Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-174.135.62.244-20160603201323/@comment-25936766-20160722013853

Killua102 wrote: -and put all my reasons why I think jaunexweiss not work, would be something forced, which ruin the character development of both characters and make them seem childish and generic, some father issues in common, as well as a pseudo-infatuation by jaune (for reasons that were never clear) is not a good basis for a relationship. It would not be automatically forced. It depends on how well the whole thing is written. It would not make them seem childish nor generic either. "Father issues", they don't have that in common. Jaune doesn't even seem to have any family issues. What they have in common is Legacy; they both have big names to live up to. Jaune has the Arcs, Weiss has the Schnees.

Not to mention that both went to Beacon to avoid their then-present situations. Weiss went to Beacon to have the freedom of a Huntress without her dad's vigilance. Jaune went to Beacon to be a hero instead of just an average joe.

-jaune paired with the girl he liked at the beginning (which was constantly rejected) by mainly superficial reasons would seem childish and has not matured and moved on. -"Mainly superficial reasons". If it happened in Volume 2, they would be superficial. But White Knight did not happen in Volume 2. And in future volumes, any reasons they can have for entering a romantic relationship are not going to be necesarily superficial.

-"Would seem childish and has not matured and moved on". Childish? Nope. "Not matured"? Wrong. The fact that Jaune stopped hounding all over her is proof of maturity. See, the problem was not that Jaune was interested in Weiss and tried to court her, the problem was that he was reaching into harrassment territory while at it.

And despite the hypocresy in his words, the fact that he was willing to "give up on her" so Neptune could go ahead, seeing how Weiss had shown more interest in him, is also mature. And something that noticeably improved her opinion of Jaune.

I would like the typical hero cliche, instead a human character that does not always achieve their goals and not always live up to their expectations I can't tell what exactly you're talking about. Are you saying you want a character that doesn't always achieve their goals or live up to expectations? Cause that's not the "typical hero cliche". Nor would it necesarily be the case here. (And if you meant that, don't say "instead").