Board Thread:Episode Discussion/@comment-14138255-20160214165601/@comment-64.233.172.180-20160224000001

The Devil&#039;s Advocate WP wrote: 73.Anon.52 wrote: I did not forget that, I understood you the first time. The problem is that the soul transfer obviously failed to bond the two hosts before it was interrupted... what you are suggesting is that it then succeeded after Pyrrha died... like a minute+ after Amber died. The containment chamber was broken and Amber would have at least needed the glass removed prior to any miraculous resurrection, and as for "Ambyrrha" generating that much energy...I can't see a partial, dead soul mixing with the remnants of a soul whose entire living body was incinerated(indicating the aura was weak... effectively at 0 at the time) producing enough "oomph" to kick-start a body, especially one with a glass arrow placed such that the now moving heart cuts important arteries. You see, this is my issue, people are just assuming things to be true they can't be reasonably certain of unless there is clear confirmation from RT. We don't know if the transfer failed completely. All that is certain is that Cinder interrupted it as it was occurring. People are assuming the arrow would stay stuck in Amber being both irremovable and positioned so as to be unavoidably fatal thus preventing her from being revived. None of that can be stated with any certainty. They very clearly state they have no clue what could be the outcome of their Aura transfer idea or if it would even transfer the Maiden powers to Pyrrha. Certainly, they can't know how things would shake out if Amber were killed mid-transfer or if she could be fully revived with double the Aura. It is literally unprecedented in the RWBYverse so people being so certain about how it really turned out and shouting down others is just annoyingly smug.

What's even more annoying is those who are yelling that we need to accept that Pyrrah is dead when the very nature of the theory states that Pyrrah's death is what allows the possibilty for Amber to be alive. I was the first one to post the theory on this thread and it was just one of the ideas I was spit balling on how we could get a spiritual successor for Pyrrah as Rooster teeth has a habbit for making such characters when ever they trully killed of one of the main characters in Red vs. Blue. Even in that very post I mentioned it was a theory that was out there and I didn't expect people to take it too seriously.

For those who just come up with sound objections such as, "would Pyrrah have had enough aure to start a regeneration Proces when she died?," I acknowledge your sound argument and admit I'm not to sure. For those who mention the arrorw in Amber's chest I would say that that C.C. from code geass and Wolverine from the X-men movies had regeneration that caused bullets lodged in their bodies to pop right out as they healed and I bet the Doctor from Doctor Who would also be during his regeneration process.

When I spitballed Pyrrah's deathsomehow causing Amber to comeback from the dead I was fully aware that people on this forum had stated that Roosterteeth had confirmed that both Pyrrah and Roman where dead but they hadn't confirmed Amber. Futhermore while typing out the theory I felt that I was laying metaphoric flowers next to a gravemarker for Phyrrah, and that I was adding additional meaning to her sacrafice with this theory. So I'm actually offended by People who are intterepting this theory as a cheap way to bring Pyrrah back from the dead. It isn't, if anything this theory acknowledges Pyrrah is dead and tries to help people come to terms with it by saying that all that build up around her being chosen to become a fall maiden wasn't waisted and will have plot relevance later in the series. This theory is helping some people accept Pyrrah is dead so we shouldn't be shouting down those who do believe in it and are liking using it to help cope with the loss of Phyrrah.

-Defcon Deceiver.