrow be Ruby's biological father. He, and the other writers, already have a great foundation set up for Qrow to be Ruby's biological father.

And "nothing" in your mind obviously uses a different than accepted definition considering that these interpretations have been going on ever since Qrow was introduced, by many fans who started watching RWBY before I ever heard of the show. That's still a question asking for permission my dude. Did you not see Tai was visibly angry? He knew what Qrow was going to talk to her about. Had he not been her father, I don't think he would be so upset about it, but wasn't going to be rude.

Okay, if you know what Miles said, and take it into account, then why the hell do you still believe this theory?

Also, there is a difference between "should happen", and what you want, "should happen because of they have a foundation." What good would it to for the plot? How in the world would it progress it? All it would do is add unneeded drama. It really seems like you think it should happen because you want it to.

Also, as others have stated, with what Monty and Miles both said, it's obvious that the writers NEVER intened their relationship to be taken as, "he's secretly her real dad."