Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-4830106-20140905003518/@comment-14909251-20140907035340

VedranTheII wrote: Actually, given what we’ve seen this episode, there is a possibility we misinterpreted who this song is about. Guys I’m starting to think Red Like Roses Part 2 wasn’t about Summer and Ruby…But Yang and her Mom, which fits more with the betrayal theme the daughter seems to have towards the whole ordeal given that Yang is STILL looking for her to ask questions.

And personally I’d find it pretty lame if Summer is alive, since it unintentionally devalues Papa Xiao Longs breakdown, Ruby’s blood lust AND Yangs quest at the same time, so I’m going to presume her  dead and prepare my right hand to make contact with my face if proven otherwise.

It would devalue things, which would also provide for drama. My thinking is that, if Summer really is alive, then her not returning is due to something really serious. Not suggesting she is physically unable to come back, but it may be that she feels she needs to stay away to protect people or something.