Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27404492-20170918133425/@comment-25936766-20170930160134

KingFubuki92 wrote: 1) In addition, assuming she did live in Menagerie, she should have known then that the WF held a presence there, seeing as her Dad was the former leader, unless they suddenly established a presence there after Ghira stepped down for whatever reason.

2) It could be common knowledge and Sun just didn't know about it (He isn't really that bright for a guy named Sun), or because it was given to the Faunus, she may have learned the idea of it being slap in the face while in the WF. Like a common idea Adam could have preached was........

3) We know she did yell at Ghira and Kali before she ran off to stay in the WF, they could very well have told her they were going to Menagerie and asked her to come with them before she yelled at them. 1) It's logical that the "WF in Menagerie" stuff is more recent than expected. Why would a group that used to protest for Fair Treatment of Faunus go protest in the Faunusland of the world where Faunus Discrimination does not exist???

Even when they went violent, the WF seemingly cares more about dealing with people who treat Faunus "badly" than anything else. And until then, they only seemed to "convert" the Faunus citizens in the Kingdoms, the ones that had actually suffered discrimination (supposedly).

So there being WF at all in Menagerie was reasonably surprising.

2) The whole "slap in the face" is not so much common knowledge as much as an opinion. Despite it's size, Menagerie is miles better than Vacuo in practically everything but territory and the only thing it lacks is an academy and CCT.

And it still does not justify why she would speak of it with such a matter-of-fact tone. For example, I know Australia has dangerous wildlife too, from poisonous beaver-ducks to exploding trees. Doesn't mean I would say it's practically hell just based on what I read on Wikipedia or hear from others when I've never stepped foot there.

If you want to argue that she believes that because Adam/the WF indoctrinated her about it, then the same goes for basically everything she says about the Faunus Discrimination too. And as likely as it is, that's kind of irrelevant, and still speculation.

3) True......except there's 1 big problem with that: That means they didn't live in Menagerie until then, and by the time they moved there Blake was off with the WF.

Which means, she would never call Menagerie her "home".

One does not call some place "home" just because their parents live there. If you lived for years in Texas but your parents live in Boston, are you going to say Boston is your home? No, you won't, unless you have a definition of "home" so broad that it loses meaning.