Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24098614-20180508224452/@comment-34724302-20180525162818

73.Anon.52 wrote: Masma93 wrote: Arkantos95 wrote:

Terribleness of that last bit is debatable considering weak maidens are how you get Cinder. Killing a little girl because you deem her as weak is a terrible thing, especially if that girl trusted and cared for you. Except we know she was weak because Raven is not the only one who thought so... we have no proof of the latter at all.

Raven killed her, but we have no evidence of circumstance, had she been training her or assisting suicide any trust the young maiden may have had would have been paid in full, Raven giving her a better chance than her daughter in the first instance and actively helping her accomplish what she wanted in the latter.

As Arkantos said, even if Raven did just kill her for being weak, it was a far kinder fate than what happened to Amber, whose soul was literally torn in half, half chained to her tormentor/killer and meta-physically bleeding out... I mean seriously think about the implications... she may be unable to pass on to whatever afterlife Remnant has forever(she was at least denied it for Cinders lifetime), and even if her soul gets there it will be irreparably damaged. Kinder fate that Amber's one it doesn't matter because it still doesn't justify her killing of the Spring Maiden.