Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-24177652-20140316072117/@comment-107.193.122.68-20140710025312

SilverScorcio wrote: Ok. This is going to be a long post, so bare with me here. I have a theory that Summer Rose is Cinder Fall. My 'evidence' to back this up is that they are total opisites. Lets take their names. You have Summer Rose and Cinder '''Fall. '''Fall is the opposite of summer. And then Rose and '''Cinder. '''Cinder being the opposite of a rose. Roses are organic, nature. While cinders are the aftermath of destruction. Another point is that both Cinder and Rose refer to the color red. With Summer Rose being a lighter red, and Cinder Fall being a darker red.

Ok. So there has been a lot of speculation as to who Summer Rose might be. For this theory, I have Summer as Rubys mom. And in the song Red Like Roses Part II it sings from two points of view. Ruby's from when she was younger, and her mom Summer. Now, Ruby thinks that her mom has died, and everyone tells her that her mom is ''dead. ''But, I belive that Summer just became Cinder. Because, when it is sung from the older POV, she never says that she dies. Just that she left, and wasn't able to come back. That she is shattered from anguish of not being able to pretect her daughter.

this can be compared to how Darth Vader killed Anakin. But really, anakin just became Darth Vader. And Luke was told by Obi-Wan that Anakin was killed Vader Fall isn't the opposite of summer. Winter is. Everything else works.