Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-38076728-20190825160615/@comment-39854843-20190826191020

No, they could still be 2 souls. Ozpin hasn't fully merged with Oscar yet. And even if they had merged, there's no reason why they couldn't be separated.

In fiction, the job of the writer is not to ask what can't be done, but to find creative ways to make something possible. That's exactly what I've just done. What you've done is invented, based on fictional scientific principle that none of us have a comprehensive understanding of, limitations that say, "no, that's not possible".

Science has no limitations, especially in a fictional world. In 1910, it was thought impossible to split an atom. Then Rutherford came along and said "no". There have always been those who say something can't be done, simply because they haven't seen it done, or because they have an incomplete understanding of the universe. Science has a funny way of proving them wrong, as it has countless times.

Moreover, I find that your theory of "Oz dying somehow" to be far less likely to happen, considering that it was God's will for Oz to permanently exist on Remnant to combat Salem. Him dying would make the God of Light fallible, which doesn't seem very godly to me.