Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4141313-20181128141152/@comment-4141313-20181129090546

73.Anon.52 wrote: BlizzardDragon wrote:

73.Anon.52 wrote:

1. I have seen the theory, I have NOT seen the theory tied down with the baggage you are saddling it with and then using said baggage to dismiss it.

It's like me telling you I was watching YT video's and like MLP, then you tell me well obviously to watch MLP I must be seeing porn because this is the internet, when I never told you I watch MLP on YT... they are completely unrelated stories and neither disproves or proves the other.

The "curse" is both Salem and Ozpin's, Salem cannot die, and Ozpin cannot pass on, a co-mingling of both curses would likely present itself just as the presence of magic did, now personally I don't think it manifested as Oz's did... I think they were stuck "between", Ozpin then found them and used the relics and his own power to finish the process

2, 3, & 4. We were told a MYTH, we were not told Ozpin's version, how many times have you read a true Grimm version of a Disney story with as much in common?

5. I agree with you the theory is unlikely, but do not think it can be dismissed. 1. What baggage? What are you even on about.

As for the curses, how would that even work? Last I checked, while one curse can affect another, curses typically do not end up merging into a third seperate curse.

Ozma doesn't even have a curse. A curse implies it was applied to him as a form of punishment and that it was against his will. He was told what it entailed, accepted the terms, and it worked as advertised. So by technical definition, Ozma wasn't cursed, he was blessed by a God. Now clearly, it didn't stay a blessing, but it was never a curse.

And most of what you are suggesting requires quite a few leaps in logic, with no factual basis behind it.

2-4. Except not only did Ozma himself tell the Myth, if it had been false, Jinn, the one who was revealing what he'd been hiding from them, would have brought it up. It wouldn't have been a big line change. Just take her original line, and add something to it.

Jinn: And at the head of that kingdom blossomed... a family. Ozma and Salem had been blessed with four young maidens.

Would that be hard? But she didn't say that, and considering the argument of Ozma's diminishing magic, which has nothing to do with the myth itself and you noticeably didn't argue against, the implication is that the Myth is true. All Myths have basis in truth afterall. The Girl in the Tower was true up until the claim Ozma and Salem lived happily ever after, which Jinn herself said. So the basis behind the myth would have to mean Ozma was indeed a hermit at some point, was visited by four young women, and they gained magic.

Except only one of Ozma's daughters displayed the propensity for Magic before their death, and if they had it already, why would Ozma's magic be diminishing from giving it.

Plus, there's what Chish said, the castle they lived in was filled with ashes, so at least one of those daughters likely died in that fight, as Salem reconstituted from her ashes.