Board Thread:Off Topic/@comment-26299202-20150615164508/@comment-24891101-20150615185029

Then there is no argument here, if you refuse to detail it further. There are situations in which each weapon would win. This is trivially obvious. Suppose the hammer was initially positioned above the opponents skull, in the middle of a downswing. This is an obvious victory.

Select a scenario, otherwise this is meaningless. You have not provided enough information. Do so, or there is no debate. That is the equivalent of asking for an exact value of a differential equation without specifying initial conditions. There is no exact solution without more information.