Thread:Alzrius/@comment-16774229-20131031212846

I've decided that our argument has no place on the JNPR dorm thread any more, and that it's best that we continue it here.

Now, I understand your point, and I think that in the end, it will be a difference of opinion. But if you plan do this, I have some advice and warnings for you. No, you can't perfectly predict what people can and can't understand, but I would think that someone who prides themselves on their communication skills as much as you can deduce a general standard based on the pervs posts. Just as you wouldn't speak to 3rd grader the way you do to a doctor and expect them to understand you, you can't go onto foume about hormonal teens sharing a room(where most of the content is ideas for how this could work out in funny scenes) and expect them to understand your high brow analysis. Again, I understand that you're guess can't be perfect, but I think I would have thought the crowd wasn't up for that sort of thing give what came before. Of course, there were some people there who did enjoy the discussion, but I suspect you may not always be as lucky. If you were to bring this kind of discussion to a more popular thread, say “What's Going on With Juane and Pyrrha”, or any of the “Where For Here?” threads, chances are you would be met with more opposition, annoyed emoticons, and maybe even caps lock rage. That's just a guess on my part, but I've spent a good amout of time on the forums, and I that's the understanding I have of the community.

Now I understand if you disagree with me, but that's the way I see the isue. Althoe we're a speculation based comuity, the things that we discus at lacth tent to be about story, charicters, and other importent things. When we bring up less important matters(Klepto Yang, anti corporate Blake, and JNPR dorm at a time), the discussion is more tongue and cheek, and less in depth. I'm sorry, but I think I was wrong when I said that this was about being inclusive. Now that I think about it, I just feel like this sort of thing is trying to turn the forums into something their not. It's worked pretty well for you on that thread, but as you could tell by Argen's post on Maki's wall, there are some people who don't want it to go in that direction.

I apologize if this looks like an attack, but I'm worried about the wiki, and I'm worried for you to a degree.

P.S. I was looking on your contributions to see if you'd been on any other threads, and that's how I found your post on Maki's wall. Posting on someone's wall is the most personal method of communication we have here, so it's generally seen as intrusive to respond to a post on somebody else's wall. Just trying to show you the ropes. :)  