Talk:Qrow Branwen/@comment-4555743-20171116223520/@comment-4010415-20171119063740

1. I'm pretty sure I'm not complicating things in the least. It's a pretty straightforward and simple line of thought.

2. Except that, when you draw a pistol and shoot a few bullets into the ceiling out of anger, you're doing it on purpose to lash out. Weiss did not mean to activate her Semblance at all. She jerked away from Jacques, she fell on the floor, and then she looked at the Boarbatusk summon as if she was wondering why that was happening. She wasn't trying to lash out, and it is not the same as drawing a pistol and firing it in anger. It just happened, and she had no control of it. It also seems out of character that Weiss would just suddenly decide to send out a summon toward an unarmed, pampered posh lady who likely didn't even have her Aura unlocked, just because she's angry with her.

3. True that it hasn't been made 100% clear if her eyes turning red is a quirk or Semblance, especially since Neo's and Klein's eyes change color for unknown reasons. Though, there is still the fact that Yang did not actually appear angry the first time her eyes turned red and she used her Semblance to break Junior's bat. It was a look of concentration, not one of anger.

It would be helpful if they would show us something that makes it clearer, like Yang using her Semblance while completely calm or clearly feeling something other than anger.