Board Thread:Administrative Requests/@comment-34633327-20171126024934/@comment-26397825-20180112010000

Coco: Eh, while it shows here eyes, her model is pretty much never seen without them. Meh

Fox: While the lighting is better, the angle is not. If you could get a shot of him from the same scene looking more towards the camera it would be much better. Also, CharMugs should be a 1x1 ratio to make it square, and his is not. No

Yatsu: That's a good shot. Can we shorten it a bit to make it 1x1 ratio please? To kee it the same as other. Yes, but a 1x1 ratio

Cardin: I don't know what the point of the proposal is for. It's got the same expression, but it's further away and at night time so the colours are subtly shifted, plus he's facing away from the camera. No

Raven. No. Her design is not centered around those eye flares - they're not a thing she does all the time, so it definitely shouldn't be her CharMug. A picture of those can be added to the Maiden part of her powers and abilities section, but we definitely should not use it for her CharMug.

Penny: It doesn't achieve anything along the same lines as the Cardin proposal. It's even from the exact scene the current CharMug is from. No

Ciel: The original has a nicer angle for showing more of her face, being as it's from the side which is not covered by ther hair. No

Flynt: It does show his eyes better and loses the arm from the picture as well. Needs to be shortened to a 1x1 ratio. Meh 

Neon: it shows her face better, including the little heart mark on her cheek that is not visible in the original. Again, shorten it to 1x1 and I'm fine with this. Yes, if made 1x1 ratio

Scarlet: The only thing this accomplishes is by making it not blurry - you would have found a better picture in the SSSN vs NDGO fight. It would have been lit better for one, instead of the night time filter they have going on in that shot. No

Sage: The same reasoning as Scarlet. No

Neptune: This shot just manages to make him look sleazy. No

Lionheart: There's not much difference beyond Lionheart facing the camera more. Meh

Hazel: The new one somehow makes it look like Hazel has no nose or mouth. No

Cinder: The open mouth in that expression makes her look stoned. There's got to be better shots in the previous scenes from the Grand Hall, rather than grabbing one from the Vault. No

Emerald: Needs to be made 1x1 ratio, but otherwise Meh

Mercury: The camera is basically looking up his nose because his head is tilted back. It would be good to get away from the purple-Merc, but there are plenty of better shots than this. Such as from Rest and Resolutions, or even from earlier in the fight for Haven. No

Corsac: Him not wearing a hood is like Raven wearing her mask; it's a thing that happens, but it's not the major part of their design and he spends far more time hooded than not. His CharMug should reflect this. No

Fennec: There's a lighting filter on this image that washes out the colours, and the image doesn't show anything better than the original does. No

Oscar: Proposal 2 is far too far away; these are supposed to be small squares with the character's face in them, and you can barely make out Oscar's face in the second proposed image. The first is much better, though given how many you've pulled from Vault of the Spring Maiden I'm suprised you didn't pull one for Oscar from there too. Proposal One is okay