User blog comment:Jjripper/RWBY Volume 1 Episode 1 Critique/@comment-3257939-20150605091635

You had some really good points such as how the series simply ignores common sense sometimes like how they get videos of every single thing Ruby does or why the plot forces her to be useless when she has to be.

But if I had to label the way you review, I'll say that you're one of those people who compare the it could have been better with the ''it's sh*t. Your explanations of why some things in the show are bad is to explain how you'' would have made them better. I'm sorry dude. First create your own show and then you can tell other people how to do their job. And by that I mean that you didn't take in consideration that this series has a really low budget. You're requesting a lot of things that the show can't give since RT basically grabs anyone who's available in their office.

Also, your idea of a perfect episode is one that explains everything, I'm sorry but what? Do you realize what you're asking? Dedicating an episode to explain what dust is, its colors, how it works, what is aura, how it works, what is semblance, how it works, what are faunus, why are they being discriminated, origins of mankind, grimm, etc, etc, etc. Do you realize how boring that would be? Do you think people want to sit there and listen to the rules of a fictional world? That's not how this works my friend. One cannot simply put all the info in one episode. That would make it really boring.

Again, you had some really good points and others were really bad. Next time, take in consideration the people in charge of this and don't just justify a point by saying that you dislike it. Barely dressed? Seriously? Ok, I'll go tell Yang to wear something more modest because that would go so well with her character and wouldn't make it bad characterization, would it?