Board Thread:Speculation House/@comment-27143816-20160216033644/@comment-14909251-20160603140851

Arkantos95 wrote: I know I said I wasn't going to talk about this again, but it's going to bug me if I don't. The problem with Ambyrrha isn't that it goes directly against the word of God (only because there's no precedent set for or against it), but that it flies in the face of logic and all the shown facts.

The pod Amber was in was pierced by the arrow that impacted in her lung, and then had most of the door shattered by Amber having her power (and I assume her soul since her Aura was still coloring it), so it's highly doubtful that it could still function.

Pyrrha wasn't hooked up to anything when she got in the pod, so there's no reason to assume that Amber was hooked up to anything that could revive her from drowning in her own blood for the 10 minutes or so she'd have between getting shot and Pyrrha dying for this whole "supercharged aura" thing you keep talking about to happen.

Amber's Aura, the physical mainifestation of her sould, represented by the amber light, was ripped violently from Pyrrha and Amber alike by Cinder, so there's no reason to believe a piece would be left behind. In fact, we have no reason to believe the soul would even survive in a foreign host for any length of time.

And if a piece of her soul was still in Pyrrha, why wouldn't it have charged Pyrrha's Aura more during the fight? Pyrrha's Aura was completetly drained, and Amber's little chunk didn't do a damn thing to help if it was in there.

Then there's the issue of the fact that we're talking about two people who were horribly traumatized fused into a single body at the center of an ever-increaseing horde of soulless monstrosities hell-bent on seeking out negative emotions with no other source to look for is somehow expected to escape alive.

And none of this is mentioning the fact that she's unarmed, dressed in what amounts to rags, has somehow pulled the obsidian (read: breakable glass that can splinter and sherd up more organs) arrow out of her chest and major organs, gotten all of the blood that's filled her lung over the past few minutes out, and is somehow expected to climb up a ruined elevator shaft unnassited. And GTFO with her using Pyrrha's Semblance, becuase you're saying Amber is the dominant person here. The only reason she'd have Pyrrha's Semblance would be covenience, and that is unaccepatable.

TL;DR: This "theory", even as you have explained it, has no basis in logic or canon. It's patently ridiculous, and ther reason for this isn't stubbornness, it's logic. Much like every other ressurection theory I've hear, this one fails to impress me or give me any reason to believe it. Here's the problem: not a single fact is presented in this entire post that would go against this theory. All you have against this is speculation based on facts i.e. things we know to be canon, which is no different from my own speculation. You are just saying that your speculation is better than my speculation and that is just hubris. None of what you said is inherently more logical, just inherently more arrogant. Seriously, if anyone here can't take people presenting speculation you don't like because it goes against what you speculate in a forum specifically for speculation then you should just leave.