Talk:Summer Rose/@comment-73.37.249.206-20150608213458/@comment-24891101-20150609003244

We have reason to believe that that specific incident in Volume 2's stinger was actually a dream, based on accepted cues from other media. We have no reason to believe that the entire show is a dream. That's not a counterargument.

This is a good point. But presumably it will be explained later. We have little context for the departure. The theory doesn't presume to explain literally everything about Raven, merely how she relates to Yang.

We don't know what happens with the children of faunus. They may not exhibit any obvious traits. It's impossible to tell at this point.

As to the deep cover concerns (and to some degree to point two), it's possible she's not undercover, but actually just radicalized, merely willing to save her daughter's life.

Also, it's worth noting that Raven being a faunus is not entirely central to the theory, but it work well with it.

As to predictability in general, RWBY isn't good with going the non-obvious direction. Witness Penny and Blake.