Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-35199716-20190903052606/@comment-37471367-20190906231420

I’ll change it up and switch to 1-6 in place of best to worst.

V1- To be fair, it was a prototype. It was the fights that ultimately hooked me in. Ranked no. 4

V2- Better than 1. Fights are better. More coherent plot. Probably the most watched volume. Ranked no. 1

V3- No denies how great that volume was, but that’s on the second half. The only reason I don’t watch it more is obvious. Ranked No. 2

V4- One word: Boring. Just boring. Qrow v Tyrian is the only part I like to watch. Ranked no. 5

V5- Talking is for RvB. Too much inaction in the first half. Some fights are just plain poorly executed (Giving Kalia enough time to get a tray in the open when you have automatic weapons!). The exceptions are Sun v Illia and Raven v Cinder. Used WAY too much budget on character shorts and thank goodness they learned their lesson. Issues with Yang begin to surface (Forced overreacting to an ability. Seriously, it was overblown). Ranked no. 6

V6- Great start. Once again taking issue with a certain blonde being out of line, overly angsty and a bit hypocritical. Origin was great. Apathy were terrifying. I love Maria. “We get it! Pyrrha’s dead!”. Mech fight was good. Adam fights were good, but this is were issues surface. In this case, overuse of cliffhangers bleeding over from V5. And then of course, the controversy, both in and out of the show’s writers influence. Still a good volume. Ranked no. 3