Talk:Semblance/@comment-70.27.60.223-20151031212444/@comment-27087951-20151104233756

@Shoddy: 1-Nonsensical doesn't mean it's a bad idea. Sometimes it's a better idea because it makes less sense. In this case: A minigun that tuns into handbag that doubles as improvised hammer. Versus, weapons of glass that shatter when hitting anything even remotely tougher than flesh. Of which, given there are Grimm tougher than Tanks, would be a lot of enemies here.

Using an Obsidian weapon is a bad idea, because it shatters easily, unless you go the Aztec route, in which case you're not using an Obsidian weapon, you are using a wooden weapon with obsidian edges.

The only thing preventing Obsidian from being useless in Remnant, is Aura used to prevent it from breaking appart with every hit. But problem: You would constantly use a lot of Aura to keep it together. With any other weapon, the Aura cost would be far lesser both in short and long term.

Just because X makes no sense, doesn't mean that it isn't a good idea (and remember, many things began making no sense). Just because Y makes more sense, doesn't mean it's a good idea either, even if by comparison.

2-Excuse me for being PoMo instead of trying to be part of this wiki's "collective mindhive". Do you want me to agree to everything you guys say here even if I don't agree?